genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Melody_Sparce's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 14 -> Detransitioned: 15
female
regrets transitioning
influenced by friends
became religious
started as non-binary
only transitioned socially
had religious background
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the comments provided, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user's perspective is consistent and develops over time, from personal struggle with identity to a specific, faith-based worldview. The language is nuanced, emotionally varied (anger, reflection, empathy), and includes personal, mundane details (like the armpit gland comment) that are atypical for a bot. The passion and political stance are aligned with genuine, strongly-held beliefs observed in the detransitioner community.

About me

I started identifying as genderfluid at 14 because my friends made it seem like the coolest thing to be and I desperately wanted to fit in. I began to question everything after learning about detransitioners and realizing the vast difference between trans women and biological women. Rediscovering my faith in God gave me the strength and peace I had been missing. I now see that my journey was really about a need to belong, and I'm working to embrace my womanhood and biological reality. I deeply regret ever advocating for policies that compromise the safety and privacy of women in their own spaces.

My detransition story

My whole journey with this started my freshman year of high school. I’m a junior now, so looking back, it feels like it happened both a long time ago and just yesterday. It all began because of my friends. I had a lot of LGBTQ friends, and they had a huge influence on me. Two of them, in particular, were the ones who really pushed the idea that I might be genderfluid. They made it seem like being transgender or homosexual was the coolest thing you could be. They had this idea that if thinking of yourself as the opposite sex gave you a feeling of euphoria, then that meant you were definitely trans. I never really understood that reasoning, even back then, but I went along with it because I wanted to fit in and be accepted.

For a few months, I identified as genderfluid. I remember getting really angry about things like trans women being told they couldn't use the women's restroom. At the time, I saw it as a huge injustice. But now, I see it completely differently. I can't believe I ever thought it was okay for a male to feel entitled to female spaces. We have separate spaces for a reason—for safety, privacy, and comfort. It’s about protecting women. The whole thing feels surreal now; sometimes I think I’ll wake up and it will have all been a crazy dream.

I started to pull myself out of that mindset after I learned about detransitioners. Watching Matt Walsh’s documentary, "What is a Woman?", was a big moment for me. It really highlighted for me that there’s a vast, undeniable difference between trans women and biological women. When I tried to talk to one of those friends about this new perspective and the trends I was seeing—like how it seems to be mostly emo, socially awkward female kids who are identifying this way—she completely dismissed me. She argued that detransitioners were "only, like, one or two people." It was so frustrating because she would talk about the importance of minorities, but then completely ignore this one.

A huge part of my journey has been my faith. I grew up in church, but for years I ran from God, telling myself I didn’t believe. But last year, I found peace in Him again. It was like I was talking to Him with every step I took, even when I was trying to walk away. Accepting God back into my life was the best decision I’ve ever made. It gave me a strength and a peace I didn’t have before. Now, I pray every day that others who are suffering can find that same peace.

Looking back, I think a lot of my initial push to identify as something else was wrapped up in a need to belong and the influence of the people around me. I never took hormones or had any surgeries; my transition was entirely social. I’m grateful for that now. I’ve had to really work on redefining what womanhood means to me, which has been a hard task. I realize now that I may have pushed these ideas on people close to me, and that’s a hard thing to face.

I don’t regret exploring my identity because it led me to where I am now, which is a much more secure and peaceful place. But I do regret being so easily influenced and for not thinking more critically about the consequences of what I was advocating for, especially when it came to women's spaces. I now believe that while an individual trans person might have innocent intentions, the movement as a whole is forgetting the fundamental reasons we have sex-separated spaces, which is to protect women.

My thoughts on gender are that it is fundamentally tied to sex. The line between a trans man/woman and a biological man/woman is vast. For me, rediscovering my own womanhood has been about embracing my biological reality and finding strength in that.

