genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Cal7045's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 16 -> Detransitioned: 23
male
took hormones
regrets transitioning
influenced online
retransition
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this user account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The comments display a consistent, nuanced, and evolving personal narrative of a male detransitioner (MtFtM). The story includes specific, believable details (e.g., age of transition/detransition, family dynamics, therapist interactions, dating history) and expresses a range of complex emotions—regret, sadness, frustration, and cautious optimism—that align with the genuine experiences of detransitioners. The user's advice is measured, often acknowledges personal limitations ("I'm not a medical professional/lawyer"), and avoids simplistic or extremist rhetoric, which adds to its credibility.

About me

I started identifying as transgender at 16 because I felt I couldn't be a sensitive boy and fit in. I lived as a woman for five years after starting hormones at 19, but it was a constant, stressful struggle to try and be someone I wasn't. I realized my desire to transition was socially induced and that the reality never felt right, so I detransitioned last year. I now see that I don't need to fit a specific checklist to be a man. I'm just trying to be myself, a mix of masculine and feminine traits, and build a new life from scratch.

My detransition story

My whole journey with this started when I was around 15 or 16. I was never a super masculine boy growing up, and I could tell that frustrated my dad, even if he never said it outright. I felt like I related more to girls because they seemed to be allowed to be more like me—softer, more emotional—without getting crap for it. I started to believe that I couldn't be my true self and be a boy at the same time. That envy and the feeling of not fitting in led me to identify as transgender.

It became an obsession. From 16 to 19, being trans was my entire life. I was convinced it was the only way to be happy. When I was 19, I started medically transitioning with hormones. My therapist at the time was a big part of pushing this forward. I found out later that she told my family I would kill myself if they didn't support my transition, which was a really heavy form of emotional manipulation. I don't think she was evil, just caught up in this "affirm or else" bubble that a lot of gender therapists are in.

I lived as a woman for nearly five years. But it was a constant struggle. I spent so much energy trying to pass, trying to look and act like a "normal" woman, and it was incredibly stressful. There was always this nagging feeling in the back of my mind that I was never really going to be the same as someone born female, no matter how much affirmation I got. I also faced some subtle discrimination; nothing super obvious, but you just get a feeling when people are uncomfortable with you and want you gone.

I started to realize that a lot of my desire to transition was socially induced. The idea of being a woman was different from the reality. The reality was a ton of work for a result that never felt quite right. I also began to see that not being trans would just be easier. I was tired of the stress and the worry about how people saw me.

Last summer, I decided to detransition. It was a massive shift. I told my close friends and family, packed up my women's clothes, and started dressing like a guy again. The obsession I had with being trans just vanished, and for a while, I felt like I had nothing else to focus on. It was rough. I had to build a new life from scratch. I’ve been going back to school and getting involved in local clubs to find fulfillment.

I don’t regret transitioning because it was a part of my life that led me to where I am now, but I do see it as a mistake. Looking back, some of the things I said and did are embarrassing. I was young and impressionable, and I bought into a narrative that wasn't true for me. My thoughts on gender now are a lot more apathetic. I don't feel super strongly about my "manhood." I just try to be myself, a mix of masculine and feminine traits, without forcing myself into any box. The idea that you need to fit a specific checklist to be a man or a woman is what got me into trouble in the first place.

I still struggle sometimes. There are days I think about transitioning again, but I’ve accepted that I will never pass as a woman in a way that would make me happy. It’s easier to just accept the body I was born with, even if it sometimes bothers me. I joke that I was "assigned unlucky at birth." My transition has permanently affected my body, and that will impact dating in the future, but I haven't really tried yet, so who knows.

My main advice to anyone questioning is to take things slow. There's no rush. Give yourself time to heal and figure out what’s truly healthy for you, not what fits a philosophical debate or an online trend. Be patient with yourself.

