genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/GatzbyMink's Detransition Story

Detransitioned: 21
female
low self-esteem
internalised homophobia
hated breasts
regrets transitioning
homosexual
puberty discomfort
started as non-binary
only transitioned socially
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or an inauthentic actor.

The comments demonstrate:

  • A consistent, detailed, and personal narrative about detransition/desistance, body image, and finding identity through butch lesbian communities.
  • Internal coherence across multiple posts over time, with consistent themes and a clear, evolving perspective.
  • Emotional nuance that aligns with the expected passion and frustration of someone who has experienced this journey, including anger at gender roles and concern for children.

The account does not exhibit the repetitive, generic, or agenda-driven posting that would indicate a troll or bot. The perspective is specific and personal.

About me

I started out as a teenage girl who was so uncomfortable with my developing body that I thought I had to become a man to be my true, masculine self. My journey was really about struggling with being a gay woman and thinking transition was the only way to be accepted. Everything changed when I found a community of butch lesbians who showed me I could be both fully female and completely masculine. Now I'm at peace, living as a woman who is comfortable in her own body and expresses herself in a masculine way. I've even kept my male name, and my only regret is not having these strong female role models when I was younger.

My detransition story

My whole journey with gender started when I was really uncomfortable with my body, especially when I started developing breasts. I hated them. I felt like they were in the way and stopped me from being who I really was, which was a masculine person. I thought that to be free and to be seen as masculine, I had to be a man. I started identifying as a trans man. I even changed my name to a male one, which I've actually decided to keep.

A huge part of my struggle came from internalized homophobia. I'm a homosexual woman, but for a long time, I hid that by channeling my feelings into being trans. It was easier to think I was a straight man than to accept being a butch lesbian. I also had really low self-esteem and I think I saw being a "boy" as a social position that meant freedom, while being a girl felt like a set of restrictions.

What really changed everything for me was finding a community of butch lesbians. Seeing women who were bodybuilders, who wore suits, who were strong and confident in male-dominated jobs completely shifted my perspective. They were masculine, but they were women. They weren't ashamed of their bodies. They proved to me that being female wasn't an obstacle to anything I wanted to do. I saw that my body was strong and that there was nothing inherently feminine or taboo about it just because I had breasts. I started working out shirtless at home, just getting used to my own body, and my mind started to change.

I had been on a waiting list to see an endocrinologist about taking hormones. But after surrounding myself with these strong, gender-nonconforming women, my dysphoria just vanished. I saw that I could achieve my workout goals without testosterone. When the doctor finally called me after months of waiting, I told him I didn't need his help anymore.

I stopped using a binder and other things I was doing to look more male. Now, even though I dress extremely masculine, people see me as a woman, and I'm okay with that. The judgment is real, but it's not worth being someone you're not just to please others. I've had to unlearn a lot of what society taught me about gender. I see the world in a more simple, physical way now. Being a woman is just being an adult human female. How you express yourself—masculine, feminine, or in-between—is totally up to you.

I don't regret my transition journey because it led me to where I am now. It was a process I needed to go through to understand myself. I'm at peace with being a butch woman. My main regret is that I didn't have these kinds of role models growing up. I get worried for kids today who are pushed into strict gender roles, like the little girl I saw being steered away from a Spider-man bike towards a pink one. I think if more kids could see happy, gender-nonconforming adults, they would feel less like they are abnormal.

Here is a timeline of my journey:

Age Event
Early Teens Started feeling intense discomfort with my body and breasts during puberty.
Late Teens Began identifying as a trans man, socially transitioned, and changed my name to a male one.
20 Was on a waiting list for an endocrinologist to discuss testosterone.
21 Found a community of butch lesbians; my perspective on gender and my body began to change.
21 My body dysphoria vanished; I cancelled my appointment with the endocrinologist and stopped identifying as trans.
Present (21+) Living as a butch lesbian woman, comfortable in my body, and keeping my male name.

Top Comments by /u/GatzbyMink:

12 comments • Posting since March 9, 2023
Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) explains how social expectations and gender roles can cause body resentment and sex dysphoria in children, arguing that a girl who is forced to cover up at puberty may develop jealousy toward male agency and a desire to escape sexualization.
32 pointsApr 17, 2023
View on Reddit

I'm not sure, but maybe those kids say "I want to be a boy/girl" because the things they like and resonate with the most are traditionally attached to the opposite sex. And they might be aware that they're not the opposite sex, so they feel like they can't be just the same in their own body since they're not expected the same stuff, nor treated the same, which cause distress about not fitting in.

