genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/CoanTeen's Detransition Story

female
only transitioned socially
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user's perspective is consistent and nuanced, expressing a common detransitioner/desister viewpoint that prioritizes therapy, critiques gender ideology, and shares personal experience (e.g., identifying as a "female tomboy"). The language is natural, passionate, and shows the development of ideas over time, which is not typical of bot behavior.

About me

I'm a female who was always a tomboy, and I never felt my interests made me less of a woman. I became deeply concerned watching others, especially young people, rush into medical transition instead of exploring the root causes of their pain. I believe we need to challenge rigid stereotypes and that proper therapy should always come before permanent medical procedures. My own peace came from self-acceptance, not from changing my body. Now, I regret that so many are convinced altering themselves is the only solution.

My detransition story

Of course. Here is a summary of my experiences, based on my own comments.

My whole journey with this didn't start with me transitioning myself, but with me watching what was happening around me and trying to understand it. I’m a female who has always been a tomboy. I like sports, I’m a natural leader, and I never had any time for things like makeup or doing my hair. I never once questioned that I was a woman because of it. I am just me. I figured out that if someone had a problem with how I was, that was their issue to deal with, not mine.

I started seeing more and more people, especially young people, talking about being trans online. The more I saw, the more it deeply concerned me. From my perspective, it looked like a lot of people were being led down a path that didn't make sense. It seemed like if a kid showed any behavior that wasn't a perfect stereotype of their sex, they were immediately labeled as trans. To me, this is a completely backwards way of thinking. It reinforces the most rigid stereotypes of what a man or a woman should be, which is the opposite of what I believe in. I believe everyone is an individual and we all fall on a spectrum of being gender non-conforming. That doesn't make anyone trans.

I saw a lot of people who were really struggling, and it seemed like their problems were much deeper than gender. I kept wondering, why do you feel uncomfortable in your own body? Do you have other issues going on? Have you suffered from abuse or trauma? Do you have a good relationship with your parents? I felt that these were the questions that needed to be asked first, before anyone ever mentioned hormones or surgery. Medical intervention should be the absolute last resort because it changes your body permanently. You can't go back.

I also saw people who seemed to be dealing with things like OCD, or a fetish, or deep-seated insecurity, and they were being told that transitioning was the answer. I don't believe a psychiatric problem can be solved by bending reality or altering your body. It’s like putting a bandaid on a wound that’s infected underneath; it doesn't actually fix the problem. I think what people really need is proper, critical therapy from a psychotherapist who isn't just going to affirm everything they say, but will actually help them dig into the why behind their feelings.

I had my own problems with therapists who were too "hippy-dippy," so I learned to be direct. I would tell them straight up that I only wanted science-based information. If they weren't comfortable with that, I’d find someone else. I think that's a good approach for anyone. You have to find a therapist who will be critical but empathetic, and you have to trust your gut.

I even saw this play out in my own dating life before I met my husband. I always felt weird and insecure around boyfriends and felt like I had to act a certain way. The minute I stopped caring and decided to just be my true tomboy self, I attracted people who were actually into me for me. That was a huge lesson in self-acceptance.

As for my thoughts on gender itself, I think it's simple. I respect everyone's right to live their life how they want and to present themselves how they want. People should have their own spaces and be treated with basic human decency. But I also believe in stating what I see as the scientific truth: that sex is real and immutable. You can live as and pass as the opposite sex, but that doesn't change your biological reality. I don't think stating that fact is hateful.

My regret isn't about a personal transition, because I never medically transitioned. My regret is that I watched so many others rush into it without asking the hard questions first, influenced by online communities and advocacy groups that I believe have too much power. I regret that so many young people are being convinced that changing their bodies is the solution to their problems, when I strongly believe that true peace comes from self-acceptance and dealing with the root causes of our pain.

Here is a timeline of my relevant life events based on my experiences:

Age Event
Throughout childhood I was a happy tomboy, comfortable being a female who didn't conform to stereotypes.
Early 20s Dated while feeling insecure, tried to act differently to please boyfriends.
Age 24 Had a personal breakthrough, decided to be my authentic tomboy self no matter what.
Shortly after 24 Met my husband, who was attracted to me for who I truly am.
Age 31 (2019) Was actively engaged in online discussions, expressing my concerns about the trans movement and advocating for thorough therapy.

Top Comments by /u/CoanTeen:

14 comments • Posting since September 18, 2019
Reddit user CoanTeen comments on the need for trans spaces and condemns calls to "get rid" of a social group as extreme and immoral.
31 pointsSep 28, 2019
View on Reddit

I'm not a radfem and I think transfolk should have their own space and their own bathrooms. Also, I think "getting rid" of a whole social group is rather extreme and automatically invalidates anything you have to say because it makes you an immoral being. How would you feel if people here said that "we gotta get rid of all trans people". You are doing exactly the same to another group of people. You've got no morality or principles. Watch yourself in the mirror.

