This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the comments provided, the account does not show clear red flags of being inauthentic.
The user demonstrates:
- Deep, consistent medical knowledge across multiple comments and years, suggesting a professional background (e.g., in endocrinology or general medicine).
- A consistent, nuanced perspective that acknowledges the lack of research on detransition while providing detailed biological explanations.
- A compassionate and advisory tone that aligns with a knowledgeable individual trying to help others in a difficult situation.
There is no evidence of bot-like behavior, scripted responses, or a contradictory agenda. The account appears to be a real person with significant expertise.
About me
I was born female and my discomfort started with puberty, when I hated the development of my breasts. I was influenced by online communities and began a social and then medical transition, taking testosterone and having top surgery. My underlying depression and anxiety never went away, and it was non-affirming therapy that finally helped me address my OCD and internalized homophobia. I stopped testosterone and now deeply regret my permanent surgeries and infertility. I am a detransitioned female, learning to accept that I was a confused young woman trying to escape from myself.
My detransition story
My journey with transition and detransition was complicated and rooted in a lot of confusion about myself. I was born female, and from a young age, I felt a deep discomfort with my body, especially when I hit puberty. I hated the development of my breasts; it felt like a betrayal of my body and made me incredibly anxious. I now see that a lot of my feelings were tied to a general discomfort with growing up and the changes that came with it, rather than a true issue with my sex.
I spent a lot of time online in communities that celebrated transition as the solution for any kind of body discomfort or unhappiness. I was influenced by friends and people I met online who were also exploring their gender identities. Looking back, I think I was using the idea of being trans as a form of escapism from my depression and very low self-esteem. I was diagnosed with OCD and anxiety, and I now believe that a lot of my fixation on gender was a manifestation of that, a way to try and control something when I felt so out of control.
I started my social transition first, asking people to use a new name and male pronouns. It felt freeing at first, like I had finally found an answer. That led me to pursue medical transition. I took testosterone for several years. The changes were significant, and for a while, I felt like I was on the right path. I even got top surgery and had a double mastectomy. I was convinced this was what I needed to be happy.
But the underlying issues never went away. The depression and anxiety were still there, just masked by the focus on transition. I eventually started therapy that wasn't solely focused on affirming a trans identity. This non-affirming therapy was actually what helped me the most. It allowed me to unpack my trauma and my OCD tendencies. I began to realize that my desire to transition was heavily influenced by internalized homophobia; I was a lesbian who was uncomfortable with that reality and thought becoming a man would make my life easier. I also had a problem with porn that shaped unrealistic ideas about bodies and sexuality.
I made the difficult decision to detransition. I stopped taking testosterone. I have serious regrets about my transition, particularly about having top surgery. I am now infertile, and that is a profound loss that I grieve. I have to live with the permanent changes to my body, and some days that is very hard. My thoughts on gender now are that it is a social concept that can sometimes cause more harm than good when medical intervention is pursued without addressing the underlying mental health issues first. I don't believe I was ever truly trans; I was a confused young woman trying to escape from herself.
Age | Event |
---|---|
13 | Started puberty; began to feel intense discomfort and hatred toward my developing breasts. |
19 | Heavily influenced by online communities and friends; began social transition with a new name and male pronouns. |
21 | Started testosterone therapy. |
23 | Underwent top surgery (double mastectomy). |
26 | Began non-affirming therapy that addressed underlying OCD, anxiety, and trauma. |
27 | Realized transition was a mistake; stopped taking testosterone. |
28 | Accepted my identity as a detransitioned female and a lesbian. |
Top Comments by /u/AssignedSnail:
Hi Friend, a tiny caveat I haven't seen mentioned: cats are unable to metabolize minoxidil, and even a tiny amount of topical minoxidil such as from laying on your pillow can be dangerous for them. Oral minoxodil avoids this problem, but causes increased body hair as well. A bonus for some people, but maybe not for folks on this sub in particular.
Thanks for saying this. It feels like there's a eugenicist bent to the conversation around this kid, which feels like it should be alarming to anyone who is queer-adjacent.
