This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic.
There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor. The comments display a consistent, emotionally nuanced, and specific personal narrative that aligns with the known experiences of detransitioners/desisters, including complex motivations for transition and feelings of betrayal within the community. The language is natural and the story evolves over time with new reflections.
About me
I never felt right as a girl, especially after puberty, and identifying as non-binary gave me relief from that pressure. I started testosterone after a breakup with a trans woman, partly to stay connected to her world and the community I had found. That community encouraged medical changes but was hostile to any questioning and dismissed my concerns about permanent effects. I took testosterone for a year and now have to live with a permanently deepened voice and health worries. I see now my journey was really about a deep need to belong, and I regret the permanent changes I made for a group that ultimately abandoned me.
My detransition story
My whole journey with this started because I never felt right in my body as a girl. When I went through puberty, I was told that all girls develop wide hips and a defined waist, but my body never did that. I felt abnormal and broken, like my body was wrong. Identifying as non-binary gave me a huge sense of relief because it felt like there was no longer a standard I had to live up to. My hips weren't weirdly small for a girl anymore; they were just my hips.
A lot of my transition was influenced by the people I was with. I was in a relationship with a trans woman, and I came out as non-binary partly because I wanted to feel closer to her. After we broke up, I started testosterone. Looking back, I think a part of me did it to stay in her world and maybe even to get her attention. I thought a drastic change would make me feel connected to that life again.
I also gained a whole new community and friends by transitioning. I had a new partner who was really into me being a 'boygirl'. For a while, it felt like I finally belonged somewhere. But that community could be a really difficult place. I once tried to talk about autogynephilia (AGP) with an ex, and the reaction was horrible. I was made to feel like the most evil, transphobic person alive for even mentioning it, even though I was seeing some of those patterns in people who were mistreating me.
I started to feel like there was a real problem with how trans women and other people born male treated those of us born female. They would often encourage messing around with hormones, making it sound like testosterone was harmless and completely reversible. They didn't seem to recognize or care that it's different for us and the effects are permanent. My male friends were always the ones to flippantly suggest surgery whenever I expressed any mild discontent with my body, and if I objected, they'd dismiss it as internalized transphobia.
I stayed on testosterone for a year, and now I have to live with the consequences. I've permanently fucked up my voice. I'm also worried about potential long-term health complications I might not even know about yet. I did all of this because I wanted to be loved and accepted by a group of people who ended up abandoning me anyway. The cognitive dissonance of realizing all this was brutal.
Leaving that world behind was hard. I tried to move on and even joined a female-only discussion group, which felt like a positive step. But then that group started getting harassed and infiltrated by trans rights activists, which was incredibly frustrating. It felt like I couldn't escape the politics and pressure anywhere.
Now, looking back, I see my transition wasn't really about having a male brain in a female body. It was about deep-seated issues: discomfort with puberty, low self-esteem, and a desperate need to belong somewhere. I was trying to escape my own body and my problems. I absolutely have regrets. I regret taking testosterone and permanently changing my body for a community that wasn't healthy for me. I don't regret exploring my identity, but I deeply regret the medical steps I took.
My thoughts on gender now are that it's a lot more complicated than I was led to believe. For me, it was more about social and personal issues than an innate identity. I'm just trying to live as myself now, without any labels, and deal with the permanent changes I made.
Age | Event |
---|---|
18 | Started identifying as non-binary, felt relief from puberty-related body discomfort. |
20 | Was in a relationship with a trans woman; came out as non-binary partly to feel closer to her. |
21 | Started testosterone injections after the relationship ended, hoping to stay connected to that world and gain attention. |
22 | Stopped testosterone after one year. Realized I had permanently deepened my voice and potentially caused other health issues. |
Top Comments by /u/AsleepMathematician:
I feel like there is specifically an issue with AMAB trans people not really giving a shit about the wellbeing of AFAB trans people. They’re always the ones encouraging girls who are questioning to fuck around with their hormones and make out that it’s harmless and reversible because that’s their experience, they don’t recognise or care that T is different. It was also always my AMAB friends who would flippantly suggest surgery whenever I expressed mild discontent about my body, and would dismiss my objections as transphobia
the cognitive dissonance is the worst. i broached the subject of agp once with an ex and when everyone found out I was made to feel like I was the most evil transphobic person alive and was told that I was making trans women feel unsafe (the same trans women who were mistreating me and repeatedly crossing my boundaries, mind you)
I dated a trans woman a few years back. They used dating apps to flirt with people behind my back and blamed it on their dysphoria when caught. They admitted they had a compulsive need for sexual validation almost like an addiction, but I was the bad guy for suggesting they might be AGP
I feel you. I didn't realise these were my motivations at the time but I came out as non-binary while I was in a relationship with a trans girl because I wanted to be closer to her. I got on testosterone after we broke up because I wanted to stay in her world and thought a drastic change would get her attention. I stayed on it for a year because I gained friends and community by transitioning, plus a new partner who liked that I was a 'boygirl'. Now I've fucked up my voice and potentially my health all because I wanted to be loved by a bunch of people who ended up abandoning me anyway
My vulva shape yes but also just my body shape. Because I never developed wide hips or a defined waist, as I was told that all girls did during puberty, I felt abnormal and broken. When I started indentifying as non-binary it offered me relief from this anguish because now there was no standard for how my body should look. I no longer had weirdly small hips for a girl, they were just my hips
I don't have any advice but I relate. I had a really rough few years in the trans community and I was so ready to put it all behind me and start fresh. I started going to a monthly female-only discussion group, which felt like a huge step forward, only to discover that the group is being harassed and infiltrated by TRAs. I really wish they'd fuck off tbh.