This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic.
The user's narrative is highly specific, emotionally consistent, and reflects the complex, often painful, personal experience of a desister (someone who stopped social transition). The comments detail personal trauma, social isolation, loss of friends, body image issues, and nuanced critiques of trans and LGBT communities that are common and deeply felt within the detrans/desister community. The language is natural, with personal anecdotes and variations in tone that are difficult to fake.
About me
I started socially transitioning as a teenager because I was deeply uncomfortable with my female body and found intense acceptance in online trans communities. I lived as a guy for four years before realizing my desire to transition was rooted in trauma and a need to belong, not a true male identity. When I stopped, I lost almost all my friends, which was isolating but forced me to find people who accepted the real me. I still struggle with my body and plan to have surgery for my own comfort, not to fit any label. Now I know my discomfort didn't mean I was born in the wrong body, and I'm just a woman who doesn't conform.
My detransition story
My whole journey with this started when I was a teenager. I was really uncomfortable with my body, especially when I developed a large chest. It caused me a lot of physical pain on top of the mental distress. I didn't like being a girl and I felt like I didn't fit in. I spent a lot of time online and ended up in social circles with a lot of other young trans people. It felt like I had finally found a place where I belonged, and the acceptance I got from them was really intense. I came to believe that I was trans and started socially transitioning. I lived as a guy for about four years.
My mom wouldn't let me start hormones, which in hindsight was probably a good thing. After those four years, I started to really question everything. I realized that a big part of my desire to transition was rooted in childhood trauma. I also saw that a huge number of people in these spaces, including me, were neurodivergent or autistic. I think for a lot of us, it wasn't about a deep-seated gender identity, but about not fitting in, wanting that sense of community, and not presenting our gender in a way that satisfied other adults.
I decided to step back from the trans activist circles and the online groups. I told myself I would just dress and act how I liked, and if the dysphoria came back, I could always pursue medical transition later. But a funny thing happened once I disconnected from that environment: my dysphoria lessened a lot. It didn't completely go away—I still don't particularly like being female and I still hate my breasts—but it became much more manageable.
When I desisted, I lost almost all of my friends. They were mostly from queer groups, and they took it as a betrayal or thought I was giving in to transphobia. It was incredibly isolating and scary to be suddenly alone, but it forced me to go out and find new friends who didn't know me from before. It was better to be myself alone than to be someone else with everybody else. Even now, some people who knew me then will ask why I still look and act like a guy if I'm not trans anymore. It's frustrating because it feels like they'd rather I be a man than a woman who is just non-conforming.
I'm bisexual, and I've come to see that being gay or bi is entirely different from being trans, even though they get lumped together. One is about who you love, and the other is about who you are. I think the idea that if you question your gender you must be trans is ridiculous. It puts so much pressure on people.
I don't regret exploring my identity, but I do have some regrets about the whole process. I regret how quickly everything moved and how there was no real therapy or deep questioning encouraged. They'll let just about anyone start hormones without really digging into the reasons why. I regret the friends I lost and the time I spent living as someone I wasn't entirely sure about. I still struggle with my chest and I plan to have a reduction or full removal for my own comfort, and that sometimes makes me question if I was right to desist. But overall, I know I made the right choice for me by stepping back. My thoughts on gender now are that it's a lot more complicated than we're led to believe, and for some people, like me, discomfort with your body or your role in society doesn't always mean you were born in the wrong one.
Age | Year | Event |
---|---|---|
15 | 2017 | Started socially transitioning after joining online trans communities. Lived as a guy. |
19 | 2021 | Began to desist after realizing my transition was influenced by trauma and social circles. Disengaged from trans communities. |
19 | 2021 | Lost most of my friends after desisting. |
20 | 2022 | Continued to live as a desisted female, but with a non-conforming appearance. Still experience discomfort with my chest. |
Top Comments by /u/Any_Independence9453:
Honestly once I desisted I got a lot of that whole "why do you still look and act like a guy even if you're not trans anymore" and I think it's mostly lgbt activists that tend to be this way. Find friends who didn't know you before you desisted and you won't have to deal with much of this.
I'm bi and I still don't particularly like being female so it's a bit different but It frustrates me how much some people would prefer we be men than non conforming women.
Honestly the idea that only trans people question their gender so if you question your gender you must be trans, it's so ridiculous. Replace trans with queer and it's the same thing but somehow more offensive. Not to mention that I really don't think lgb issues really align with trans issues. We want very different things.
I definitely think a large part of it is social. And as far as these kids go, I remember seeing something about 50 percent of kids at a particular clinic were neuro divergent or autistic. So I think it largely minors who don't have any kind of gender dysphoria, want the love bombing that comes with being in trans circles, and also don't nessesarily present their gender to adults satisfaction are way more at risk of regretting transition.
I kinda went thru the same kinda thing when I was about 4 years out(social only cause my mom wouldn't let me do hrt) I kinda came to the conclusion that I would act and dress ect how I liked and if the dysphoria persisted I'd go do the medical stuff. But honestly after disengaging with my more trans activist and trans teen circles, my dysphoria has lessened a lot. If you need a shoulder or smth, dm me
I also realized I was transitioning because of childhood trauma, and I can't tell you how many friends I've lost. Simply desisting or detransitioning is so isolating, but even more so when it's related to trauma/abuse. I worry a lot about my younger trans cousin hating me because after 4 years of mostly socializing with other young trans people I know what they say about desisted/detrans people.
It really your choice to tell people or not but while people might assume you're a guy off the way you look, most won't tell you that you should transition when you correct them. I can't give great advice on family if that's more of the problem though.
Being trans is entirely different than being gay. Although we get lumped together because people used to lump them together cause they're both often gender conforming. So I think people don't stop being gay. Plus they'll let any old person start horrmones without therapy or an actual diagnosis.
I lost most of my friends when I desisted. I think this was because I was mostly involved in 'queer' groups and they thought that I was desiring because of transphobia or something. I ended up being forced to find new groups and I made more friends. It's scary and shit but I still think it's better to be yourself alone than be someone else with everybody else.
I'm in basicly the same boat. Always had a large chest. So there's the physical pain to add onto the mental. I plan to have either get them removed or reduced. I can't much give any advice on getting over it. Honestly these feelings make me question if I was right to desist.