This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
This account appears authentic. The comments display a deeply personal, nuanced, and emotionally complex narrative of transition, detransition, and ongoing identity struggle. The language is inconsistent, self-contradictory, and deeply introspective in a way that is highly characteristic of a genuine human grappling with these experiences, not a bot or troll. There are no serious red flags suggesting inauthenticity.
About me
I started transitioning as a teenager because I felt deep jealousy of men and thought becoming one would solve my problems with rejection and make me happy. My journey was driven by internalized homophobia and low self-esteem, and I rushed into taking testosterone because I felt suicidal. I realized I didn't have to be a man to be a whole person or to love women, and that transitioning made me more isolated and insecure. I stopped hormones after finding someone who accepted me, but my body is now permanently changed and androgynous. I'm healing now and just consider myself me, embracing all parts of my story to feel whole again.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender started when I was a teenager. I never felt like a girl and I felt a deep jealousy of male love interests in the media and in my life. I had this idea that if I were a guy, I would never need the people who rejected me, and I would finally be gendered correctly. I was only right about the second part. I used to think, "I'm not in the wrong body; I'm in the wrong society," but that changed when I developed crippling discomfort with my body and became desperate to transition.
A big part of my motivation was internalised homophobia and a deep-seated low self-esteem. I was attracted to women, but I could only be comfortable with romance if I put myself in the place of a man. I felt like being a guy would solve all my problems with rejection. I had a boyfriend who broke up with me when I came out as trans, and that rejection sent me into a spiral. I progressively destroyed my own liveliness after that. I wanted to find someone who would accept me, but I kept getting rejected, so I felt like the problem was me. I thought if I were happy with my physical self, I would stop chasing people.
I started presenting as male and eventually took testosterone. I did everything rashly because I felt suicidal. I feared that if I didn't become a guy, I wouldn't be able to hold back those dark thoughts. I can't say what would have happened without it, but I am still alive. At the time, I was deeply involved in trans medicalist communities online. They convinced me that if I wasn't passing as male, it was because I wasn't trying hard enough. I took T for months after I realized I didn't like looking like a man because I was worried about not being a "real" trans person and not deserving respect.
Taking testosterone was a turning point, but not in the way I expected. The weirdest thing was that after taking T, I realized how significant women were to me. I saw that I was very attracted to them, but also that women could have fulfilling lives. I realized I didn't have to want pregnancy just because I'm female, and I didn't have to let guys treat me like another species. I saw that I could have found love without making myself physically androgynous.
I also realized I wasn't "free" like I thought I would be. I feared if I was being a guy correctly and worried about aging. Even though people stopped calling me a lesbian, I felt I had to conform to straight male standards to not be seen as weird. My social life crashed. I felt like everybody thought I was ugly, weird, and a creep. I had been considered attractive before transitioning, and I pushed those people away because I wanted to be a guy. Now, I just wanted my old life back, before I got bogged down by my perceptions of femininity and masculinity.
I stopped taking testosterone after I reconnected with someone who liked me for who I was all along, regardless of my transition. I'm now trying to heal my view of life. My body is permanently changed. I sound like a 14-year-old boy on the phone, and my appearance is weirdly androgynous. I don't pass for a usual woman. Transitioning and detransitioning caused major setbacks. I became more isolated, developed body image issues I never had before, and got into a toxic relationship. I literally don't sound or look like myself because I wanted to become like the guys who rejected me.
I regret not valuing myself and my future enough. I struggle with dissociation and avoidance worse than ever. I don't feel that I am cis or trans. My transition to male will always be part of my story. I take a holistic approach where all versions of myself are me to avoid dissociation. I am both the girl I was before and the boy I was during transition. To deny either feels like erasing my life. Now I am just me. My body is female and androgynous, and I am myself. I only consider myself nonbinary now because calling myself a woman hurts old wounds, and I'm not female in the same way I was as a girl.
