This story is from the comments by /u/Cool_Incident_7272 that are listed below, summarised with AI.
User Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic.
The user shares a highly specific, nuanced, and emotionally charged personal narrative spanning gender transition, detransition, anorexia, and religious deconversion. The story contains consistent, intricate details about medical procedures (blockers, T cream), psychological motivations, and physical changes over time. The language is passionate, reflective, and contains the raw emotion and anger often seen in this community. The writing style is conversational, includes personal asides, and shows a natural flow of thought, which is difficult for bots to replicate convincingly.
About me
I was a tomboy as a little girl and socially transitioned to live as a boy named Charlie. I was put on puberty blockers and testosterone at twelve, but I stopped all of it at fifteen and developed a severe eating disorder. My anorexia was a way to control my body and stop it from developing into a woman’s, and my strict religious beliefs made me feel immense shame for being female. I’ve since left that religion, recovered from my eating disorder, and decided to detransition. My body is now finally starting its natural female puberty, and I’m embracing my life and health without being burdened by those old struggles.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender started when I was really little, around six or seven. I was a major tomboy. I wanted to be a boy, so I peed standing up, loved football, and just insisted I was one. My name was Hannah, but I changed it to Charlie. Because I had some other behavioral issues, a specialist diagnosed me with gender dysphoria and recommended I transition. That set me on a path.
I got on puberty blockers when I was twelve, right before I would have started developing breasts or gotten my period. I remember having a little bit of nipple swelling and discharge right before, but the blockers stopped everything. I practically begged them to put me on a low-dose testosterone cream, and they did. They told me it wouldn't change my voice yet, but it did. My voice started to drop and I started growing stomach hair and a lot of muscle.
By the time I was fifteen, I decided to stop everything—the blockers and the T. When I got off them, I felt really weak and nauseous. That's what started my weight loss. I stopped working out and lost all that muscle, and then I just got addicted to the feeling of losing weight and eating very little. That turned into full-blown anorexia.
I think for me, the eating disorder was a subconscious way to escape gender. It was about finding control over my body when it was about to go through changes I couldn't control and felt uncomfortable with. Being underweight also meant I didn't get my period, which kept me from fully developing into a woman. It was a way to stay in this neutral, pre-pubescent state.
Around this same time, I was also deep into religion. I had converted to Islam when I was thirteen and practiced it really strictly. I learned classical Arabic, prayed five times a day, didn't listen to music, didn't touch women—the whole thing. Being transgender felt like a living sin, and I followed all the rules for males. I was basically in denial that I was female. My whole life was ruled by fear, guilt, and shame. I planned to detransition and become ultra-feminine to follow the rules, but I hated it. I finally cracked under the pressure and left the religion. I realized I was worshipping out of fear, not love, and I felt nothing in my heart. I believe in a loving higher power now, but not one that demands that kind of control.
Deciding to detransition was scary. I was afraid of seeing family again and felt ashamed, like I was just another gullible person who made decisions too fast. But it was so worth it. My main motivation to recover from the anorexia was to just be healthy. I scared myself with the facts—like how being underweight can cause osteoporosis later because of a lack of estrogen. I never thought I'd be able to live with myself over 81 pounds, but I pushed through. Now I feel so much more alive. I'm mountaineering, doing gymnastics, working, and I even worked on a farm. I couldn't have done any of that when I was sick.
My body is finally starting to change now that I'm restoring my weight. I'm noticing a little bit of discharge and some nipple swelling, which are signs that my body might be starting puberty finally. My voice is still low from the T, but it's settled into a more neutral tone and I've made peace with it. I feel more non-binary now, but that doesn't make me any less female. My chromosomes are XX, and that's just a fact. I'm embracing being female, and I'm finally starting a real life that isn't burdened by religion, gender, and obsessive diet and exercise. I couldn't be happier.
Looking back, I can't believe how young I was when all this started. Kids that age should not be getting any sort of cross-sex hormones. Period. I don't regret my journey because it made me who I am, but I do think the medical system failed me by not looking deeper into why I felt the way I did. It was a crazy ride, but I'm finally on the other side.
Age | Event |
---|---|
6/7 | Socially transitioned. Changed name from Hannah to Charlie. |
12 | Started puberty blockers and low-dose testosterone cream. |
15 | Stopped blockers and testosterone. Developed anorexia. |
17 | Restoring weight, body beginning to show first signs of female puberty. |
Top Reddit Comments by /u/Cool_Incident_7272:
I was the 15 year old freaking out on here two years ago about deciding to detransition (and, thank God, leaving Islam). I don’t even know where to start, but please feel free to ask questions and I will explain my story! (I thought I posted this last night but it turns out I didn’t put it on the detrans forum, whoops).
Long story short, I am done with all my crazy phases, embracing being female, and waiting to start puberty since I am finally restoring my weight after anorexia (which started right after getting my blocker out).
It has been a crazy, crazy ride and I’m finally starting a real life that is not burdened by religion, gender and obsessive exercise/diet. I could not be happier.
Wait for real?! I have actually never spoke to another person around my age in this same situation with blockers (not ever going thru female puberty). I forgot how scared I was to detransition, too. I was scared of having to see family again and felt ashamed, like I was another gullible victim of making decisions too fast.
