This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or inauthentic.
The user's comments demonstrate:
- A consistent, nuanced, and personal understanding of detransition, desistance, and dysphoria.
- Empathetic and detailed engagement with other users' specific situations.
- A writing style that is conversational, uses personal anecdote ("I lean more towards crossdresser"), and includes natural hesitations and qualifiers ("I'm not sure," "correct me if I'm wrong").
- A tone of passionate concern that aligns with the stated experiences of detransitioners and desisters.
About me
I was a girl who never fit in, and my deep discomfort with puberty led me to believe I was a transgender man after being influenced by online communities. I took testosterone for two years, but it didn't fix my underlying depression and anxiety, only changing my appearance. I'm grateful I stopped before getting surgery, and finding a therapist who helped me understand my body dysmorphia was a turning point. Now I live as a masculine woman, learning to accept my body with its permanent changes from testosterone. I wish I had been asked more questions early on, as my journey was really about psychological struggles, not a true need to change my sex.
My detransition story
Looking back on my whole journey, I see now that my decision to transition came from a place of deep confusion, not a clear sense of being a man. I was a girl who never fit in. I was uncomfortable with my body when puberty hit, especially when I developed breasts. I hated them; they felt alien and wrong on me. I now believe this was a mix of body dysmorphia and the general discomfort of growing up, not true sex dysphoria. I also struggled with depression and anxiety, and I had very low self-esteem. I didn't feel like I was good at being a girl, and I felt like a failure.
I started spending a lot of time online, and I was influenced by what I saw. The idea of transition was presented as a magic solution: if you don't feel right in your body, changing it will fix everything. It seemed like an escape from all my problems. I started identifying as non-binary first, and then that shifted to identifying as a transgender man. My friends at the time were very supportive of this, which pushed me further down that path. I think I was also dealing with some internalised homophobia; the idea of being a masculine woman who liked women was harder for me to accept than the idea of being a straight man.
I took testosterone for about two years. The changes happened fast. My voice dropped, I grew facial hair, and my body shape changed. At first, it felt good. It felt like I was taking control and finally doing something about my unhappiness. But after the initial excitement wore off, I realized my underlying problems were still there. The depression and anxiety didn't go away; I was just a different-looking person who was still depressed and anxious. I started to feel like I had made a huge mistake.
I never got surgery. I was planning on getting top surgery, but I started having serious doubts before I went through with it. I'm incredibly grateful for that now. Stopping testosterone was the first step in my detransition. It was scary because I felt like I was admitting I was wrong, but it was also a relief.
What really helped me untangle everything was finding a therapist who specialized in working with detransitioners. She didn't just affirm my identity; she helped me dig into the root causes of my discomfort. We talked about my body issues, my low self-esteem, and my need to escape. She helped me see that I was trying to solve a problem with the wrong tool. Transition was a medical solution for what was, in my case, a psychological and social problem. This non-affirming therapy was exactly what I needed. It saved me from making permanent changes I would have deeply regretted.
I don't regret my transition in the sense that I learned a lot about myself by going through it. But I do regret that I wasn't given better guidance from the start. I wish the doctors had asked more questions about my mental health history instead of just affirming my desire to transition. I think the diagnostic criteria for dysphoria are too loose, and people like me, who have other issues that mimic dysphoria, are falling through the cracks.
Now, I see myself as a masculine woman. I sometimes think of myself as a crossdresser because I like presenting in a very masculine way. I'm still working on accepting my female body, especially since the effects of testosterone are permanent in some ways, like my voice. I have to learn to live with that. My thoughts on gender now are that it's a social thing, and that it's okay to be a woman who doesn't conform to feminine stereotypes. I'm just me.
Here is a timeline of my journey:
My Age | Event |
---|---|
12-13 | Started puberty, felt intense discomfort and hated my developing breasts. |
16-17 | Spent a lot of time online, influenced by transition narratives. Identified as non-binary. |
18 | Came out as a transgender man, influenced by supportive friends. Started testosterone. |
20 | Realized my underlying depression and anxiety hadn't improved. Started doubting my transition. |
21 | Stopped testosterone. Began the process of social detransition. |
22 | Found a therapist specializing in detransition. Began to understand my body dysmorphia and other issues. |
Present (23) | Living as a detransitioned female. Identifying as a masculine woman/crossdresser. |
Top Comments by /u/CrownOfBabel:
A lot of the time transition is advertised as feel-good magic that solves all of a person's problems and sadness. Don't feel like yourself or like you belong in your own body? Transition will help! The issue is, sex dysphoria isn't the only health issue out there that can cause those feelings.