Here is a timeline of the main events:

Age Event
15/16 Started identifying as transgender.
19 Began medical transition (hormones).
19-23 Lived socially and medically as a woman for nearly 5 years.
23 Detransitioned socially and medically (stopped hormones).

Top Comments by /u/Cal7045:

39 comments • Posting since May 1, 2023
Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) comments on a post about questioning gender identity, explaining that the original poster may be on too many medications that are heavily influencing their perspectives and judgment, and advises consulting a doctor or psychiatrist about which are necessary.
34 pointsSep 18, 2023
View on Reddit

I don’t think I or anyone else here is a medical professional, so please take these words with a grain of salt, but my gut feeling is that you’re on way too many medications and that those medications are either heavily influencing your perspectives and/or influencing your judgement.

I would seriously talk to another doctor or psychiatrist heavily about what medications are necessary or not and if you need to get off them for a while. I would also avoid drugs (ones not prescribed by a doctor) in general.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) explains how paternal disappointment in his lack of masculinity and envy of female social freedom led him to transition as a teen.
19 pointsDec 12, 2023
View on Reddit

I know I’m coming from the opposite direction as you, but maybe it’s somewhat relatable.

I was never super masculine growing up and that, even though he won’t admit it, was a source of frustration for my father. I could just tell the way he acted around it. I don’t think he doesn’t love me or anything, but it was a thing regardless.

It led me to feel like I related more to girls (I started identifying as trans when I was 15/16). I perceived to some degree that girls around me weren’t expected to be strong or be responsible in a “masculine” way. I know those kinds of expectations have roots in sexism (and was ironic because my sister is more “masculine” than I am), but it was still there. It made me envious that women could act like I did (more feminine) and not get crap over it.

I think that led me to believe that I couldn’t be “me” and be a boy. Sometimes I feel that way still, but as I’ve gotten older I’ve begun to care less and less about people’s perceptions of how “manly” I am. Of course when you spend years and years convincing yourself you’re not man, it’s hard not to feel that way still.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) explains that most trans women do not achieve a completely female-passing appearance, noting that passing is often limited to those who transition as minors or have exceptional genetics.
16 pointsDec 8, 2023
View on Reddit

Unfortunately the idea of something is way different that what it turns out to be. For most trans women, and I say this because it’s a hard truth for most, don’t get to the point where they look completely like women. I don’t say this in the way of you looking like a masculine woman or something, but that in a way people know you were not born female. In my experience, the trans women who pass started transitioning as minors or just won the genetic lottery. I’ve found they’re a minority of trans women. Unfortunately, you have to keep this in mind before doing anything. I was told I would pass, but after nearly 5 years on hormones that never came to pass. Like I said, the reality is way different than the fantasy.

It’s not to say that transitioning can’t be worth it regardless, but I find that a lot of people set their expectations way too high for transition and then reality hits them hard and they can’t handle it. Just know what you may be going into and manage those expectations and know that all your problems won’t be magically solved.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) reflects on the embarrassment of transitioning, citing hindsight, regrettable statements, and the influence of the "transition or suicide" narrative.
16 pointsOct 15, 2023
View on Reddit

Not really sure to be honest. There's some really stupid stuff I had said during transition that in hindsight I am embarrassed over. I do think that transitioning looked kind of ridiculous for me in hindsight and I could understand now why some people around me thought that way. So yeah, transitioning was kind of embarrassing, but I also realize that lots of people make stupid life decisions and that's just part of life sometimes.

