genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/CareyCallahan's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 20 -> Detransitioned: 24
female
took hormones
regrets transitioning
trauma
depression
serious health complications
body dysmorphia
sexuality changed
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the comments provided, this account appears to be authentic. The user demonstrates a consistent, nuanced, and deeply personal narrative of their detransition experience, including specific medical, psychological, and social details. The writing style is complex, emotionally varied, and shows genuine engagement with others' posts. There are no red flags suggesting it is a bot or an inauthentic account. The passion and anger expressed are consistent with a genuine detransitioner's perspective.

About me

I'm a woman who started transitioning because I never fit the narrow expectations for how a girl should act. Taking testosterone unexpectedly shifted my sexuality towards men and left me with lasting physical changes I regret. I became psychologically addicted to binding and went through a severe depression when I stopped everything. I now manage my occasional dysphoria through yoga, a good job, and setting firm boundaries. I've found peace by rejecting the idea that my value comes from my body or a category, and I'm finally building a life I love.

My detransition story

My whole journey with gender has been a long and confusing one, and looking back, I can see how many different pieces of my life came together to push me towards transition. I was always a bit of a strange girl, and people around me noticed. I remember a coworker once told me she never really saw me as a "girl" because I was bad at details and being neat. I think I have some problems with executive dysfunction, and not being able to meet those expectations of how a woman should act really messed with how I saw myself. When I came out as trans, it was like a relief to a lot of people in my life because it finally explained why I was different. But now, that just makes me angry. Just because my brain works differently doesn't mean I needed to spend years letting doctors poke and prod at me.

I started identifying as trans and began taking testosterone. I was on T for about nine months. Before that, I identified as bisexual and dated men and women equally. But being on T changed my sexuality in a way I never expected. It made me intensely, almost surrealistically, attracted to men. I went from being a Kinsey 4 to a Kinsey 1. Before transition, I thought I'd end up with a woman, so this shift was really counterproductive and something I had to mourn. I'm still mourning it, to be honest. Adjusting to being a straight woman has been hard; it doesn't come naturally to me at all, and I feel like the most awkward straight woman in the world. Men can be really freaked out when I disclose my past; they think I'm a lesbian in denial or something else entirely.

During my time identifying as trans, I became psychologically dependent on binding. It was addictive. Putting on the binder felt like a relief, but taking it off at the end of the day was incredibly distressing. Avoiding the reality of my chest just made the eventual confrontation with it so much worse. I have intense feelings of disgust about my breasts, which I think are more typical of body dysmorphia than gender dysphoria. To cope, I do a lot of bra-less yoga at home. The stretching and exercises, without being constrained, help a lot. Yoga gives me a sense of self-efficacy that decreases those dysmorphic feelings.

Stopping testosterone was rough. I had a severe depressive episode for about six months after quitting, and I was still depressed for another year after that. The hormonal swings definitely made it worse. The whole experience of my trans identity collapsing was like a death. It was painful and scary, and it's the kind of thing other people often don't believe you about. I was a true believer when I was in it, with a whole story about how I'd always been a trans boy. When that belief crumbled, it was traumatic and changed me forever.

Even now, after detransitioning, I still have periods of gender dysphoria. It comes and goes, like a flu or a depressive episode. I've made a commitment to myself that my dysphoria doesn't get to ruin my health or my finances. I've learned to manage it. Getting a professional job with an office door I can close has helped immensely, as has daily yoga and working out. Giving myself permission to stand up to people who bother me is surprisingly effective. I see my life as one long experiment in how to live without being consumed by dysphoria.

I've also had to grapple with the physical effects. I suspect that my time on testosterone wasn't good for my body's inflammatory response. I have a detransitioned friend who has to center her whole life around controlling her inflammation, and I think there's a connection, even if the medical community is dismissive of it. I had laser hair removal on my face and lower body, and I still have to shave my face about once a month. My voice is permanently lower, though my range has broadened over time. Binding didn't do my breasts any favors, but it's damage I have to live with.