Here is a timeline of my journey:

My Age Event
14 (Freshman year) Was influenced by friends and began identifying as genderfluid.
14 (Later that year) Learned about detransitioners and watched "What is a Woman?"; began to question my identity.
15 Stopped identifying as genderfluid and fully detransitioned socially.
16 Found peace and renewed my faith in God.
16 (Present) Gaining a clearer understanding of womanhood and the importance of female-only spaces.

Top Comments by /u/Melody_Sparce:

8 comments • Posting since December 27, 2022
Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) explains her changed perspective on male access to female spaces, arguing it's an entitlement that compromises women's safety and comfort for the sake of validation.
44 pointsJul 16, 2024
View on Reddit

When I identified as gender fluid for a few months my freshmen year of high school, I remember how angry I would get when trans women were told to stay out of the women's restroom. At the time, I saw no problem with it. But now, years later, I can't fathom the idea of a male feeling entitled to female spaces all because of their transition.

I think it's easier to understand why it's such a weird entitlement to have when you turn back the pages and realize that we have separate spaces for a reason. Stuff happens, and when they do, you want to be comfortable and know that the people around you are all the same sex as you as well. More than that, there's a threat to women's security when this happens. With the new wave of transitioners and how easy it has become to claim to be trans, our spaces grow less and less secure by the day. You never know who is actually telling the truth or not. And it's socially taboo to question people's motives.

In all honestly, I'm okay with trans people using the restroom that alines with the gender they're going for. But the moment they begin to get angry at the sex that uses that restroom for feeling uncomfortable, that's when it becomes my problem. Because that's the moment I realize it isn't about being comfortable. It's about gaining validation from everyone else and disturbing others' lives to get it.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) comments on the social pressure to identify as LGBTQ, explaining how friends who viewed it as "cool" influenced her to ID as genderfluid, and details a debate with a friend who dismissed detransitioners as insignificant.
40 pointsSep 2, 2023
View on Reddit

I don't think I've ever resonated with a post on this subreddit more than I have just now. For me, though, it was my freshman year of high school (I am now a junior).

I was also friends with a lot of lgbtq people who had a giant influence over me. And my parents, like yours, weren't big on this either and never talked about it, nor did they know about what my friends' influence was doing to me.

For me, however, it was two friends in particular who made me think that I was genderfluid. Both of them ran and still run with the belief that being homosexual and/or transgender makes you ten times cooler. And that if it makes you euphoric to call yourself the opposite sex, then you must be trangender (something that, even now, I still fail to understand the reasoning behind). For one of them, if it wasn't gay, the excitement wasn't thrilling enough.

I dragged myself out of that situation quickly after learning about detransitioners, and after watching Matt Walsh's documentary 'What is a Woman?', - the most notable trait about it being the people's inability to recognize that there is a vast, vast line between trans- men/women and men/women.

The other friend, actually argued with me when I brought up detransitioners when I was talking to her about my new conclusion and the trend that I've noticed when it comes to minors identifying as lgbtq today; I see it a lot more in females than I do males, and it's typically the emo, socially awkward kids that do it. In her own words, the amount of detransitioners is "only, like, one or two people." The stupidity of it all being that she claims minorities are just as important as majorities. The lgbtq community is a minority, and detransitioners, a minority off of that, why do we talk so much about one, and nothing about the other? And why is it okay to leave out the detransition and desister rates when discussing the topic, but it isn't okay not to talk about it at all in school's curriculums in today's world?

The whole thing is honestly still so surreal to me. Sometimes, I feel like I'll wake up to find it was nothing more than a crazy dream.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) comments on the difficult but important process of redefining womanhood and finding self-acceptance during detransition, acknowledging potential social loss but emphasizing personal growth and recovery.
21 pointsDec 27, 2022
View on Reddit

Embarrassing as it may seem, this is such an important part of yourself to rediscover. Redefining your womanhood and what that truly is has grown to be such a hard task in our current times. And although you may have lost some, and are bound to lose more if you decide that detransition is right for you, you will find those who will respect the leaps and bounds that you underwent in order to come to this revelation. On top of that, realizing that you may have pushed this on those close to you is huge. I believe that this is a good start on your road to recovery, if not a great start. Look into yourself before looking to those around you in search of answers and I believe that this will go better than you think.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) explains that a painful lump in the armpit is likely a normal inflamed lymph node or gland caused by deodorant ingredients, shaving, or clogged pores.
8 pointsAug 22, 2024
View on Reddit

