This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it's a bot or inauthentic.
The user shares a detailed, personal narrative of starting transition at 19 and detransitioning around 24, including specific grievances with their therapist and the online trans community. The language is nuanced, emotionally consistent with a detransitioner's experience, and shows internal reflection, all of which are difficult to fake convincingly.
About me
I started identifying as trans at 16, driven by puberty discomfort and low self-esteem. An online community and a therapist pressured me with the idea that medical transition was my only option to avoid suicide. I took testosterone for five years before realizing living as a trans man was exhausting and restrictive, not freeing. I stopped hormones and began to detransition, and now my dysphoria is nearly gone as I've worked through my other issues. I'm now focused on living my life in peace, away from that community, and accepting the permanent changes from testosterone.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender started when I was a teenager. I was 16 when I first came out as trans. Looking back, I think a lot of my feelings were tied up in puberty discomfort. I hated the changes happening to my body, especially developing breasts; it felt wrong and foreign to me. I was also struggling with a lot of other things, like depression and really low self-esteem. I didn't feel good about myself at all.
The online community I was in at the time was a huge influence. It felt like a safe space at first, but it became an echo chamber. I was surrounded by people who all believed the same thing: that if you had these feelings, you were trans, and transition was the only way to avoid suicide. This idea was reinforced by a therapist I saw, who told my parents that I would kill myself if they didn't affirm my new identity. I didn't find out she had said that until much later, and I'm still angry about it. I can't think of any other area of mental health where a professional would present such an extreme, dualistic choice. It felt like emotional blackmail and it completely removed any other option for exploring what I was feeling.
I started taking testosterone when I was 19. For a while, it felt like it was helping. The physical changes made my body dysmorphia feel a little quieter. But as time went on, the reality of living as a trans person set in. It was exhausting. By the time I was 24, I realized I couldn't do it anymore. It felt like my life was becoming smaller and more restricted, not freer. I was constantly anxious, walking on eggshells, and the online community I had once relied on became unbearable. They were so dogmatic, treating any question or doubt as an act of violence.
I stopped hormones and began to detransition. It was a process of stepping back and untangling everything. A big part of it was realizing that I had stopped caring about my gender so much. The intense dysphoria I had felt is nearly gone now. I think a lot of my drive to transition was a form of escapism—from my body, from my insecurities, and from other problems I didn't know how to deal with.
I do have some regrets. I regret not having a therapist who would have helped me explore my depression, self-esteem, and discomfort without immediately jumping to medical transition. I regret the influence the online community had on me and the fear-based messaging that surrounded everything.
Now, I believe that feminine men and masculine women exist and that's perfectly okay. People should be able to wear what they want and act how they want without it meaning they have to change their entire identity or body. I try to avoid the online trans community now because I find the environment too stressful. It's sad, but I need to protect my own peace.
I don't know if I'll ever fully look like a typical female again because of the long-term effects of testosterone, and that's something I just have to live with. My main goal now is to just live my life, away from all the noise and pressure.
Age | Event |
---|---|
16 | Came out as transgender. |
19 | Started hormone therapy (testosterone). |
24 | Stopped testosterone and began to detransition. Realized I could not live as a trans person anymore. |
Top Comments by /u/AltCam1:
One of the things I will never forgive is my therapist telling my parents I was going to kill myself if they didn't completely affirm me. Same with the trans community, at least online, for spreading the idea that it's literally suicide or transition. I 'came out' at 16 and started HRT at 19.
I had no idea my therapist told this to my parents until a while after I started my transition. Even while I was on hormones, it struck me as completely inappropriate. I can't think of another mental health treatment that gave such dualistic choices.
There has to be a better way of exploring these issues.
I would avoid the online trans community. I've found that most of them are young (not that I am not) and are dogmatic about their beliefs. They've been conditioned to see any slight pushback as transphobia and violence. It's really sad, but after I detransitioned and started stepping out of that mindset more, I've discovered a lot (not all) of online trans people I talked to were unbearable to be around. Walking on eggshells all the time.
At around 24. I found, among other things, that I stopped caring about my gender so much. Also came to the realization that I couldn’t live as a trans person anymore, as it was unreasonably restricting my life.
However, my dysphoria is nearly gone now.
exhausting to still have the trans community heavily in my awareness
This is one thing that kinda runs through my head a lot. Part of me really wants to continue stepping away from trans stuff, but on the other hand, I don't want to count anyone out because of who they are, especially if they really click with me. I guess I would have to talk to the person I may consider dating before I can know for sure.
I think the main point they were making is that a lot of people who went through extensive transition-related treatment will sometimes not 'pass' as their birth sex even after detransition. I've seen some detrans women, for example, who were on T for so long that even after being off appear more like men. So that in real life, they may be treated the same as a non-passing trans woman and face the same fears/discrimination they may endure.
Feminine boys and men exist out there. From what I understand, it seems like you're worried about experimenting with your presentation because people may assume you're trans?
I would dress in what makes you feel comfortable. I'm really not sure if the average person out there is going to tell you that you must be trans based on that. Of course, people can sometimes view feminine guys as a bit odder.