Reddit user CoanTeen comments on medical transition as authorized self-harm, arguing trans advocacy groups pressure doctors into prescribing hormones and surgeries, and target younger people while silencing dissent as bigotry.
20 pointsSep 18, 2019
View on Reddit

I don't think you should throw the baby with the bathwater when it comes to doctors. I believe trans advocacy groups are too powerful and force doctors into prescribing hormones or else. They are infiltrating every strata of our society trying to convince younger and younger people that they are trans and they need puberty blockers, hormones and bottom surgery. If anyone dares to speak up, they are labelled as bigots.

I don't get how people don't realize that we are all individuals. Everyone is gender non-conforming to different degrees, it does not mean everyone is trans.

Reddit user CoanTeen comments on the importance of respecting everyone as a default, even when ideologies differ.
16 pointsNov 14, 2019
View on Reddit

Is there a good way to be trans? More like, is there a good way to be a good human being?

Yes, stick to respecting everyone as a default even if they don't follow the same ideology as you. You can disagree with people without belittling them, etc. If the people around you find it offensive that you respect everyone by default, you probably aren't surrounded by good people.

Reddit user CoanTeen explains how trans ideology can create cognitive dissonance by demanding physical transition to fit gender stereotypes, which they argue is contrary to self-acceptance.
16 pointsSep 24, 2019
View on Reddit

You have encountered the cognitive dissonance of the trans ideology. As soon as someone doesn't match the stereotype of what a male or female are, either how they look or behave or like or dislike, the trans ideology demands that you transition to the opposite sex to better match the stereotype of what a male or female should be. The previous statement is contrary to self-acceptance because, as you said, it demands that you change everything about your body.

Reddit user CoanTeen explains why they believe medical transition is a damaging "bandaid" that fails to address underlying psychiatric problems.
13 pointsSep 28, 2019
View on Reddit

A psychiatric problem cannot be solved by bending your reality. You'll come to realize that at the end of the tunnel nothing really changed and you only damaged your body with hormones and/or surgery. Your body is your body and you should accept it how it is, get a critical therapist to help you with your mental issues. T doesn't solve anything, much less surgery. They are only a bandaid that will not cure the festering wound you have.

Reddit user CoanTeen explains their view that questioning gender identity may stem from unrecognized trauma, advising trauma therapy and disconnecting from online trans ideology.
9 pointsSep 25, 2019
View on Reddit

It's as if you have suffered some kind of trauma that doesn't allow you to recognize your body as your reality? Get trauma therapy and get off the internet. Trans ideology is corrosive and makes you doubt yourself when you're at your most vulnerable, adolescence.

Reddit user CoanTeen explains their view that stating a person is not a woman, despite their appearance, is not hateful but a "scientific truth."
7 pointsSep 26, 2019
View on Reddit

We aren't hating on you for stating the scientific truth.

We aren't racist for stating the scientific truth.

Why are you so upset someone is saying the truth? You can live as a woman if you want, you can pass as a woman, that's great but you are not a woman. You have the appearance of a woman.

Reddit user CoanTeen comments that embracing her tomboy identity and rejecting insecurity led to finding a partner who accepted her for who she is.
5 pointsNov 20, 2019
View on Reddit

I always felt weird around my boyfriends and could never be myself due to my own insecurities. The minute I said "fuck it, if they don't like the real me they can go to hell" I started finding people that were into me, a tomboy. I found my husband shortly after. The key is not to be embarrassed of who you are.

Reddit user CoanTeen advises questioning individual to prioritize relationship evaluation and self-exploration for trauma or abuse before considering gender identity.
5 pointsNov 20, 2019
View on Reddit

It seems you're questioning your sexuality based on a crappy relationship. If you aren't comfortable around your bf, dump him and get another one. You're supposed to be with someone that makes you feel confident.

Secondly, ask yourself why are you disconnected from your own body. Do you have a history of abuse? Sexual trauma? Toxic parents? Toxic friends? The question of being trans or not should be the the very last one to be asked.

Reddit user CoanTeen comments on the pressure to label gender-nonconforming kids as trans, arguing it enforces rigid stereotypes and creates cognitive dissonance.
4 pointsSep 23, 2019
View on Reddit

This is exactly what people are doing to kids now a days. If they show any inclination towards stereotypical behaviours of the opposite sex they are labelled trans. It is such a backward view. They don't realize they are trying to fit a rigid stereotype of what being a woman/man means. The cognitive dissonance is enormous in the trans community.