genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Manuerafa2's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 13 -> Detransitioned: 14
female
depression
influenced online
influenced by friends
puberty discomfort
started as non-binary
anxiety
benefited from non-affirming therapy
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user's story is highly detailed and internally consistent, revolving around their professional experience as a nurse in a gender clinic and their personal experience as the mother of a gender-confused daughter. The language is nuanced, emotionally varied (showing compassion, frustration, and expertise), and reflects the stated passion and anger common in the community. The advice given is specific, practical, and aligns with a desister/detransitioner perspective.

About me

I'm a mother and a former nurse from a gender clinic, and this started when my daughter began identifying as trans at 13. I knew this wasn't right for her because her distress seemed rooted in puberty and anxiety, not a true male identity. I focused on limiting her harmful online time and asking questions to help her think for herself instead of just affirming her. Now, she identifies as non-binary and her mental health is improving with proper treatment for her anxiety. I believe we need to help kids explore their feelings without pressure, and I'm just giving her the space to find her true self.

My detransition story

My journey with this started not with my own transition, but through my daughter. When she was around 13, she began to identify as non-binary and then started talking about being trans. This was incredibly difficult for me to watch, especially because of my professional background. For over a decade, I worked as a nurse in a clinic that was a leading center for gender and LGBTQ+ care. I saw firsthand the good that transition can do for the small number of people who truly need it. But with my daughter, I knew in my gut that this wasn't her path.

She never expressed a desire for a male name or male pronouns. She had no issues with her genitals or her periods. Her "dysphoria" seemed to come entirely from hating her developing breasts and feeling like she didn't fit in with other girls. She's a gamer, loves anime, and isn't into typical "girly" things like shopping or makeup. Online, she found a community that told her this meant she was trans. She was also struggling with anxiety and depression and was seeing a psychiatrist for it. I strongly believe her feelings were a mix of puberty discomfort, the pressure to fit in with a specific friend group, and the influence of spending too much time in online spaces that promote a very rigid view of gender.

It was a constant battle. She’d call me a "TERF" or a "boomer" if I even gently questioned anything. I couldn't outright ban her from the internet, so I had to subtly limit her exposure by getting her out of the house—taking her on errands with me, walking the dog, anything to connect in the real world. My strategy, which my own therapist agreed with, was to ask her the right questions to make her think for herself, not to preach at her. I wanted her to build her own conclusions. It was frustrating and heartbreaking to see her so influenced by what I saw as a kind of online cult, especially when a YouTuber she followed detransitioned and was immediately silenced and attacked.

Through all of this, my views on gender have solidified. I believe most people are simply gender non-conforming, and that's a beautiful thing. A woman can hate her breasts or love video games and still be a woman. I think we, as a society, are too quick to medicalize normal feelings of discomfort, especially in young people who are dealing with underlying issues like anxiety, depression, low self-esteem, or the effects of bullying. These kids need therapy and support to work through their problems, not just hormones and surgery. The pressure to immediately affirm any declaration of a trans identity without exploration is dangerous, and it silences any professional who tries to ask important questions.

I don’t regret my work at the clinic, as I know we helped people. But I deeply regret what is happening to a whole generation of kids, including my daughter, who are being led down a path that might not be right for them. I benefited immensely from non-affirming therapy myself—the kind that makes you ask "why?"—and I think everyone questioning their gender deserves that same space to explore without pressure.

My daughter is now identifying as non-binary, which I see as a step back from a full social transition. She's doing better with her anxiety and depression on medication, and I am just giving her time and space, hoping she will eventually find her true self. I have no regrets about advocating for her to slow down and think.

Here is a timeline of our journey:

My Age Event
13 My daughter begins to express gender confusion, influenced heavily by online friends and communities.
13 She is diagnosed with anxiety and depression and starts seeing a psychiatrist.
13 She adopts a non-binary, then a trans male identity, though she rejects male pronouns and a new name.
13-14 I work to gently question and engage her in critical thinking, while managing her online exposure.
14 She settles on a non-binary identity as her mental health stabilizes with treatment.

Top Comments by /u/Manuerafa2:

16 comments • Posting since February 6, 2020
Reddit user Manuerafa2 explains the importance of therapy and support for a detransitioning FtM individual, offering reassurance about hormonal recovery and resilience.
46 pointsFeb 10, 2020
View on Reddit

I strongly recommend therapy or some sort of support group, even ones that are not specific for trans youth (anxiety, depression, etc) . I know it’s difficult, and I don’t know if you have means to afford it... can you talk about this openly with your parents, ask for their help in this? If not, do you have friends that can be understanding and to whom you can open yourself and vent? I saw someone offering therapy in this sub too.

