genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Bottled_Penguin's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 17 -> Detransitioned: 24
female
took hormones
regrets transitioning
serious health complications
now infertile
puberty discomfort
only transitioned socially
autistic
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, the account appears to be authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user presents a highly detailed, consistent, and emotionally resonant personal narrative about desisting after a social transition due to a severe PCOS diagnosis and subsequent hysterectomy. The story is specific, medically plausible, and recounted with visceral emotion and personal regret that would be difficult to fabricate consistently over many months. The user also expresses a nuanced, albeit critical, perspective that aligns with a genuine desister who feels harmed by their experience.

About me

I started feeling like I was trans as a teenager, right after I got my first period, and I was completely convinced I was a guy. My mom was skeptical and insisted I see a doctor, which I finally did just to get her to stop, and I was diagnosed with a severe hormonal condition that was flooding my body with testosterone. After a difficult fight to get the necessary surgery, I had a hysterectomy and the moment I woke up, my dysphoria was completely gone. I regret not listening to my mom sooner, as the whole experience caused my family a lot of unnecessary pain. Now, I'm just myself, living without labels and grateful that we found the real medical cause for my distress.

My detransition story

My whole journey started when I was a teenager. I felt like I was trans and I was completely convinced of it. This was around the time I got my first period, and that’s when everything started to feel wrong. I came out and socially transitioned at 17. I dressed masculine and wanted to be seen as a guy. I even wanted to start hormones.

But my mom was incredibly skeptical. She kept pushing back and insisted that I see a doctor. She knew something else was going on. I fought her on it for years, absolutely certain I was right. I was stubborn and just wanted to be left alone to transition.

Finally, just to get her to stop bothering me, I agreed to see an endocrinologist. That one appointment changed everything. I was diagnosed with a severe case of PCOS. It was so bad that my ovaries had basically stopped producing estrogen and were flooding my body with testosterone instead. My body was giving me a natural form of HRT, and it was completely screwing with my head, making me believe I was a man.

The only way to fix it was with surgery. I had to fight for it. Doctors were more concerned about my potential to have kids than my actual health, and I had to threaten to perform the surgery myself with a butcher knife before anyone would take my pain seriously. At 24, I had a total hysterectomy and oophorectomy—everything was removed. The surgeon said it was the most severe case he’d ever seen.

The moment I woke up from that surgery, it was like a fog lifted. My dysphoria was just gone. I instantly felt like a woman again. I’ve been on estrogen ever since to manage my hormones, and it’s made me feel so much better.

Looking back, I do regret socially transitioning. Not because of the identity itself, but because it caused so much unnecessary drama and pain for my family, especially my grandparents who were near the end of their lives. I regret not listening to my mom and getting help sooner. It would have saved me and everyone around me so much agony.

My thoughts on gender have completely changed. I think the world has become way too focused on putting everything into boxes—if a girl likes boy things, she must be trans, and vice versa. It feels like we’ve gone backwards to having very rigid definitions of masculine and feminine. I stopped labeling myself. I’m not masculine-presenting or feminine-presenting; I’m just me. I do what I want. I can be working at my forge doing blacksmithing one minute and then gushing over pink glitter and crocheting the next. I’m a chameleon. Life is too short to worry about what box you fit into; you just have to do what makes you happy.

I’m autistic, but I don’t believe that was related to my desire to transition. It was purely a hormonal issue caused by my PCOS. The whole experience has made me very skeptical, and I believe that anyone considering transition should have a healthy dose of skepticism and get a full medical workup to rule out any underlying conditions. Hormones can do some really screwy things to your brain.

I also have some strong feelings about the trans community itself. I think it can be a real echo chamber where any criticism or skepticism is shut down. I’ve seen people get pushed into identities they might not have otherwise had, and I’ve lost friends over it. I’ve also been chased out of women’s spaces and the lesbian community because my concerns, as a survivor of SA, about safety and comfort were dismissed. It feels like only one side gets to talk, and it’s hurtful.

Overall, I’m just glad I found the real root of my problem. It was a medical condition, not an identity one. I’m grateful every day that my mom was stubborn and got me the help I really needed.

Age Event
14 First period; PCOS symptoms began.
17 Socially transitioned, began living as male.
24 Diagnosed with severe PCOS by an endocrinologist.
24 Underwent a total hysterectomy/oophorectomy; dysphoria resolved immediately.
24 Began taking estrogen.
Now Over a decade later, living without dysphoria and rejecting gender labels.