My thoughts on gender now are complicated. I think a lot of my struggle was related to the reality of being a woman in a patriarchy. It's scary, unfair, and denigrating. We're not allowed to acknowledge how bad it really is without being called insane or being isolated. Finding all-female, radical feminist spaces was crucial for me. It helped me see that the shame and fear aren't inherent to being alive. I've moved from feeling impotent rage to feeling a potent rage. I've accepted that I don't owe this society anything in terms of how I should be, and that has been incredibly freeing. I concentrate on growing my skills, accruing resources, and doing what I find fun.

Do I have regrets? Yes, I really wish I had never started testosterone. I'm glad I stopped when I did. My gender dysphoria has decreased since I stepped away from the trans scene and stopped putting myself in situations where strangers constantly comment on my body. I've started to see my appearance more pragmatically, as a tool for navigating the world, rather than as the primary way I express myself. It was a rough way to clarify my sexuality, and it was a scary experience overall.

In the end, I've found a good place. I have a boyfriend who is wonderful and brings me flowers, a job I like, and I feel like a hot badass at least three days a week. The first year of detransition was dark and heavy, but I moved towards good things. I learned that my value isn't dependent on a perfect body or fitting into a neat category. It comes from my intelligence, my commitment to truth, and my ability to navigate life's challenges.

Here is a timeline of my journey:

Age Event
Early 20s Came out as transgender and began identifying as a man.
23 Started testosterone (T).
23-24 Experienced a shift in sexuality, becoming primarily attracted to men.
24 Stopped testosterone after 9 months.
24-25 Severe depressive episode following cessation of T.
24 Began the process of social detransition, reverting to living as a woman.
25 onwards Continued to manage fluctuating gender dysphoria through lifestyle changes like yoga, career shift, and setting boundaries.

Top Comments by /u/CareyCallahan:

47 comments • Posting since January 13, 2019
Reddit user CareyCallahan explains why the detrans subreddit cannot have an anti-GC (Gender Critical) policy, stating it would exclude many detransitioners who hold those views and advising users to seek other communities if trans issues are their sole priority.
47 pointsAug 5, 2019
View on Reddit

People are actually allowed to care about what they care about. A big enough percentage of detrans-ers turn GC to have some kind of anti-GC policy would exclude TONS of detrans-ers. There are BIG communities on reddit where trans people are the one and only priority, so that's a good place for you to socialize if trans people are your top priority. You're gonna eventually have to make your peace with a world where people think differently from you and have different priorities, or else you will spend your whole life tortured by the basics of human interaction.

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains their fury over a surgeon's actions, commenting on a video by an FTM detransitioner who had a failed phalloplasty and stating that Dr. Crane should lose his medical license.
30 pointsAug 6, 2019
View on Reddit

This was a very generous video to make. Thanks for putting the info out there. I am fucking furious that this happened to you and a lot of other people and I don't even know what justice for something like this could look like. But Crane needs to lose his license.

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains that a woman's value is not defined by her body's conformity to a male libido ideal, but by her intelligence, truthfulness, humor, resilience, and rejection of abuse.
21 pointsAug 6, 2019
View on Reddit

Her value as a woman was never dependent on her body remaining in some conceptually pristine, acceptable to the male libido state. Her value as a woman comes from her striking intelligence, her commitment to telling the truth, her humor, her ability to navigate betrayal and darkness, her generosity, her rejection of abusive dynamics and BS.

Women like this are exceptionally valuable. Maybe not to the average hetero male, but let's be real, their approval was probably never a goal and I'm not sure why they would start mattering to her now.

And I'm just saying as a woman who has dated women, for sure women like this will never lack for partners and friends.

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains why a boyfriend ashamed of his detransitioning partner is a "scam artist" and "rankest garbage pile," advising her to "take the trash out" to find someone who will honor her.
20 pointsJun 5, 2019
View on Reddit

This boy is no good. Boys who try to get the benefits of a relationship without claiming and honoring the person making those benefits possible are scam artists and not good or honorable people. He should've claimed you when you were trans-identified, and yeah duh he should be claiming you now.