Hang in there, it is a journey to find yourself and although it hurts, you were brave enough to try it out and discovered that this is not for you. You are very young and your body and mind are much more resilient than you can even imagine. Your female hormones will kick in, just give time to your body to go back to normal testosterone (for females) levels. You’ll see and feel subtle changes within weeks. You are strong and it will get better

Edit for missing word

Reddit user Manuerafa2 (a nurse who worked in a Gender Dysphoria facility) explains that a detransitioning person's body needs time to detox from testosterone, and reassures them their appearance and voice will become more feminine again. They also discuss their view that a generation of girls questioning gender are being mishandled with medication instead of therapy.
31 pointsFeb 6, 2020
View on Reddit

I’m going to say to you what my therapist always say about my daughter: you (like her) are very young. Your body needs time to “detox” and your own hormones need time to reset. I’m also a nurse that worked in a Gender Dysphoria facility, so I can say that you will look less manly and more femjnine once all T is off of your system. Your voice will get higher, maybe not as pre-T as someone already mention, but you are going to see that your old you will be back. Be patient and be good to yourself, we all need time to heal. We sure have to be angry with reckless professionals and clinics, I’m anything but a transphobe, but I see that there’s a lot of mishandling of a generation of girls that question gender and society, and that we’re medicating people that really need therapy and support, not drugs and “drag”. You are brave and strong and very smart for figuring all by yourself, hang in there! You will feel better!

Reddit user Manuerafa2 comments on chest dysphoria, advising against top surgery for a user who is sometimes okay with being a woman, suggesting weight loss, breast reduction, or birth control instead.
23 pointsFeb 17, 2020
View on Reddit

I think you are not trans, since you have periods where you are ok with being a woman. It is totally possible to be female and have chest dysphoria. Some women hate their hips, their thighs .. why can’ t others hate their breasts? It’s one of those myths transactivism tries to sell - if you hate your breasts, you are trans !!! - and what about body dismorphic disorder? I think until you feel mentally stable and less confused, you shouldn’t go the mastectomy route. Weight loss and breast reduction may alleviate your anxiety. Did you get your period yet? Since it was bothering you when you were younger, and you just got out of T, it may be a good a idea to think about birth control pills to not have periods at least for now, it would be one less stressor. Baby steps. Breathe. Good luck

Reddit user Manuerafa2 offers support and suggests connecting with other detransitioned men who had surgery but are now living as men again.
19 pointsMar 28, 2020
View on Reddit

I’m so, so sorry you feel this way... i wish I could offer you more than my solidarity. I’ve read twice in this sub about two other detrans guys, if only they could show up here to talk to you... they were both operated too but were back living like men. I think talking to them will really help you having some hope and perspective for your life... Have you open up to your parents about how you feel ?

Reddit user Manuerafa2, a mother and former clinic worker, discusses her daughter's gender identity and the fear professionals have of being labeled transphobic for exploring underlying causes of dysphoria like low self-esteem, depression, and internalized homophobia in young women.
13 pointsFeb 7, 2020
View on Reddit

Me too, am a mom of a confused teenager girl (who says she’s not confused anymore - she’s identifying herself as a gender non-conforming person). And the irony of life is that I worked for 11 years in a clinic that is the reference for trans people in my town.. I am very proud of the inclusiveness and the results of our service as I do believe that are people whose only answer (and care) is to transition. That said, i can also affirm that most professionals are scared of being labeled transphobes just to mention that maybe low self esteem, depression, bullying, internalized homophobia, patriarchy and the position left for women in our society may be playing a role in so many young women developing gender dysphoria. I cannot be open to my daughter about these stories here yet, since she’s super sttuborn and “knows it all”, still using “terf” and “transphobe” for us, who there to question somethings, but she’s building her own opinions with tidbits of stuff I say to her. My goal is to ask her the right questions and make her see for herself. She kind ofrespect my view in these subjects (since I am a professional in this field), but she listens a lot to online stuff still, so we are taking baby steps getting there. But someday I wil present her all your stories, because you are not people like me, an outsider, you are the real deal, and your stories are so valid and important, I don’t think you know how much. So thank you, to all detransioners here, this generation will own to you this new chapter in caring for the youth

Reddit user Manuerafa2 advises a detransitioned teen to find new friends and hobbies after a failed attempt to discuss gender identity with a trans-activist peer group.
12 pointsFeb 20, 2020
View on Reddit