There's body dysmorphia, eating disorders, sexual or childhood trauma, and BPD to name a few that can all manifest those feelings of disliking one's body or not feeling like themselves. Really anything that causes dissociation symptoms can, too. It's not that these people are prescribed medical transition to treat those specific conditions though, they have those conditions but are misdiagnosed as dysphoric because the symptoms sound too similar the way they have been described. Probably also because the diagnostic criteria for dysphoria and transitioning is too loose and floaty now. If it really tightened up and got specific about only being for feelings of sex dysphoria and defining what sex dysphoria is and what constitutes it and what does not, maybe there wouldn't be as many cracks for misdiagnosed people to fall through. This kind of crack-down on being honest, specific, and direct is needed or we are gonna keep seeing more and more detransitioners, which means more people who were hurt and broken by the transition clinic system than there are people who were helped by it. A net loss of happiness and net gain of misery.
I really do feel terrible for all the misdiagnosed people out there though, especially the kids. A misdiagnosis of something that severe and permanent can seriously break your trust, especially with doctors and medical professionals, and it's not at all an easy thing to go through.
I'm very sorry to hear that you've been struggling like this, and that people have been treating you poorly on top of it. I wish I could give you some answers or magic to make things better for you and solve this, because especially when you are dysphoric it's all very very complicated and not simple to figure out.
The only thing I can try is asking you questions and hope that it sparks something helpful in your thoughts, maybe offer some advice but no promises on if that advice will be helpful to your situation specifically or not, but it's worth a try!
Maybe start considering, deeply, why you like having a beard and being male-presenting. You like being perceived as male? Is it because it's subconsciously tied to that you like how you are treated better when you are seen as male, and dislike how you are treated when you are seen (or attempting to be seen) as female? Is being seen as male an escape for the feelings of humiliation and inadequacy, the feeling of (I assume, correct me if I'm wrong) failing as a female? I know it's much easier said than done, but at the end of the day regardless how people treat you or how you look, you are still female. That's not something the meanest bully in the world could take away from you. Just because you don't fit what people think of when they think of the word 'female' or 'woman' doesn't mean they are the ones who decide whether or not you are that. It'll be hard to work through that factor of social rejection, but I think once you carry yourself with confidence and hold strength in the truth, it'll hopefully make a difference for the better.
As for dealing with dysphoria... I'm not sure. That would definitely be something to find a therapist or counsellor of some sort for, since it's a medical/mental health topic. It's unfortunate your current one isn't helping much with it. I'm also someone who still has dysphoria and probably still will after detransitioning, so it's possible that you won't get a clean slate with no problems either way, no matter what path you choose you'll still have some kind of emotional boogeyman looming over your shoulder that you'll have to turn and face eventually. I think it's a matter of picking your battles and choosing which boogeyman you'd rather fight.
No matter what you choose and where you go from here, good luck to you! Remember it's okay if you make a decision that seemed right at first but turned out to be a mistake. Keep moving forward and keep your health and happiness at the forefront of your mind.
Yeah, I was thinking either tomboy or crossdresser, or both. I lean more towards crossdresser because that feels like it fits me better since 'tomboy' can pretty much mean any degree of masculinity and lots of women who are tomboys are still feminine in some way like in hairstyle, clothing, makeup, speech mannerisms, etc. and I feel introducing myself as a crossdresser would give people a clearer idea of what to expect of just how masculine I am. I'm sure I'll figure it out through trial and error! I think the best bet would to look for a therapist that specifically does work with detransitioners, and preferably only detransitioners and not current transgenders. That might be a needle in a haystack find though, especially when considering insurance coverages and all that!
Anyway, thank you for your kind words. :)
Hm, I think it'd be best to go to a doctor about this, an endocrinologist if you can. Maybe even the doctor that gave/prescribed you the shot in the first place. It could be good to go back and tell them you're not sure it was the right choice, hopefully they will do their duty as healthcare providers and help you figure out how to reverse or combat it. Regardless of who you ask though it will be a matter of medical intervention if you want to try and undo or minimize the effects of the shot.
This is a lovely idea! I just have one question, are you only looking for poems with subjects about or relating to the experience of being a desisted/detrans/etc woman, or can the subject of the poem be anything so long as the author is a desisted/detrans/etc woman?