Take for example a young girl who loves running shirtless with her male friends and when puberty hits her, she's asked to hide her body, to wear a bra, to stop being shirtless outside. That's a big change to adapt to and not understanding why might cause resentment towards one's body and womanhood in general. Jealousy toward male agency might happen as well, the desire to have a flat chest so you could "be just like them/free of a burden and sexualisation".

And more the kid is being forced into a role they don't like and their desires ignored, more sex dysphoria grow to the point of detaching themselves totally from their body and feeling a strong attachment to the body of those who are treated differently than they are. Everything about them tend to appear "greener". Growing up without being told that a girl can do the same as boys, simply being normalized by the sight of a woman's nudity without any sexual or maternal connotation because a woman shouldn't have a "context" to be shirtless, can play a huge role in sex dysphoria.

We should tell them that being a girl is more than they might think. That there's nothing wrong with them and that the world is just mad about girls being their authentic self. Having gender nonconforming role models could be really helpful as well, as it visually proves to those kids that people like them exist and are happy just the way they are as women and men.

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) discusses witnessing gender role enforcement, from a coworker afraid to buy "women's" jeans to a mother steering her daughter away from a Spider-man bike.
25 pointsApr 19, 2023
View on Reddit

You know. Today I had to tolerate my coworkers making comments about how certain clothes were "for boys" and others "for girls". One of them was interested in a pair of Jean and then paused, asking us if it was for women. We didn't know what to tell him. I personally just said it was just jeans, so either. But he ended up not taking them as if he was afraid of something. Stigma? Nobody would have ever noticed. Probably knowing it certainly was not "for men" felt wrong to him. But why is it wrong?

Another thing I noticed. A little girl with her mother. The mother pushed the girl to go towards the little pinky bike, but she ran for the Spider-man one. The mother ended up feeling uncomfortable and led her again to the pink one. If there's something wrong, it's clearly gender roles.

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) comments on the social pressure to transition, explaining that as a butch woman she is now seen as female despite her masculine presentation after stopping binders and makeup.
24 pointsMar 11, 2023
View on Reddit

I'm a butch woman. I dress extremely masculine. After stopping using a binder and stuff to thicken my eyebrow/sideburns, I started to be seen as a woman regardless of my gender presentation. The judgment is real, but is it really worth being someone you're not to please others?

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) explains why David Reimer became suspicious of his assigned gender, citing his artificial genitals and unexplained doctor visits.
16 pointsApr 13, 2023
View on Reddit

To be honest I think he started to get suspicious because his artificial genitals weren't like the others. Not only that, but visiting a doctor you don't even know why? His parents probably lied to him about why he would go there, but a teenager isn't stupid

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) explains how coping with gender dysphoria involved getting comfortable being shirtless and reframing their view of the female body by surrounding themselves with butch lesbians.
14 pointsMar 9, 2023
View on Reddit

For me, it was about getting comfortable being uncomfortable by being used to my naked body. I would workout shirtless, clean the house shirtless, cook shirtless. My mind has changed its way of thinking about the female body when I started to surround myself with butch lesbians. It made me understand that there's nothing inherently feminine or taboo about my body simply for having breasts. And I could behave however I want without being ashamed of them being in the way. They're a part of me. If it's too hard for you right now, you can start with wearing just a sports bra.

It did go away for me.

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) explains that being a woman is an inherent, expansive identity that cannot be taken away, especially for GNC and biracial individuals.
11 pointsApr 27, 2023
View on Reddit

Desisted biracial here 🖐🏼 I know it can be hard to think that you're not "worthy" to be a woman when you're gnc, but something I've understood for the last months is that being a woman isn't something someone can take away from you. It's more than who we are or what we identify. It's what we are. In the goods and the bads. But it doesn't mean that we can't be who we want to be, woman is expansive 💪🏼

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) comments on feeling powerless watching children in gender-affirming scenarios, fearing they lack the maturity to understand the long-term consequences.
10 pointsApr 19, 2023
View on Reddit

That's what I'm fearing. Growing up made me feel so concerned for kids. Seeing them and their parents in those kind of scenarios reminds me of when I was a kid myself. I didn't had the maturity to notice how wrong those actions were. Now that I do, I feel so powerless and it hurts to see those stuff and knowing most people won't take them into account, thinking it doesn't have any consequences because they're doing "what's right".

