genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Kaiayos's Detransition Story

female
low self-esteem
depression
influenced online
anxiety
only transitioned socially
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user's perspective is nuanced, self-reflective, and consistent with a desister's experience (someone who questioned their gender but did not medically transition). They express empathy, acknowledge their own uncertainty, and focus on the complexity of gender dysphoria and the permanence of medical procedures, which are common and genuine concerns within the detrans/desister community.

About me

My journey started with a long, confusing period of deep uncertainty, spent mostly in online communities. I strongly believe many people, including myself, can confuse issues like depression for a need to transition, and I was terrified of making a permanent mistake. I came to see that you can't change your biological sex and that transitioning can't fix social problems, only physical discomfort. I never took any permanent medical steps, and I'm now grateful for my extreme caution. My biggest takeaway is that these decisions need immense time and self-reflection, not pressure.

My detransition story

My entire journey with gender has been a long and confusing one, built on a foundation of deep uncertainty. I spent a lot of time in online communities, reading and thinking, and my own views were always mixed. I never felt like I had a clear answer for myself or for anyone else.

I strongly believe that a lot of people, maybe including myself, confuse other issues for gender dysphoria. I think depression and body issues can feel a lot like the desire to transition, but they aren't the same thing. For me, the big question was always: if you can't actually change your biological sex, is it even worth all the trouble? I desperately wished I could just be happy living as I was born, but I was also terrified of living a life filled with dysphoria, always wondering if I had passed up a chance to feel better.

My thoughts on gender are that it's mostly about the body. I don't think your personality, your likes and dislikes, or who you look up to have anything to do with it. Transitioning can only treat the physical discomfort of feeling like your body is wrong; it can't fix problems with fitting in or finding your place in the world. In fact, I think trying to live up to a new set of gender roles can sometimes make those social problems even worse. Gender roles themselves seem like a toxic part of society that cause nothing but pain.

Because of this, I was always very cautious about medical procedures. I feel that surgeries are pushed too hard and should be an absolute last resort, something you only do when you are one hundred percent sure. Hormones have some permanent effects, but surgery is almost impossible to undo. I remember feeling so much pain for others who had surgeries and then regretted them, knowing how expensive and difficult it is to even try to reverse things.

I saw a lot of pain in the online communities I was in, and it hurt me to see people being met with negativity or condescending answers when they were just looking for help. I always believed that the priority should be caring for people, not pushing an ideology.

Looking back, I don't have a simple story of starting hormones and then stopping. My experience was more of a long, internal debate. I never felt sure enough to take any permanent medical steps, and I'm grateful for that now. I think putting off transition to really think it through is some of the best advice I could have given or received. I don't regret being so cautious, and I don't regret my transition because, for me, it was mostly a social and internal process that I ultimately stepped back from. My biggest takeaway is that these decisions need time, deep self-reflection, and extreme care, especially when it comes to irreversible surgeries.

Age Year Event
N/A 2018-2019 A period of intense online engagement and internal questioning about gender and transition. No permanent medical steps were taken.

Top Comments by /u/Kaiayos:

6 comments • Posting since October 22, 2018
Reddit user Kaiayos explains their struggle with the decision to detransition, questioning if medical transition is worth it if gender cannot truly be changed and expressing fear of living a life with dysphoria.
9 pointsJul 5, 2019
View on Reddit

To be honest, I feel exactly the same way.

If you cannot truly change your gender, is it even worth the trouble?

I would love to be able to just live as I was born and be perfectly happy with it, but I also do not want to end up living my entire life with dysphoria knowing that I gave up a chance to relieve that pain early on in my life.

Life is rough and uncertainty does not help.

I wish that I could offer you advice, but I suppose that I am in the same boat as you. All I can do is let you know that you are not alone in your ordeal.

Reddit user Kaiayos explains why surgeries should be a last resort in transition, discusses the permanence of procedures, and offers advice on potential future transplants and career options to a detransitioning user.
6 pointsOct 22, 2018
View on Reddit

I really wish that surgeries were not pushed so hard.

Surgeries should be considered the end-game, and only done when the recipient is absolutely, one-hundred percent sure that they want it.

HRT can have some permanent effects, but is still mostly reversible through de-transitioning. Surgeries, however, are not so easily undone.

