genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/MentallyWill_'s Detransition Story

Transitioned: 19 -> Detransitioned: 24
female
low self-esteem
hated breasts
took hormones
regrets transitioning
escapism
depression
got top surgery
now infertile
puberty discomfort
started as non-binary
anxiety
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic.

There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic. The comments demonstrate:

  • Personal, emotional depth and a consistent, supportive tone.
  • Shared lived experience with specific detransition struggles (mourning, name anxiety, passing concerns).
  • Nuanced advice that reflects a complex, personal journey, not scripted talking points.

The passion and anger mentioned are present but are channeled into empathetic support for others, which is common and expected in this community.

About me

I started transitioning because I felt a deep discomfort with my female body during puberty and thought becoming a man was the answer. I took testosterone and had top surgery, which felt right for a while, but I eventually realized I was trying to escape my underlying depression and anxiety. Now, I’ve stopped hormones and I’m grieving the permanent changes and the person I tried to be. I regret not dealing with my mental health first and that I can’t just go back to how I was. I’m trying to move forward, seeing that my body is still a woman’s, even if it’s now permanently altered.

My detransition story

My whole journey with transition and detransition was, looking back, me trying to solve a different problem with the wrong solution. I was deeply uncomfortable in my own skin, especially when I went through puberty and started developing breasts. I hated them; they felt foreign and wrong on my body. I think a lot of my initial feelings were rooted in a deep discomfort with the changes happening to me and a feeling that I had no control over my own body or my life.

I started identifying as non-binary first, and that quickly spiraled into identifying as a trans man. It felt like the answer to all my problems. Taking testosterone and getting top surgery felt like steps I had to take to finally feel right. For a while, it did make me feel better. I felt like I was taking control and finally becoming who I was supposed to be.

But eventually, the feeling didn't last. I started to realize that the underlying issues were still there. A lot of my struggle was tied up with low self-esteem, depression, and anxiety. I was using transition as a form of escapism—a way to run from myself and the parts of being a woman that I was scared of, like dealing with misogyny. I was trying to fix an internal problem with an external change.

Coming off testosterone was one of the hardest things I've ever done. I'm now a few months off it, and I'm going through a real mourning phase. It's agonizing. I'm grieving the person I tried to be and the permanent changes to my body. I got top surgery, and while I don't necessarily regret the reduction of my chest dysphoria, I regret the reasons why I did it and that I permanently altered my body for what I now see as the wrong reasons.

My biggest struggle now is my name. I have a masculine name that I chose, and it feels like my biggest "clocker." It's hard to let go of because, in a way, it still feels like my name. But it's a constant reminder of everything I went through and now serves as a source of anxiety when I introduce myself. I'm worried about the legal process of changing it back to something more feminine or androgynous.

I look in the mirror now and I just see someone who looks female-to-male. I feel like that's all anyone will ever see me as, and it's a painful feeling, knowing I can't just go back to how I was. My own eyes and mind are my worst enemies right now. A friend has been trying to help by reminding me that there are women with hormonal issues who might have similar features, but it's hard to shake the feeling that I did this to myself.

My thoughts on gender have completely changed. I don't think it's the profound, internal identity it's made out to be. I think it's mostly just… bullshit. Not in the way the trans community says, but in the way that we put way too much importance on it. Some people are just feminine men, some are masculine women, and some are in between. That's all it is. Forcing yourself into a box is how this whole mess starts.

I do have regrets about transitioning. I regret not dealing with my mental health first. I regret not understanding that my discomfort was about puberty and control, not my fundamental self. I regret the permanent changes and the fact that I'm now infertile. I would tell anyone questioning to put gender on a shelf for a while and focus on their mental health. Live in the in-between space and see how that feels. Don't force it.

My partner has been a huge support, reminding me that this experience has given me a valuable and unique outlook on life, even if it was a painful way to get it. I'm trying to see that as a small blessing and learn to be here for myself as I move forward.