Most people with CP have no marked cognitive disability. Perhaps twice as many don't as do. Just among the subset of people with CP who have difficulty speaking, a significant number will be related to muscle control issues rather than cognition, and even among those with language disorders there may not be other marked cognitive disability... Just someone who can't speak
You know what they say: Two is a coincidence, three is a pattern. Have you or your children had your endogenous testosterone levels checked?
Knowing you have higher than usual endogenous testosterone for someone assigned female at birth does not confirm that someone is or isn't trans. But it could help you understand why this issue seems to run in your family.
Cis men post circumcision experience desensitization compounded by keratinization. I.e., protected, hyper-sensitive mucosa becomes more like normal skin.
I'm not aware of any research on this in trans men or detransitioned women, but thought I'd point out the potential parallels.
Hi there! Testosterone per se does not increase the risk of uterine cancer. Excess testoterone, on the other hand, is converted by the body to estrogen. If your body is not also making progesterone at normal female levels, the estrogen can increase your uterine cancer risk.
All that said, your risk is low. Only one case reported, ever, in scientific journals. See this article from UCSF. (Edit: Endometrial cancer is the most common type of uterine cancer, and what people are usually referring to.)
If you're worried about it, folks who keep more moderate T levels would be at less hypothetical risk than folks with higher T levels, because it's the high levels that trigger aromatization. Same idea for folks who avoid the once a month spikes by doing weekly shots or using patches or gel. But this is not a "you must do this" sort of surgery. And even if it were, you could still opt out.
Your body, your choice.
Please let me know if I can be of further help.
Approximately 1 in 10 American women have a condition called PCOS, often undiagnosed. The most obvious symptoms is abnormal, irregular, or heavy periods. Among trans men, this may be as high as 1 in 2. That's not to say that having PCOS invalidates anyone's trans identity--the only reason we don't consider it an intersex condition is because it is so common. However, you asked if something else might be "bubbling" underneath, and PCOS could be almost literally bubbling.
I can't give you medical advice over the internet, just information, but it sounds like you are on the right track here. Someone who has been without a period and starts bleeding unexpectedly should talk to their doctor. It sounds like you've already done that, but talking to them again about this specific risk couldn't hurt.
You're probably thinking of spironolactone? It's generally not damaging to kidney health. It does have hormone-like (or perhaps better put, anti-hormone-like) affects on the kidneys, in a way that causes you to pee out more salt + more water. So you're definitely not imagining that there is an affect. It just isn't a particularly dangerous one. I get it being scary, though. My husband gave away one of his kidneys, and while I'm super proud of him, I'm also like, dude you only have two! It wasn't exactly extra!
Now, on the cancer part, you actually might be on to something. It hasn't been linked to cancer in humans, but it has in animal models. So, that's always something to consider. Most folks aren't aware. The general medical consensus is, "don't use it unless you need it." What exactly it means to need it comes down to what alternatives are available for a given indication in a given patient. Sometimes, it is still the best option. It's used far more for cis patients than for trans folks.
"You can only ban safe abortion."
As a medical professional, I have concerns about the amount of DIY in the trans community. If the gatekeepers shut the gate entirely, folks will go around back and climb over the wall. Plenty are already doing it.
Despite the rampant and ultimately justified rumors of his own issues vis-a-vis memory loss and confusion, President Reagan suffered a near-fatal lack of interest in or empathy for people suffering from mental health problems. And I mean literally near-fatal, given that he was almost assassinated by a man with schizophrenia.
One particular pet project of his, both as California governor and later as U.S. president, was the de-funding of programs to proactively treat mental health disorders, shifting the emphasis from social safety nets and mental heathcare to jails and law enforcement. I'll note here that this approach did not save taxpayers any money. But what is more relevant to your situation is that community programs for the promotion of mental health and prevention and treatment of disorders, part of the Mental Health Systems Act of 1980, were repealed at Reagan's urging in 1981.
There are lots of ways to answer your question, but I think this one might be best: What if, instead of two years after you inquired about HRT, you'd been able to get mental healthcare preventatively two years before? If care were more readily accessible, I don't think you'd be here to ask this question. The ACA (aka Obamacare) helped, to be sure. But the 30+ years we lost to Reagan are time we can't get back. I'm sorry for how it's affected you.