This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or operating in bad faith.
The user demonstrates a consistent, nuanced, and highly analytical worldview across all comments. Their writing style is complex, personal, and shows deep engagement with the philosophical and social aspects of gender, detransition, and online culture. The passion and criticism align with the expected perspective of a desister or critical detransitioner.
About me
I started identifying as non-binary in my late teens because I felt I didn't fit the stereotype of a man and thought transitioning was an escape. I confused a sexual fetish for a real identity and started taking hormones, believing it was my only path to happiness. The physical changes scared me, and I realized the ideology just reinforced the stereotypes I hated. I stopped hormones and found a therapist who helped me address my real issues like anxiety and low self-esteem. Now I know my problem was never being male, but learning to accept myself as the kind of man I want to be.
My detransition story
My journey with gender started in my late teens, not from a place of deep-seated dysphoria, but from a deep feeling of not fitting in. I was always a bit different, and I struggled a lot with anxiety and low self-esteem. I spent a huge amount of time online, and that’s where I first got deeply involved with trans communities. It felt like I had finally found a place where I belonged, a group that understood what it was like to feel out of place. Looking back, I can see I was heavily influenced online. The communities I was in were intense echo chambers; it felt like we were all validating each other's deepest insecurities, and anyone who questioned anything was immediately shut down. It was like a digital cult.
I started identifying as non-binary first. It felt like a way to escape the pressures of being a man and all the expectations that came with it. I hated the stereotypes I was supposed to conform to. I thought that if I wasn't a "typical man," then maybe I wasn't a man at all. This eventually led me to believe I was a trans woman. I think a lot of this was a form of escapism. I was running away from myself and from my problems by trying to become someone completely different.
I was also dealing with a serious porn problem at the time, specifically sissy porn. I now see this as a form of autogynephilia (AGP), where the idea of being a woman was sexually arousing. I confused these sexual feelings for a genuine identity. I thought my arousal was a sign of my true self, when it was really just a fetish I had developed. I started taking hormones for a short time. I was so deep in the ideology that I thought it was the only solution to my unhappiness.
But the changes from the hormones started to scare me. It made me realize how permanent and serious this all was. Around the same time, I began to seriously question the ideology itself. I saw how it reinforced the very gender stereotypes I claimed to hate. Trans women I knew would wear excessive makeup and hyper-feminine clothes, not to break down stereotypes, but to fit into a cartoonish version of what a woman is. It felt like we were all just playing dress-up with stereotypes instead of challenging them.
I realized that my real issue wasn't with my body, but with how I felt about myself and my place in the world. I had internalized a lot of negative feelings about being a man, and transitioning felt like a way to opt out of that. I also saw how the medical system had completely failed. There was no real questioning; therapists were too afraid to explore my trauma, anxiety, or my porn addiction because it might be seen as "transphobic." I benefited immensely from finally getting non-affirming therapy—therapy that was willing to ask the hard questions about my childhood, my mental health, and my online influences instead of just affirming my self-diagnosis.
I stopped hormones and detransitioned. I don't regret exploring my identity, but I deeply regret taking hormones. I am lucky I stopped before any permanent, serious health complications or infertility set in. My journey taught me that my problem was never gender. It was a combination of depression, anxiety, low self-esteem, and the desperate need for community in a world that feels increasingly lonely and disconnected. I thought transitioning would solve my problems, but it was just a distraction from doing the real, hard work of self-acceptance.
I now believe that the healthiest thing is to challenge stereotypes, not our bodies. I'm a man, and I can be whatever kind of man I want to be. I don't have to fit a stereotype to be valid.
Here is a timeline of my journey:
Age | Event |
---|---|
17 | Began spending excessive time online, influenced by trans communities. Started identifying as non-binary. |
18 | Began identifying as a trans woman. Started taking estrogen hormones. |
19 | Realized the ideological contradictions and stopped hormones. Began detransitioning. |
20 | Started non-affirming therapy to address underlying anxiety, depression, and porn addiction. |
Top Comments by /u/OZIOZIOZIO:
I hate to be harsh but you knew that this is how she and most other people thought about gender...thats what motivated you to pass in the first place, right? I hate to say it, but it is unfair to ask her to assimilate to your reasoning when you spent all the previous time assimilating to hers.
Instead of changing your gender or pronouns based on society's perception of what a black man looks like and does, you should trail blaze for being a shamelessly feminine black male. You have to emanate the change in the world you want to see instead of changing yourself based off the world.