At the same time, after adamantly defending my trans identity for years, buying into the "it's transition or suicide" narrative and then all of a sudden realizing I was wrong can be embarrassing. Should it be embarrassing? Probably not given how heavily influenced a lot of us were by trans stuff at a young age. We are super impressionable when we are young.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) explains how his therapist emotionally manipulated his family by claiming he would commit suicide if they didn't support his transition.
15 pointsJul 20, 2023
View on Reddit

I did not transition as young as you (I was 19), but after I detransitioned I discovered that everyone in my family was being told by the therapist I saw that I will take my own life if they did not support me. Emotionally manipulated into believing it was supporting me or pretty much killing me. I know people will say I was an adult and made a conscious decision, but when the therapist and doctors are not being 100% honest and doing their due diligence, it's hard to argue that a patient or their family is making an informed decision.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) explains why a biological basis for being trans would be rejected by activists and how it could improve medical gatekeeping.
15 pointsMay 19, 2023
View on Reddit

It wouldn't matter to activists if the brain difference argument was proved 100% anyway. They'll decry that it is transphobic, as it will inevitably deny a portion of people's trans identity. What it would do, however, is give physicians a reason to deny HRT and surgery to people who are not actually gender dysphoric, distinguish dysphoria from just regular body dysmorphia and refer them to more psychological care.

It's important to remember too, while I'm sure there are "real trans people," activists' definition of being trans is so inconsistent that it means virtually nothing. Under their current framework, anyone can say they are trans and they must be accepted as such. No questions asked.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) explains why, as a bisexual man, he remains politically liberal despite issues with the trans community.
14 pointsMay 17, 2023
View on Reddit

I can relate to other LGBT people as I am bisexual with a preference for men, so I can relate a lot to gay and bi men just by being of the same demographic. I remain pretty solidly liberal, however, despite any issues that they may have. I'm not a one-issue voter where some trans stuff is enough for me to do a 180 on a significant amount of my values.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) explains his transition was motivated by societal pressure against feminine men, shares his 5-year medical transition and detransition experience, and offers hope by comparing it to a self-inflicted wound that takes time to heal.
14 pointsNov 22, 2023
View on Reddit

I was never like some masculine boy growing up either. I’ve theorized that this fact was one of the main reasons I transitioned. Being a feminine guy is still sadly looked down upon.

If it helps any, I medically transitioned for nearly 5 years and have since detransitioned and found a good place for myself as a man again. It’s not to say I don’t struggle sometimes, but it’s better than where I was.

The important thing is to not beat yourself up and to give yourself time. I don’t know if it’s a perfect analogy, but for some of us transitioning was like a self inflicted wound, and it takes time, like any injury, to recover from it. Some people will take longer than others to recover, and that’s okay.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) urges a suicidal user to seek professional help, disconnect from toxic online influences like 4chan, and take life one day at a time.
14 pointsOct 30, 2023
View on Reddit

Please reach out for help. You don’t have to eat yourself alive and be alone in all this. Please reach out to a professional. They can aid you in the struggles you are going through, including the gender ones.

In the long run, please drop the negative influences. From what I have read, it doesn’t feel like the people you are talking to have your best interests in mind. 4chan, in all honestly, and to some extent all social media, can have some pretty awful people on them. I would disconnect with these people and find friends and communities that help you find happiness and actually care about you. Don’t let others views about you determine your happiness. You must do what is right for you, whether you transition or not.

As someone who has struggled with depression and has strongly considered taking his own life, just take things one day at a time. One step at a time, one breath at a time. Focus on today, getting through it, setting small goals for yourself, going to bed, and taking the next day on its own. While I am not perfect, I try to remember this: every day is a gift and being alive is a tremendous gift. This isn’t meant to guilt you or anyone struggling with these issues, but something I have come to realize when going through mine. I won’t say that life is perfect and you won’t have hard times, but I try to remember that.

I will just say again: please seek out professional help. You don’t have to struggle alone. You are capable of being loved. You can find friends. I have no doubt of that.

Reddit user Cal7045 (detrans male) comments on the rise of people claiming a trans identity without transitioning to avoid hardship and feel special.
13 pointsJan 19, 2024
View on Reddit

It’s sadly become common for people to claim a trans identity and then live as they are always have so they can feel special and face none of the consequences. A way of identifying yourself into a minority without the hardships. It’s especially insulting to the actual trans people and other minorities.