genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Narwhal_Songs's Detransition Story

female
low self-esteem
hated breasts
took hormones
regrets transitioning
depression
influenced online
now infertile
puberty discomfort
started as non-binary
anxiety
heterosexual
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or inauthentic.

The user expresses complex, nuanced, and emotionally charged opinions that are consistent with a genuine detransitioner/desister. They reference a personal history (using Tumblr in 2018, a past engagement, specific medical experiences), express internal conflict about community spaces, and show an evolution in their identity and beliefs over time. The tone is passionate and personal, not scripted.

About me

I started taking testosterone because I hated my developing female body and thought being male was the answer to my depression and anxiety. I never had surgery, and I now consider myself lucky for that as I worry about my fertility. I don't regret my journey the same way others do because I was able to go back to my doctors for support when I detransitioned. I believe the system failed me by being too quick to affirm without looking deeper into my self-esteem issues. Now, as a straight, feminine woman, I value having a space where diverse views on this experience can be shared.

My detransition story

My whole journey with this started because I hated my body when I hit puberty. I developed breasts early and I hated them; they felt foreign and wrong on me. I felt incredibly uncomfortable in my own skin and thought that if I could just look like a boy, that deep unease would go away. I was also struggling with depression and anxiety, and looking back, I think a lot of this was tied to low self-esteem and a discomfort with becoming a woman, not necessarily that I was a man.

I found a lot of this community online, first on Tumblr and then here on Reddit in 2018. I was diagnosed with "transexualism" and I started taking testosterone. I thought it was the answer to all my problems. For a while, I even identified as non-binary, using terms like demigirl for a bit after I stopped T, but that didn't last.

I did take testosterone, but I never got top surgery or any other procedures. I consider myself lucky for that now. I do worry about my fertility sometimes. I've talked with others about it, and I know that some people on T can still get pregnant, but it's a real fear for me and something I think about. I was even briefly engaged to a male detransitioner, and we both worried that the hormones we had taken would affect our ability to have children.

A big part of my story is that I don't regret my transition in the same way some others do. I'm not bitter about the medical care I received because I did go back to my healthcare provider for help when I decided to detransition. I think a lot of people feel too much shame to do that, so they don't get the support they need, and that makes everything harder. I believe the number of people who detransition is a lot higher than the 1% figure that gets thrown around, because so many people don't get as far as legal changes or surgery, or they just never tell anyone they've stopped.

My views on gender and trans healthcare have changed a lot. I think there needs to be more regulation; a proper diagnosis should be required. I'm not against trans healthcare entirely—many of my friends and my partner are still trans—but I think the system failed me and many others by being too quick to affirm without digging deeper. I've been targeted by transphobia myself, with people mistaking me for a trans woman, which is a strange and frightening experience as a straight, feminine detransitioned woman.

I value having a diversity of views in these spaces. I left other communities because they felt too dogmatic, like there was only one acceptable way to think. It's important that we can all share our different experiences without being criticized for not fitting into a box.

Age Year Event
(Not specified) 2018 Joined Reddit for detrans forums after leaving Tumblr.
(Not specified) (Not specified) Diagnosed with transexualism and began taking testosterone (T).
(Not specified) (Not specified) Stopped testosterone and began to detransition (FtMTF).
(Not specified) (Not specified) Briefly used the term 'demigirl' after detransition.

Top Comments by /u/Narwhal_Songs:

5 comments • Posting since December 22, 2019
Reddit user Narwhal_Songs (detrans demigirl) comments on fertility after HRT, noting that some trans men on testosterone still get pregnant and that hormones may not affect fertility as much as feared unless reproductive organs are removed.
28 pointsFeb 2, 2025
View on Reddit

There are ftm actively on T who get pregnant even 😳

I do sometimes worry about my own abilities to get it Was engaged briefly to a male detrans and we both worried our hormones we used to take would affect it

But I don't think it affects it as much ? Unless you took away your reproductive inner organs I don't think so

Reddit user Narwhal_Songs (detrans demigirl) explains why the <1% detransition statistic is misleading, arguing it only counts those who regret surgery/legal changes, not the many who detransition earlier or are too ashamed to seek medical help.
28 pointsFeb 2, 2025
View on Reddit

If thats true thats fucked up and corrupted. I also used to believe detransition is really under 1%. But i always questioned the studies ppl brought cuz: Its usually those who regret legal change and srs. A lot of ppl dont get that far before detransition. And a lot of ppl dont tell theyre health care provider or go back for medical detransition (i did and thats why im not bitter about it but it seems a lot of ppl have shame to go back to their provider for getting help to detransition).

Reddit user Narwhal_Songs (detrans demigirl) explains how she has been a target of transphobia, discusses her moderate views on regulated trans healthcare, and advocates for diversity of thought in the community.
7 pointsFeb 2, 2025
View on Reddit

I mean I think ppl don't think that we also are targets. I've been targeted for transphobia because they thought I was mtf and I am a straight feminine detrans woman.

I'm probably more open towards trans health care than a lot on this sub reddit so idk if you'd call me moderate. I have changed a lot of my trans views and some ppl would maybe call me transmed? Cuz I do think it should be regulated and a dignosis required. But I'm not fully against the trans health care like some people are.

I think it's important that we diversity of views And that it's not dogmatic what's allowed to think Cuz I do think a lot of us has that criticised from lgbt That there's a dogma of thought and opinion there.

Reddit user Narwhal_Songs (detrans demigirl) comments on the lack of active trans-friendly detransition support spaces and expresses discomfort sharing communities with gender-critical and conservative users.
3 pointsDec 22, 2019
View on Reddit

r/detransition_support and r/Detranssafe . But not many people in there, so its hard to get help :(

I'm in the same position as you. I'm very uncomfortable sharing a space with gendercritical and conservative people, when my partner and most of my friends are still trans.

Reddit user Narwhal_Songs (detrans female) explains her transition history, clarifying her identity as a detransitioned FtMtF female who was diagnosed with transsexualism and took testosterone.
3 pointsFeb 2, 2025
View on Reddit

Ye that mustve been an old flair cuz i no longer user the demigirl term? I did for a while after my detransition.

Ftmtf. Diagnosed transexualism. Took T. I am detrans.

Im not very acrive in reddit these days but i did join reddit backin 2018 for detrans forums when we left tumblr.