In all seriousness, Instagram, YT, Tumblr, parts of Reddit, ANY form of Social Media needs to be drastically limited if not entirely removed from all adolescents lives. They don’t understand the nature of echo chambers, the rampant photo editing, and the vast exaggerations and mental neuroses that come with the lives of the people they’re trying to emulate. People forget how dangerous an idea can be especially when one is socially accepted and supported for having that idea. We’re literally in the age of digital cults and social media is like pandora’s box. I hate to say it, but it might be better for your teen to hate you for a few years by drastically limiting their internet use than have them physically and mentally scarred for their rest of their life....its a thankless job.
At this point, no porn is much more important than no fap. Masturbation is healthy in moderation and necessary if you’re single(monks actually can go years without but we’re not meditating all day in a fucking monastery so lets get real.)
All you have to do is completely stop watching sissy porn and keep having sex with your gf. This will eventually rewire your sexual reward circuit pathway to get hard for her and not porn.
You don’t have to ingest a substance to become addicted to something..in your case, this is called stimulus addiction. If desisting from porn proves to be too hard, cut off your internet. Get a phone plan with just talk and text. If you want to have a healthy sex life, you have to quit this and quit it FOREVER.
Yea...but as far as constructive advice goes, people are highly influenced by consistency so if you’re consistent with dressing feminine and referring to yourself as a woman, it is likely that your social circle will start referring to you as such. The hardest part about this though, is not reacting when they inevitably misgender you whether it be accidental or even intentional. You have to graciously set the standard while being passive because, at the end of the day, people referring to you how you want them to is about respect and since they have freedom of speech and don’t have to call you what you want, you can’t demand that respect...it has to be earned.
You can’t. This ideology is based off of pacifying emotion and not propagating reason. I hate to recommend passive manipulation but its the only thing that works for irrational individuals. The biggest motivator is fear and trans individuals fear dysphoria so the only way to coerce them against dysphoria is to give them something to bigger to fear.
Show her stories of the horror that is transitioning without being trans. All you can do is provide perspective and even then, she will probably despise you for it.
oh yea in both mtf and ftm trans people, their projections of their new sex is always this over exaggerated stereotypical gender critical archetype of what they perceive the opposite sex to be and its ironic because they are as ‘bigoted’ as they say other people are because they completely ignore the existence of the masculine woman or the feminine man. Its why trans woman too often wear pounds and pounds of make-up that actually helps them pass less while trans men too often start to weight lift when having muscles isn’t paramount to passing as a man.
I get that this is a coping mechanism aimed at relieving dysphoria but it still perceived by the masses and by the LGB as being gender critical which is the exact thing transgender people criticize cis people for. The irony is palpable, in that regard.
One’s sense of community has been deteriorating since the agricultural revolution and that degradation became exponential after the industrial revolution. Automation has freed us from the bosom of the tribe but has left us starving for social sustenance. All we want is to acknowledge and be acknowledged by our peers but the social hierarchy no longer exist in the culdesac or the class room or the office. The migration of our social identities from reality to the virtual has created groups ludicrously bigger than we ever evolved to experience and where our individuality must be expressed and not observed and where there is 0 accountability for the latter. Naturally, echo chambers form where every member is relishing in their perceived escape from mediocrity...clamoring to be a minority...wanting to be validated...lusting after uniqueness with such a ravenous desire that they are willing to say and do anything to achieve it and inadvertently delude themselves in the process.
No one’s to blame. It’s simply human’s social nature interacting with the rapid automation/technology it has created. We can’t evolve fast enough and so many will perish not to bullets, famine, or natural disaster...but to the most dangerous threat there is: an idea.
The fact you even mentioned “wrongthink” un-ironically should be a major eye opener for you. And the fact that someone is friends with you based off of WHAT you think and not HOW you think means they were never friends with you in the first place....they are friends within anybody who thinks like them which is, honestly, just an exercise in self re-affirming narcissism disguised as comradery.
This is textbook cult behavior.
Undoubtedly, Men are less scrutinized for their looks because, as the less fairer sex, the standard is much lower than women’s and societal appraisal of a man’s value has less to do with his looks. Of course, his sex appeal has much less influences as well so thats the balance. I’ve read a few stories on this sub where ftms were surprised how rude and indifferent people were to them when they started passing as male and how they missed the politeness that came with being a woman.