Age | Event |
---|---|
Around 17 | First boyfriend broke up with me after I came out as trans. This started a period of deep depression and desperation. |
17 | Began socially transitioning to male and presenting as male. |
17 | Started taking testosterone (T), partly due to suicidal feelings and pressure from online transmed communities. |
17 | Continued taking T for months after realizing I didn't like the masculine changes, due to fear of not being a "real" trans person. |
17 | Stopped taking T after reconnecting with a supportive partner. Began the process of detransition. |
Present (18?) | Living with a permanently changed, androgynous appearance and voice. Identifying as nonbinary as I heal. |
Top Comments by /u/DrawnonBlue:
I'm sorry for you. He's not into you so I advise you cut off hope that it's going to last. Perhaps he's trying to hold on because deep down you're the same person and looks aren't forever and all, but this can't feasibly work if he's not interested in the present version of you.
I think the transmed communities can convince people to transition more than the alternatives. In the mainstream trans communities, it's more acceptable to have a stance where you choose to not physically transition ever.
Transmeds believe those who actively want to change their bodies and pass are the only real trans people and therefore kids like me who weren't called goddamn he/him-young man-sir enough start thinking "It's because I didn't try hard enough to pass. If I looked like a 'real' trans guy, my parents/friends would accept me."
My situation was odd because I'd push away the few people who did accept me at the time, but I think that especially for a lonely and mentally ill teenager (which half of transmeds are), just being accepted by a few people isn't enough. It hurt me a lot that nobody wanted to date me, and of course I jumped to thinking I just need to be physically male and then I'd be content.
Stupidly, the opposite happened to me. People thought I was attractive for the first and only time in my life and then I pushed them away because I wanted to be a guy. First boyfriend broke up with me because I came out as trans. I also started looking more masculine solely in an attempt to pass as male.
Now I want to just live my old life because people liked me then.
I don't feel that I am cis or trans. My transition to male will always be part of my life's story and I've taken a holistic approach where all versions of myself are me to avoid the dissociation I've been struggling with for so long. I am both the girl I was before transitioning and the boy I was when I transitioned. To deny either feels like erasing my life. Now I am just me. My body is female and androgynous, and I am myself.
My feelings of dysphoria were weren't enough to convince me to transition before I stopped medication. I believe I started presenting as male and eventually taking T during manic episodes. Being in certain trans communities at the time didn't help. There are so many things I wrote that document how I was nonsensical at times, suicidal, and had crazy schemes on how I'd reinvent myself and become likable. I also repeatedly confessed romantic feelings for people and had mental outbursts which all managed to tie into how I should become a man.
I was personally really jealous of men and so I could only be comfortable with romance if I put myself in the place of a man. Gay/bi men are the only guy who are attracted to this idealized version of myself, though I also liked plenty of straight ones.
I progressively destroyed my liveliness ever since I was broken up with for coming out as trans. I wanted to find the person who would accept me, but kept getting rejected, so I felt like it was a problem with me and I would stop chasing people if I were happy with my physical self. I did everything trying to pass as male and be accepted or liked back to no avail which is how I ended up taking T as a last resort. I did everything rashly because I felt suicidal and feared that one day I wouldn't be able to hold back the thoughts if I didn't become a guy. I can't say what would've happened without it, but I am still alive.
Eventually, I reconnected with someone who liked me for who I was/am all along regardless of transition. Stopped T and am slowly trying to heal my view of life.
They act as if people who detransition never felt pain or cannot relate when some of us have gone through dozens of different battles and still face the similar adversity to trans people.
Like, wow. Just because I was born a girl doesn't mean I can just be a woman in the way most women are. Not to mention that if I didn't believe I wanted to be male for most of my life, I would've never transitioned.
Your voice will change if you take any of that stuff. Can't confirm if it'd be any slower or not, but it will. At best, you just sound like you will a less expressive voice.
I wanted the same thing but realized I did not like looking like a man. Still continued to take T for months after concerned about not being a "real" trans person and therefore not deserving to be respected as male socially.
I am happy that, for some people, it stops them from undergoing medical changes they do not want. It's better than the other side where you'll have people feeling pressured to transition to fit in with cisgender people. If I didn't become absorbed with trans medical stuff I literally would've grown out of it in a year or two.