You did your best. As someone already said, you certainly planted a seed of doubt. I truly believe that, with teens, the best thing you can do is make them think, question and go away. Your job is done, because imature teenagers are too proud and too arrogant to accept the fact that the might be wrong! They have to found out by themselves, making mistakes in the vast majority of time, unfortunately. You were brave to try and find out your own identity and your truth, and very clever to figure it out by yourself, not everyone are this smart so soon in their lifes. It’s frustrating and an annoyance to see other people thinking like that, being so narrow and shallow and manipulated, but time will tell them, time will show them you are not a TERF. In the meantime, do not give up, you just started in this school. Try new activities at school, or even something religious, because it really gives you some social ground, and hope, for real.

I don’t think you should try again with this group, they are still too deep into the transactivism web, they will not be a healthy crowd to hang with. Do you like games? Or books? Or even Tv shows? Pets? Some sort of arts & crafts? Try to occupy yourself in something that distracts you, try to find people in your area with the same interests... idk, just be a little more patient, high school is really hard, adolescence is pretty hard, and it will definitely get better, sooner than you imagine. Good luck

Reddit user Manuerafa2 (RN with 10+ years in LGBTQ+ healthcare) explains why she believes her 13-year-old daughter, who displays Asperger's-like traits, is not truly trans but is instead influenced by online communities. She details her daughter's lack of classic dysphoria (no issue with name, pronouns, or female clothes) and attributes her identity to learning that not fitting feminine stereotypes means she is transgender.
11 pointsMar 3, 2020
View on Reddit

I’m right with you on this boat. My daughter was screen for ASD twice and didn’t “make the cut”. But she behaves so much like an aspie... and now, at 13, gender dysphoria hit her hard. I’m a RN and worked for 10+ years at a gender and LGBTQ+ reference facility, so... i cannot and won’t admit being called a TERF. But I can see clearly that my daughter isn’t trans but she thinks otherwise. She did not want to be call by male pronouns nor even pick a male name, she does not have gender dysphoria in the sense that she’e really fine being called by her birth name or using female clothes or having zero genital/period dysphoria. She just “learned” online that the fact that she “isn’t like other girls, doesn’t like shopping or make up, likes games and hates her breasts” makes her trans sight. I’m respecting her “phase” pointing whenever I can what I’ve learned working with trans people for 10 years... but you know, twitter and online friends know the best

Wish you luck and that our daughters snap out of this trans cult asap

Reddit user Manuerafa2 comments on the silencing of detransitioners, questioning why unbiased research into transition regret is labeled as transphobic.
7 pointsFeb 11, 2020
View on Reddit

To think that the vast majority of people that points this out and request research and responsible answers is labeled “transphobic” , silenced and ostracized makes me feel desperate and hopeless. Until when? Why can’t be a proper, unbiased study, even to “prove us wrong “ ? If this phenomenon doesn’t exist, what is the problem with that being scientifically stated? Trans activism needs to step back and think about real people’s lifes....and let everything be addressed responsably...

Reddit user Manuerafa2 advises detransitioning commenter that stopping testosterone can help if they aren't passing as male, encouraging them to take small steps and reminding them they are brave and still young.
6 pointsFeb 15, 2020
View on Reddit

If you are not passing as a male, than you are not past the point of no return (to female). You say your body isn’t masculine enough to passa! Quit T for awhile, in a few weeks you’ll see subtle changes that might make you feel more comfortable. If you feel more confident, come out to your closest friends, and if that lift a weight of your shoulder, go all the way. You are not a blob, you tried to be more comfortable in your skin, and that requires bravery and strength. You are stil finding yourself, you are only 23, there’s a lot of time and life ahead of you. Good luck!

Reddit user Manuerafa2 advises a questioning individual to stop testosterone, explore being gender non-conforming or non-binary, and prioritize their own comfort over social pressures.
5 pointsMar 8, 2020
View on Reddit

I think you are gender non conforming, and since you’d like to be a woman again, I would suggest to first stop T. I personally think that knowing you can be whatever you want is a very freeing feeling, and the non binary/gender fluid label should give some people some peace of mind or relieve the pressure about assuming binary gender roles. Whoever make you feel traped in one identity despite your desire to be of other is not a good company for you rn, avoid. Again, stop T, see how your body behaves, if you feel confortable with the changes that will come and then, think about the social transition thing. It’s your right, it’s uour life and your body!

Have you ever talk to your partner about this? Do you think he will be supportive or do you include him in the “people will hate me if I detransion” group?