There's either a lymph node or a gland in your armpit (I can't remember what it's called exactly). But it'll inflame for certain common reasons. I get this as well every now and then, I think it has to do with blockage in your pores or something like that, but I could be wrong. It is normal, though, and there is nothing to be really worried over. Your body is likely just reacting to a common ingredient in deodorants. I used to get this every now and then, typically after shaving and then using an old deodorant I used to use.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) explains the crucial social and moral questions to ask before transitioning, warning that euphoria and dysphoria alone are not sufficient reasons.
8 pointsSep 9, 2023
View on Reddit

Honestly, who are the people you are close with and talk with most? and are they passionate about any narratives around the transgender topic? What are your morals?

For me, personally, my friends, back when I socially transitioned before realizing my mistake, had, by that point, drilled it into my head that being transgender was "so cool." And that being euphoric about thinking of yourself as the opposite sex meant you were probably trans.

Also, you should ask yourself under what circumstances would transition be necessary and why? Being gender dysphoric should not be the sole circumstance for doing such.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) comments on the importance of questioning gender differentiation to help decide between transition or detransition.
6 pointsJul 31, 2024
View on Reddit

Definitely this. Answering these questions and understanding why we differentiate between men and women so heavily will be helpful to figuring out whether transition or detransition will be the right path for you.

I hope you are able to come out on the other side of this feeling more sure of yourself, OP.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) explains the nuanced impact of male transitioners on women's spaces, arguing that while an individual's intentions may be harmless, the collective effect erodes boundaries created to protect women.
3 pointsNov 21, 2024
View on Reddit

Objectively, yes. Depending on how you, as an individual, saw it, no.

Women have obviously gone through a lot of discrimination throughout history, both modern and old. We had to fight for the ability just to vote, to have our own sports, our own private facilities, etc. When men come into a head space of transitioning into a woman, for me, personally, it all boils down to whether or not they are respectful. If you are a male in women's spaces, even if you genuinely are trying to transition, if a woman is uncomfortable and asks you to leave, you should because no matter how much society tries to push this narrative that trans women and men have different agendas (and also the fact that any man can now just say he's a woman and get a stamp of approval), you just fundamentally speaking do not belong in that space. Whether your intentions were innocent or predatory, it doesn't matter. You just don't.

If, genuinely, you had no intention of harm and did what you could to avoid it at all costs in that area of your life, then, as an individual, no. Your transition did not. The problem is not individual transitioners; it's transitioners as a whole who have suddenly forgotten about those societal boundaries that were put in place to protect women from men of all kinds, not just the sex-offender or peeping-tom down the street. They were put in place to create comfortability away from men. Period.

Future girls and women have a right to spaces that aren't invaded by transwomen. If they don't, then these private facilities, by definition, will simply cease to exist. That is my main concern with trans women and men transitioning in our modern political landscape.

Reddit user Melody_Sparce (desisted female) explains how finding faith in God provided her with profound peace and healing after years of running from her beliefs.
3 pointsJan 6, 2023
View on Reddit

Thank you for saying this. Though I don't agree with every single little piece, I've made a promise to God that I would help those around me to see the love that He has for all of us, no matter where we come from or what we've done, we are all children of God, it just takes some of us longer to realize. He will heal the broken and give strength to the weak.

I am so glad that I've come to find peace in him. I ran from Him for years, telling myself that I didn't believe, and yet, as it would turn out, I was simultaneously talking to Him with every step I took when attempting to walk away. He gave me peace last year, and now I can finally breathe. Accepting Him into my life was the best decision I've ever made. I grew up in church, but never have I felt him the way that I do now. I pray every day that those suffering could find peace in Him as well.