genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/AbsolvedMadman's Detransition Story

female
took hormones
regrets transitioning
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, the account does not show clear red flags of being inauthentic.

The comments display:

  • Personal, nuanced experience: The user discusses their own history with testosterone, research since age 15, and personal reasons for using informed consent.
  • Consistent, knowledgeable perspective: The views are consistent with a critical but invested insider's perspective, acknowledging both the necessity and pitfalls of transition-related care.
  • Natural language and passion: The tone is passionate and contains the frustration ("the misinformation of it all kills me") and nuanced reasoning you'd expect from a real person deeply affected by the topic.

There is no evidence suggesting this account is a bot or a bad-faith actor. The comments read as authentic expressions from someone within the detrans/desister community or a critical trans user.

About me

I started researching testosterone when I was 15 and began taking it at 18 because I was in a bad place and it felt like my only option. After two years on it, I've realized how many of the changes, like my deeper voice and body hair, are permanent. I'm frustrated that the community often shuts down honest conversations about these serious risks. I now believe medical transition should be a last resort after exploring other issues like trauma. While I don't regret my own choice, I deeply regret the culture that makes it hard to ask these important questions.

My detransition story

My whole journey with gender has been complicated, and looking back, I see a lot of things I wish I’d understood sooner. I started researching testosterone when I was 15, and I was on it for two years. I’m not detransitioning, but my perspective has really changed, especially now that I’m 20.

When I first got into the community, I was struck by how much misinformation there was, and still is. It really bothers me how testosterone is often talked about as if it’s no big deal, or that microdosing makes it completely safe and reversible. I tried to point out the permanent effects to people, but I was often shut down by my own community. It felt like wanting people to be fully informed was seen as a bad thing.

From all my research, I know that a lot of the changes from testosterone are permanent. Your voice drops and won't go back; you can get permanent bottom growth and body hair, including on your face; and male pattern baldness can be permanent. While fat and muscle might redistribute if you stop, changes to your skeleton, like your shoulder width, are forever. Hormones aren't just about appearance, either. They're crucial for your body's basic functions, like keeping your bones strong. Without the right balance long-term, you can develop serious issues like osteoporosis.

I accessed testosterone through the informed consent model because it was my only affordable option. Before hormones, I was in a really bad place, and I can't imagine going back to how I felt then. But I’ve come to realize that informed consent might not be the best system for everyone. There has to be a better balance. We moved away from extreme gatekeeping, which was awful and denied care to people who genuinely needed it, but now we’ve swung too far the other way. Medical transition should be a last step, not the first thing you try.

I strongly believe that before anyone makes permanent changes, they need to explore all other options. People should be encouraged to figure out if their feelings are truly about gender dysphoria or if they’re rooted in something else, like past trauma or body dysmorphia. There need to be more resources for that. It’s about keeping your mind in check while you’re going through this huge, life-altering process.

As for my own thoughts on gender, I don't regret taking testosterone for myself, but I have major regrets about the culture surrounding it. I regret that it’s so hard to have honest conversations about the risks and the permanence of the effects. I regret that alternatives aren’t discussed more. I benefited from HRT, but I know that’s not the case for everyone, and the lack of support for asking tough questions is a real problem.

Here is a timeline of my journey based on what I've shared:

Age Event
15 Started intensely researching testosterone and its effects.
18 Began taking testosterone via informed consent, after feeling it was my only option.
20 Reflected on my two years on testosterone and developed a more critical view of informed consent and community attitudes toward medical transition.

Top Comments by /u/AbsolvedMadman:

5 comments • Posting since November 19, 2019
Reddit user AbsolvedMadman explains irreversible and potentially reversible changes from testosterone, including voice, bottom growth, body hair, and skeletal structure.
9 pointsNov 19, 2019
View on Reddit

First and foremost, voice. Before your voice settles, which takes about 2 years, you deal with cracking. A lot. If you go off before the cracking stops, you will have cracking forever. Voice changes won't go back, but can be trained like mtf in SOME cases. Second, bottom growth. Will not go back. Body Hair changes. These may or may not go back. Hair loss can be permanent. Heavy hair growth including on the face can be permanent. It might thin out, it might not. Facial mechanization. It may go back it may not. Fat and muscle redistribution. It will probably partially go back but its a slow process and theres some changes, especially when you're young, that won't. Any changes to the skeleton, such as height or hand size, shoulder width, are pretty much permanent but they're not super common in the first place. Thats all I can think of, and I've been researching testosterone since I was 15 and on it for 2 years (not detransing, just educating myself on the community and found your post)

Reddit user AbsolvedMadman explains the historical reasons for trans activists opposing gatekeeping, the rise of the informed consent model, and why a balanced approach is needed.
7 pointsDec 4, 2019
View on Reddit

It stems from the fact that people who were trans in the past and needed to transition were gatekept for reasons such as being attracted to the "wrong" sex, being ugly (yes if you were considered unattractive as a woman you could be denied estrogen), being depressed even if that was caused by needing to transition, or just if the doctor didnt like you. The gatekeeping was so strict that it was just impossible for some people who really could have benefited from transition. So when the tides changed, the community pushed for the informed consent model (in america mostly) because they believe that gatekeeping has the potential to be abused and harm people who really need transition, and they believe adults should be capable of making their own decisions without needing to jump through hoops. I went through informed consent because I cannot afford not to, it's my only means of accessing my testosterone and I can't imagine how miserable I'd be without it (I have a pretty good idea though, given the place I was in before vs where I am now) But I do understand now, at 20, that IC maybe isnt the best model, at least not for everyone. There needs to be a balance between an hrt free for all and a system so difficult it makes people wish they were dead, but with the current american healthcare system being so expensive, IC is just some peoples only way to get there. I do agree that within the community there needs to be a larger push for medical transition being the last step you take, after you've exhausted other ways of trying to treat dysphoria, and you need to make sure what you're feeling is not rooted in trauma or dysmorphia before you medically transition. It isnt a curall and needs to stop being treated as such.

Reddit user AbsolvedMadman comments on the need for mental balance and exploring alternatives before medical transition.
4 pointsDec 30, 2019
View on Reddit

I feel that. A balance, keep your mind in check while you go through a huge life altering medical process, that works without making things hard. I think alternatives to transition should also be explored regularly, before radical body alteration. There need to be more resources for that

Reddit user AbsolvedMadman explains the risks of stopping hormones, warning that long-term hormone absence can reduce bone density and lead to osteoporosis due to their role in creating bone-healing cells (osteoblasts and osteoclasts), and advises consulting multiple doctors first.
3 pointsNov 19, 2019
View on Reddit

Hormones are pretty important to many functions in your body, i would 100% talk to several doctors, endocrinologists, etc before making the choice. I dont have much education on the subject, but I did study forensic anthropology and did specific research into some resources about the effect of hormone on bones. Hormones are responsible for creating osteoplasts and osteoblasts, essentially the things that heal your bones when they break. Without hormones for a long period of time your bone density is likely to go down which can lead to osteoporosis, which means they can break easier. I'd be very cautious.

Reddit user AbsolvedMadman comments on the misinformation within the trans community about testosterone, noting they are often shut down for trying to educate that its effects are serious and not easily reversible.
3 pointsNov 19, 2019
View on Reddit

I've noticed this quite a bit myself, the everpresent idea that testosterone is reversable or not that big of a deal, or that microdosing will lessen the effects. The misinformation of it all kills me, and when I do try to educate, I've been repeatedly shut down by MY OWN "community,". Like telling someone testosterone isnt something to be taken lightly is a bad thing smh