It kills me to think you're going through detransition, which is stressful af, and this clown is adding to your stress. There are people who will want to shout to the world that you are their one and only, but you will only start the process of beginning to meet them once you take the trash out.

If you would like to give me his phone number so I can explain in detail to him that he is the rankest garbage pile, it would give me joy.

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains their dislike for pronoun circles, calling them a way for people without gender dysphoria to say "you can call me whatever."
18 pointsFeb 3, 2019
View on Reddit

Sending you good vibes to find a way to work on what's important to you and navigate this. I reaaalllllly hate a pronoun circle. I hated them when I was trans too! It's just a way for people who have never had gender dysphoria to say "you can call me whatever."

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains that her biggest dating problem was her own insecurity, but she now has the best boyfriend and says men who like tomboys really love them.
18 pointsJun 7, 2019
View on Reddit

Yep! Tbh my biggest problem has been my own inaccurate ideas about being unattractive or somehow a liability. Those ideas at some low moments made me pursue morons, but I also dated a string of pretty cool guys and now have the best boyfriend ever in the whole world. The dudes who like tomboys LOVE tomboys.

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains how they were a 'true believer' in being trans, fabricating a detailed childhood narrative, and now struggle with anxiety about identifying reality after the traumatic collapse of that belief.
17 pointsFeb 10, 2019
View on Reddit

I think about this all the time. Because like when I was in it, I was really in it, I was a true believer. So I had a very detailed story about all the ways I'd always been a little trans boy. And IDK, I have so much anxiety now about my ability to identify reality and not be socially influences in how I identify it, because unfortunately I was 100% convinced. Like, when that belief I was trans crumbled, it was really traumatic. It's one of those things you always are changed by.

Reddit user CareyCallahan compares pronoun circles and identity-focused activism to consumer capitalism, arguing they prioritize personal branding over effective power-shifting like union organizing.
16 pointsFeb 3, 2019
View on Reddit

THANK YOU. It's like consumer capitalism, but for our internal experiences? I wish I had the quote, I think it was an excerpt maybe from "No Logo" that really stuck with me, which was about western labor activists meeting south asian labor activists. And the western ones were taken aback by how the south asian ones would wear Nike shirts and other branded clothing, because the western ones had this idea that part of their activism included their consumer choices. But the south asian ones didn't conceive of their activism that way- for them it was union organizing and strikes, and what you wore was besides the point. I feel like the requirement that in radical leftist groups everyone does an inward interrogation of their internal experience and offers it up to the group as the foundational piece of info to share (I mean, literally with YOUR NAME) is an extension of the consumerist view of a lot of western activism. And fundamentally, that's based on the illusion that buying the right things is somehow the same as shifting power!

I'm with you, pronoun circles drive me bonkers and as you can tell I have thought way too hard about the specifics of how they drive me bonkers. It's also like, is any of this making the left more effective? Is that time that goes to the pronoun circle time well spent? Seems like such a weird little bubble ritual.

Reddit user CareyCallahan shares an article with advice and a dysphoria tracking sheet for gender-dysphoric teens.
14 pointsApr 23, 2019
View on Reddit

It doesn't sounds like you're a teen but here's an article I wrote about discernment, and there's a link to a dysphoria tracking sheet in there: https://medium.com/@mariacatt42/advice-for-gender-dysphoric-teens-9a3e34a2e5ba

Reddit user CareyCallahan explains that the detransitioning woman already presents as a butch lesbian and will find community and acceptance within women's spaces unfamiliar to the commenter.
12 pointsAug 6, 2019
View on Reddit

You really have no experience or knowledge of women's community AT ALL. She already presents, to a lot of people's eyes including mine, as a butch woman. Her decisions about surgery are her business, and she has more insider knowledge than any of us, so she'll make the right decision for her. But socially, she's gonna be more than fine, it's just not going to be in any peer groups you know anything about.