So, I socially transitioned when I was 6/7ish. I just really wanted to be a boy. I was a major tomboy, peed standing up, loved football. Keyword “wanted”, and this was read as gender dysphoria, because of my coexisting behavioral issues, by a specialist who diagnosed me and recommended transition. My name was Hannah before, and I changed it to Charlie (I still go by Charlie now since it’s a girl’s name too and I don’t really connect with Hannah at this point). I was on the path for blockers and hormones to mimic male puberty. I got blockers at 12, before ever developing breasts and a period (though I had some nipple swelling and more discharge than normal towards the later end). They put me on low dose T cream, which I practically begged for, do NOT listen to twelve year olds. I started growing and my voice changed although although they said it wouldn’t yet.
By the time I got off T and blockers at 15, I had stomach hair and tons of muscle, and my voice stayed low (though it’s more neutral now. I made peace with it).
I feel more non-binary as well, but to me that doesn’t make me any less female, because surprise!! My chromosomes are XX. Anyhow, it’s easier for me to say now that I’ve overcome the fears, but your detransition will be so worth it and your body will be much healthier will the hormones that were meant to be in it. People will judge MUCH less than you think.
Feel free to PM me. I’d love to hear your story too!!
Thank you ❤️ And I am honestly happy to talk about anything or answer any questions.
My theory, for me at least, is that eating disorders are a subconscious way for us to escape gender by whittling our bodies down and finding control over other things when our bodies are about to go through uncontrollable and maybe uncomfortable changes. And was a really long sentence, I hope you can make sense of it…
Anyhow, my main motivation to recover was just to be healthy. I found it helpful to “scare myself” out of it by looking at the facts: if you are underweight, you will lose (or severely delay until basically adulthood, like me) your period. A lack of estrogen/a period can cause serious effects like osteoporosis later on. You do NOT want that.
There’s not really much I can say since I know how powerful obsessive thoughts are. But please know that I never thought I’d be able to live with myself over 81 pounds. I didn’t want to recover. But you really, really have to push past it. I cannot describe how much more alive I feel. There is SO much you can do when you are not obsessing over your body and food. I am mountaineering, doing gymnastics, working and making bank, and going to work on a farm. I wouldn’t have been able to do any of this when I was sick. Push yourself, give yourself time, and find things you love to do. Please, take it from me. It’s not worth it. Eat well ❤️❤️
The medical system these days :)))
To be fair it was not the shots, it was a low dose cream that supposedly mimicked male puberty for someone my age. But my voice is still unusually low for a female, which sucks, and my hormones are probably more screwed up that they would have been with just the eating disorder.
Kids that age should not be getting any sort of cross hormones. Period. Looking back now I cannot BELIEVE how young that was.
I think it did for me. I remember journaling how I felt going off hormones and saying I felt really weak and nauseous. That started my weight loss (also stopped working out so lost lots of muscle) and from there kind of got addicted to the feeling of losing weight and eating very little.
First of all, are you a deadhead, too!? I saw your username. I meant to say “what a long strange trip it’s been” in my post but forgot. If you aren’t, disregard that haha.
This will be a very long ramble but there is a lot to say. Bear with me. I converted when I was 13 by going to a masjid and taking my shahada. I practiced hardcore, Sunni, straight-from-Hadith-and-Qur’aan Islam. In retrospect, I turned this into the eating disorder of religion: I learned classical Arabic (I still can read it pretty well now which is cool!), prayed 5 times a day 99% of the time. When I didn’t I made them up and made taubah. Always kept my wudu’ for prayer and touching the Qur’an, made ghusl even after having “impure” dreams, fasted, didn’t even touch women, didn’t listen to music, etc. I was always stressed and guilty and missed music and mingling so much. Being transgender was like being a living sin, and I followed all the rules for males and was basically in denial that I was female.
When I first started considering detransition, I was actually still practicing Islam. I planned to start wearing hijab and was preparing to be all-out feminine since being a masculine woman and vice versa is a great sin. I tried by myself and hated every second of it. I eventually just cracked under the pressure and stopped practicing, finally admitting to myself that the God I was “worshipping” was just out of fear (which, in Islam, is actually the goal) and I felt absolutely nothing in my heart. To be honest, I feel like I was missing a year and a half of life.
I’m by no means atheist and believe in a loving higher power. I like to question everything now. I think my conversion to Islam was just about finding control and a sense of direction: if I do X, Allah will reward me with Y. If I do Z, I will spend eternity in hell. So do X, don’t do Z, etc. I respect people who can truly find peace within Islam, or who can extrapolate its peaceful teachings to this day and age. But I don’t sugarcoat it anymore like I used to—If you really follow Islam the way it is “supposed” to be followed, you can’t really have a life outside of it, and there’s going to be a lot of repression, shame, guilt, and stress. That wasn’t for me. If you’re still reading to here, whew, thanks! I don’t really talk about this that much. I could discuss Islam for days straight since I have so much “leftover” knowledge I want to put somewhere useful.
Of course! I haven’t had an official lab in a while (6 months?) but at that time my estrogen was at prepubescent levels and there was no development. I was plateaued at 98 pounds (at 5’6) for a while, and was having a mental block gaining weight, so I’m sure my hormones weren’t very happy about that. But now I am for real gaining weight again, so I bet my hormone levels are maybe getting higher, though we haven’t gotten a chance to do a more recent lab.
Good news is that I’m noticing a small bit of discharge (it was always completely bone dry before), and maybe a little bit of nipple swelling, but I don’t want to jinx it!