Here is a timeline of my journey:

Age Event
13-14 Started experiencing intense discomfort with puberty and developing breasts.
18 Began identifying as non-binary.
19 Socially transitioned and began identifying as a trans man. Started testosterone.
22 Underwent top surgery.
24 Began to question my transition and started working on underlying mental health issues.
24 Stopped taking testosterone.
24 (now) Currently detransitioning and coping with the aftermath.

Top Comments by /u/MentallyWill_:

5 comments • Posting since April 25, 2025
Reddit user MentallyWill_ (detrans female) advises a person questioning their gender to pause and focus on mental health first, explaining that other issues can mask themselves as dysphoria and that forcing oneself into a box is how it all starts.
12 pointsJul 17, 2025
View on Reddit

Hey. Deep breaths. I know it might seem like everythings overwhelming. When i was transitioning it felt like it was what i should be.

I seriously recommend trying to work on mental health issues and have gender be at the back of your mind, on a shelf. Somtimes living 'between transition' can help figuring this out. Trying to force yourself into a box can be how this all starts. I realized somewhere along the lines that gender really is just bullshit- but not in the trans way. Some people are just effeminate men, some people are masc women, some are an inbetween. Take time. Taking a big step back can help- sometimes other issues will mask themselves as dysphoria and gender issues. What is it that makes you believe your are trans/arent? Start from there. Just breathe ok?

Reddit user MentallyWill_ (detrans female) explains the agonizing mourning phase of detransition, framing transition as a desperate attempt to fix issues like a need for control or a fear of misogyny.
7 pointsApr 25, 2025
View on Reddit

Few months off T, and i felt this so deeply. The mourning phase is genuinely agonizing and im so glad you have friends to support you. I think something that's been helping me with it is realizing that the 'transitioned' part of us was just desperately trying to fix something. For me it was control of my environment and me. For others its the fear that comes with woman hood and misogyny. I hope you are able to heal with time. I hope we all are.

Reddit user MentallyWill_ (detrans female) discusses the challenge of keeping a traditionally male name after detransitioning, explaining it feels like her name but causes anxiety and acts as a "clocker." She shares her strategy of using the excuse "my dad really wanted a boy" and her plan to legally change it to an androgynous version.
5 pointsApr 25, 2025
View on Reddit

Heyo , similiar boat here. My name is my biggest 'clocker' yet its hard to let go of because at the same time it really feels like... my name, ykno? A go to i use when asked is "my dad really wanted a boy lol" Try looking into old school names that have the same start, Ie; William -> Willaworm A name at the end of the day is just that. A name. But i totally get the anxiety that comes with introducing yourself. It feels like a constant reminder. It has opened up some really uncomfortable topics when it comes up, that yes im a woman with a masculine name. Im also worried abt the legal stuff rn, so im just gunna hurry and try to at least androg-ify it for now.

Reddit user MentallyWill_ (detrans female) offers advice and support to a detransitioner struggling with self-image, suggesting a break from mirrors, leaning into feminine features, and comparing her appearance to women with hormonal conditions.
4 pointsApr 25, 2025
View on Reddit

Hey. I hope you start feeling better again. Ik for myself ive had to take a long break from looking at myself in the mirror- while its not the most helpful or reasonable advice, sometimes its needed. Especially when these thoughts are it its worst.

I totally feel the whole looking ftm thing. I feel like thats what everyone sees me as, and thats what ill always be seen as.

My friend has helped a lot; think about women who have hormonal issues, and might look like this. Ik it doesnt help much, because im sure you feel the "well i USED to be able to look this way and it hurts i cant go back" so all i can say is keep going forward and when you can try to accentuate the feminine features you have. Lean all the way fem for a while- it helps.

Big hugs girl. And from the photos, you are looking very fem, please give yourself some time to heal. Our own eyes and mind are our worst enemys.

Reddit user MentallyWill_ (detrans female) comments on finding value in a unique perspective, stating "The universe will be here for us as long as we are for it."
3 pointsApr 25, 2025
View on Reddit

Thats what my partner keeps saying, and what ive realised i need to learn myself. We will both have a valueable and unique outlook on things that are not common for the averaye person, and ill take that as a small blessing. The universe will be here for us as long as we are for it.