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) explains how finding butch lesbian community cured her dysphoria by showing her that being female wasn't an obstacle to her goals.
5 pointsApr 2, 2023
View on Reddit

I had internalized homophobia and taking steps in the lesbian community completely changed my views around gender and sexes. I saw women who were body builders, women with short hair in whole suits who walked into rooms like they were the boss and worked in male dominated careers. Women who understood this masculine feeling that I had and they weren't ashamed or trying to hide their bodies because of it. They were embracing that side of them and proving that there were no barriers between men and women. Them being a working class, it also helped me feel more connected to them.

Interacting in those spaces more helped me change the way I perceived my body. How strong it was. That being female wasn't an obstacle to my goals.

Butch women were the representations I needed growing up and that's really the only thing I wish for our future. To see more gender nonconforming people in this world. Sometimes, that's the only thing a kid wish to see. That they're not abnormal for desiring something unusual.

After a while, my dysphoria simply totally vanished. Even if at first I had a hard time believing I could have the workout goals I wanted without hormones, I saw women who prove me otherwise so when my endocrinologist finally called after months of waiting, I responded that I didn't need him anymore.

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) comments about using transness to hide her homosexuality before accepting her identity as a gay woman.
4 pointsApr 5, 2023
View on Reddit

I can understand how confusing things can be after a while of being used to an identity. Being homosexual is a really complex process sometimes and it personally took me years of hiding mine through transness to finally accept it and live as an homosexual woman.

Take your time, really.

Reddit user GatzbyMink (desisted female) explains how embracing female masculinity and learning about butch women helped them accept being a gender non-conforming woman, advising on names, pronouns, and redefining female titles.
3 pointsApr 3, 2023
View on Reddit

To me, it was really helpful to do a lot of research about butch women. Those women are openly masculine individuals who, just like you and I, prefer masculine roles/clothes/habits and so on. Seeing them in my day to day life helped me change the way I perceived women and what was possible as a woman. Being a woman is literally just being an adult human female. The rest is up to you to decide. Whether you want to express yourself in a masculine, androgynous or feminine way, female doesn't equal feminine.

There's also a bunch of gnc women in the media and history who helped me accept my female masculinity: Stormé Delarverie, Oscar François in The Rose of Versailles, A league of their own (have a lot of butch women, but Max Chapman was my favourite), Tegan and Sara (lesbian singers who present masculine as hell), Alison Bechdel (She created a comic about dykes and seeing her being her most authentic butch self is a blessing)

I changed my name to a male one when I was still identifying as a trans man and I decided to keep it that way. A male name for a woman doesn't mean you're not possibly one because that's something biological. No one can take that away from you, so you're not entitled to one way to behave. Thinking out of the box will makes you critical of the stereotypes and the oppressions imposed on you and accepting this as a part of your reality helps to say 'No, I'm not okay with it' rather than 'If I'm not a woman, it doesn't concern me' Because it will concern you regardless.

For pronouns, it's not going to be easy. Preferring he/him might be because you think it'll make you more masculine, which is the base of internalized misogyny (insinuating that she/her is feminine). When in reality, pronouns are just there to tell which sex you are. It won't make you more masculine/feminine as a person and what might make you feel uncomfortable is how people will perceive you/treat you because of their own sexism. You go gradually, maybe switching for she/her with masculine adjectives and male titles at first. You don't have to fit perfectly. I love titles such as king and gentleman and I keep using handsome for example. When I think of some female titles, I think of them as me being in a cross-dress version of that title: a princess dressed as a prince.

At the end of the day, even if female titles have historical meanings and ideas behind them, you, by default, can subvert them simply by existing. You have the right to reappropriate those words in your own way.

I also invite you to connect with some radfem/gender critical people. They're really supportive of gender nonconformity and detransitioners. They also have a whole bag of wonderful historical women who will help you unpack a lot of stuff born from misogyny and heterosexism.

EDIT: If you're a workout fanatic, I suggest you Samanthacmjefferson on Instagram