Top Comments by /u/Bottled_Penguin:

45 comments • Posting since March 13, 2024
Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains why she left the lesbian community, citing the pressure to accept "girl dick" as a lesbian and describing it as a lesbophobic takeover that dismisses the feelings of SA survivors.
87 pointsJul 24, 2024
View on Reddit

I've completely left the lesbian community because of it. I want nothing to do with them anymore. The second they started pushing the idea of girl dick and that you have to suck it up and fuck them, I peaced out. I'm an SA survivor, but it's obvious my feelings don't matter.

They completely lack self awareness and shove acceptance down our throats. A lot of the women that weren't comfortable have left those spaces. It does feel like whenever a new lesbian space opens up to hopefully give us some breathing room, it gets bombarded and smashed into submission. Then trans women take over. Still thinking like misogynistic and lesbophobic men, women should submit to them and be good girls about it.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains how modern gender ideology mirrors 1950s thinking by suggesting that any deviation from gendered interests, like a girl liking "boy" things, is seen as proof of being trans.
76 pointsMay 28, 2024
View on Reddit

It's like a toy aisle, one for boys, one for girls. If a girl likes something in the boys aisle, they must be trans. If a boy likes something in the girls aisle, they must be trans. Or at the very least, not conforming to current gender views.

It certainly feels like the world around us right now. If you don't 100% conform to a single gender, you must be something else. The fact they're accusing someone of being trans is pretty darn gross. We've been bombed right back to the 50s with this kind of ideology.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains her severe, debilitating experience with menstruation and ovarian cysts to challenge those who invalidate women's health struggles.
69 pointsJul 1, 2024
View on Reddit

Sometimes it feels like I read things that come from crazy people on here. That's just straight up delusional as hell to even think about. How could you even start to do the mental gymnastics to convince yourself that believing you have any say about the subject? This is just bonkers.

Okay, let me just astral project my experience onto them.

You wake up throwing your guts up every month, and eating is touch and go. Even keeping liquids down is hard.

You lose so much blood you have anemia, so you have to take iron just so you don't die. Guess how hard this is when you can't keep anything in your stomach?

Your cramps are so bad you can pass out from the pain alone, and your doctors won't give you anything to help. The cysts on your ovaries like to pop and it feels like being stabbed repeatedly, and the knife is being twisted.

You're prescribed ever birth control pill available at one point or another. They don't help, if anything they make it worse. You also go from being a fit, 110 pounds to 200+ because of the meds in a matter of months.

This hell doesn't last for 4 - 5 days, it lasts for two weeks. You're PMSing almost all the time, so you're basically insane.

You have to fight for a year to get something done about it, going to see multiple gynecologists, getting dismissed because it's more important you be a human incubator.

Although you do have to threaten to kill yourself to get the point across that you're suffering, and you mean it. Your case is eventually discovered to be so bad that at 24, you get a radical hysterectomy. Everything is removed because it's a cancer risk. This is done during a time when it was basically unheard of doing on someone so young.

Is this really what they want? Do they actually think that they have anything even close to an opinion on the matter? The sheer audacity of these people. I just... I can't... This actually really pisses me off. I don't have anything nice to say anymore. I'm just so floored at the idea.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains why detransitioners are seen as the enemy by some trans communities, citing a black-and-white worldview that rejects nuance and criticism.
57 pointsDec 15, 2024
View on Reddit

A really black and white way of thinking. If you're with them, you're a good person. If you're not 100% on board, you're a bad person. There's no grey area in this world.

We're seen as the enemy because we started seeing shades of grey to the whole thing, the nuances, the criticism, the good and the bad.

This is very much a culture that needs to be more willing to hear criticism and not put their fingers in their ears and declare any decention as people wanting them dead. Until that happens, we're going to be seen as the bad guys.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains how medical issues and "tomboy erasure" led her to mistakenly believe she was trans, criticizing the push to label gender-nonconforming people.
40 pointsJun 15, 2024
View on Reddit

I feel this so hard. I partially thought I was trans because I did more masculine things. Once I got my underlying medical issues sorted out, I didn't want to be a man anymore. I wanted to just be my tomboy self. Tomboy erasure is definitely a thing, and anyone skirting gender norms have a line of nutcases all too ready to push their personal views onto them. We've basically walked backwards to the 50's. During my childhood there was a push to break down gender norms, now we've gone back to a very rigid definition of masculine and feminine. Go outside of it, and boom, you're trans.