I am sorry that you have to go through this.

If it is any help, you can look into research being done on penis and scrotum transplants. They are still very early-on with their research, with only one operation being done, as far as I am aware. But, it would be much better than a phalloplasty, in my opinion.

Obviously, all of the medical procedures required to de-transition cost even more money on top of what you had to spend to transition in the first place. In your position, I assume that is not really money you have to spend freely.

I would hold out hope though.

While it is much easier to get a job with a degree, there are still ways to get good jobs with only a high-school diploma/GED.

Reddit user Kaiayos comments on a supportive post, advocating for prioritizing care over ideology in the detrans community.
6 pointsOct 15, 2019
View on Reddit

Thank you for this comment.

Even if it was not directed towards me, it means so much to me.

I see a lot of people post here, and I can feel the pain in their words.

And when I see some responses that are very negative, sometimes even sounding condescending, it hurts even more.

I think that it is important to remind everyone that this is a subreddit to help people.

Everyone is allowed to have their own views, but the first priority should be caring for those who need help, not pushing ideology onto others.

So, once again, thank you so much for your comment.

Reddit user Kaiayos explains that while transitioning can treat body dysphoria, it cannot solve issues with personality, fitting in, or societal gender roles, and advises careful reconsideration.
5 pointsDec 10, 2019
View on Reddit

I am probably not the best person to give an answer for this, but I would like to tell you what I think, if that is okay.

Personally, if transitioning would truly make someone happier, I am all for it. And while it is true that changing your sex is impossible (as of now), that does not mean that transition should be ruled out as an option for people who might want it.

Now, with that being said, I also think that gender dysphoria is a body issue. I do not think that anything in regards to likes, dislikes, preferences, role-models, relations, activities, feelings, et cetera has anything to do with gender dysphoria.
Or rather, the only thing that transitioning can treat is the body issues. Feeling uncomfortable with your body being feminine might be reason to consider transition as an option.

However, issues with fitting in or looking for role-models will not be solved with transition. In fact, sometimes they can even be made worse.
And while I digress a bit slightly, I think that finding female or male role-models should not be an issue concerning gender. People should be allowed to look up to whoever they want (hopefully someone worth looking up to) regardless of either of their genders.

On top of that, gender roles are, in my opinion, a very toxic part of society. They lead to nothing but unhappiness and I think that doing your best to unlearn all of them is important.
But, keeping back with your dilemma, transitioning cannot solve any issues that you may have with how you feel about your personality, only issues that you have with your body.

I will not say whether transitioning is the right choice for you because, to be honest, I do not really know. And even if I did, I do not think that I have the responsibility to tell you something like that.
The issues you have with your personality and society make me want to suggest continuing to rethink your mindset before considering transition.
Yet, your legitimate concerns about your body would be a reason to look into transition.

I do not really know what the best answer is.
I am sorry.
I know that I did not really answer your question, I mostly just wanted to share my mindset on the matter and hope that it could provide anything of worth to you.

Regardless, if I had to give any answer, I would at least put transitioning off for a few more years. Testosterone is very powerful, so the effects can still change your body a lot even after you get older. Meanwhile, you can have more time to think and see if there are any possible alternatives.

Reddit user Kaiayos explains why some people detransition, citing the exhausting effort of constantly performing a gender role as being like "forced to wear a costume all the time."
4 pointsOct 27, 2018
View on Reddit

For some people, the work of having to consciously put an effort to appear as your preferred gender everyday is just too much for them.
It is not that they feel they are pretending to be the other gender, but when you have to act and dress a certain way all the time, lest people not see you as your prefer, it can feel a lot like being forced to wear a costume all the time.
Life can become restricting, and while they do still feel dysphoric, it becomes too much for them, and they feel it would be easier to deal with their dysphoria in other ways.

That being said, I have never actually experienced it, so take what I say with a grain of salt, but that would be my assumption on the matter.

Reddit user Kaiayos explains why they believe some people confuse depression for gender dysphoria, and that the two conditions are usually separate.
3 pointsJun 16, 2019
View on Reddit

I think that a lot of people confuse their depression for gender dysphoria, or are possibly suggested that by other people.

To be honest, I do not even think that gender dysphoria and depression go hand-in-hand.

I think that they are usually pretty separate, although I could be wrong about that.