Anecdotally, I got into blacksmithing/welding/metal fabrication, I had people trying to convince me I'm trans. It was all bullshit, they saw one side of me. When they saw me doing things like working on my car, metalwork, welding, and fishing, and dressing masculine while doing so, I would get the egg cracker crowd on my ass.

On the flip side, I'm feminine as hell. My favorite color is pink and it's everywhere in my home. I have a doll collection, wear pretty clothes, paint my nails, and basically am froofy as fuck. So I'm a chameleon of sorts lol.

The kind of people who try and get you to believe you're anything but yourself, are shit lords. They're the type of person that needs to be blocked online, and burn that bridge IRL.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) comments on a detransitioner's recovery, advocating for any spiritual path that brings peace and community, citing their own experience with druidism and shamanism.
38 pointsMay 29, 2024
View on Reddit

Oh boy, this comment section is wild. You look great OP, and I'm glad you overcame your dysphoria and are in a better place.

People turn to higher powers for whatever reason they wish. If it helps them be a better person, or gives them peace, it's fine. I personally turned to druidism, with a mix of shamanism, and it helped me greatly. The fallen angel Crocell has been a huge help in healing as well.

Point being, a lot of us turn to a place that can teach us to live happier lives. Sometimes joining a community and feeling included can make people feel more grounded and better.

However the OP found a way to heal is fine by me. Let's just be happy someone is living without the dark cloud of dysphoria hanging over their heads.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains how her mother's skepticism led to a PCOS diagnosis and the end of her dysphoria.
35 pointsJun 17, 2024
View on Reddit

If someone you love, trust their judgement, and only wants what's best for you, listen to them.

My mother was incredibly skeptical about me transitioning. For the years I was socially trans, she constantly pushed back. When my face broke out really bad to the point I didn't leave the house anymore, she took me to an endocrinologist. She must have suspected I had something more going on. That one appointment led to me being diagnosed with severe PCOS, I was getting too much testosterone and my body wasn't making enough estrogen. That same year I had a radical hysterectomy and instantly my dysphoria was gone. I have my caring, amazing mother and her skeptical view to thank for it.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains that PCOS is not an intersex condition, arguing she was born a woman and developed it later, requiring surgical ovary removal.
30 pointsAug 28, 2024
View on Reddit

That is such bullshit. I had it, but needed to have them (ovaries) surgically removed.

Having PCOS didn't magically make me more of a man. It made me a woman with a medical condition. Anybody who thinks otherwise needs to have a reality check. Intersex people are born intersex. Women with PCOS are born women, and develop the condition later on.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) explains the painful recovery from a breast reduction, but says it was worth it for pain relief and shares a funny story about post-surgery Jell-O.
29 pointsApr 16, 2024
View on Reddit

I had a breast reduction, but it was because I was in constant pain because of their size. If you feel it would help you, absolutely go for it.

I'm not gonna mince words here, the recovery absolutely blows horse snot. You have to wear a special type of bra for a month, and sleep on your back. It feels like your chest is going to fall off for the first week. The incisions are pretty gnarly to look at, I almost passed out the first time I saw them lol.

But... It's all just a memory now. It sucked going through it, but it's an experience that eventually passes.

The worst thing that happened was orange Jell-O. I got some in the recovery room, still high on anesthesia. It was the single most delicious thing I've ever had, ambrosia of the gods level. I've been chasing that orange dragon ever since lol.

Reddit user Bottled_Penguin (desisted female) comments on the oversaturation of trans imagery, calling it a tiring fad they hope will fade soon.
27 pointsMar 20, 2024
View on Reddit

I'm an artist as well, yes it's very annoying. I honestly think these people are blowing all this way out of proportion, and it's the reason so many people end up pushing back. They're getting sick of seeing it everywhere too, the apathy is real. I'm getting just... So tired of seeing the trans flag in everything. It feels more like it's a fad to be trans, or identify as a different gender. I hope it goes away like a fad sometime soon, because frankly I'm just tired of it.