genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/PachaDub's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 52 -> Detransitioned: 55
male
took hormones
regrets transitioning
escapism
autogynephilia (agp)
influenced online
got top surgery
serious health complications
benefited from psychedelic drugs
This story is from the comments by /u/PachaDub that are listed below, summarised with AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
User Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user's narrative is highly detailed, emotionally complex, and spans several years, describing a personal and inconsistent journey with MTF transition, detransition, and retransition. The story includes specific, believable details about:

  • Hormone use (types, doses, effects, sourcing)
  • Physical and emotional changes over time
  • Social interactions and stigma
  • Internal conflict and evolving viewpoints

The account expresses frustration and critiques both trans and detrans communities, which aligns with the expected passion and personal stake of someone who has lived this experience. The history is long, messy, and human, not the streamlined narrative a deceptive account would typically present.

About me

I started taking estrogen at 52, thinking it would be a fun escape from my boring life. I loved the emotional changes at first, but a disturbing vision and the reality of being a man with breasts in public made me realize I could never actually be a woman. I stopped identifying as trans and now present as male, though I still take a low dose of estrogen because I prefer how it makes me feel. Looking back, I feel I was groomed by online ideologies, and it cost me friends and damaged my family. I’ve learned you can just be a feminine man without needing any labels.

My detransition story

My whole journey with this started when I was 52. I was bored with my life and feeling pretty low, and then I started seeing stuff about transitioning online. It seemed to pop up everywhere in my feeds, even though I never looked for it. I got this idea that it would be a fun diversion, a way to escape from how I was feeling. I decided to start taking estrogen, buying it myself without a doctor.

The changes started almost right away. My emotions were all over the place, and I began to grow breasts. At first, it felt amazing. The estrogen made me feel like a beautiful young woman, and I loved the way it softened my emotions and made me feel more connected to women. I even changed my name to one that could be for a man or a woman. For a while, I was totally set on the idea and even thought about getting bottom surgery. I was convinced this was the right path.

But then, a couple of years in, things started to shift. I had a really disturbing experience the very first day I took hormones. I got very stoned on cannabis and had a kind of vision. I saw myself a few years down the line with breasts and in women's clothes, and the image felt bizarre and wrong. It freaked me out so much that I stopped using cannabis for over two years because every time I did, that same unsettling feeling would come back, showing me how others might see me.

I started to realise I would never actually look like a woman. I’m a tall man, and no amount of hormones was going to change that basic fact. I began to notice people staring, laughing, and taking pictures of me when I was out in public. It was exhausting and really hurtful. I travelled to a few different countries, and it was the same everywhere. In Nepal, people pointed and laughed every day. In Cambodia, it was even worse. I used to love swimming and going to the beach, but I became too self-conscious to do any of that anymore. Having breasts as a man is not easy to hide, and it makes you a target.

Around this time, I found gender-critical forums and communities online. Their views made a lot more sense to me than the trans ideology I saw in other spaces. I never believed a man could become a woman; I just thought I could enjoy feminine things. I started to see the whole trans movement as a kind of groupthink or even mind control. The online trans communities felt like an echo chamber, just the same few topics on a loop, and they were very quick to ban anyone who questioned anything. I got banned from several groups just for having a different opinion.

I started to pull back. I took surgery off the table completely after I saw some post-op pictures; it looked horrifying and final. I stopped hormones a few times to see how I felt. Every time I stopped, my old male self would start to come back, and I didn't like him. I felt more stable and happier on estrogen; it changed my personality, my outlook, and my emotions in a way I preferred. But being on it caused me health problems—stomach issues, a painful lump in my chest, and eczema in places I never had it before. I started to worry about the long-term effects and being dependent on big pharma for the rest of my life.

I’ve ended up in a kind of middle ground. I don’t identify as trans. I think that’s a stupid idea. I present as a male in public now—I cut my hair and gave away most of my women's clothes and makeup—but I still sometimes take a low dose of estrogen because I like how it makes me feel on the inside. I’m just a somewhat feminine man. It’s confusing to have a body and mind that don’t match, but I’m trying to just be myself without labels.

Looking back, I have a lot of regrets. I feel like I was groomed by the internet and social media. I was influenced by what I was seeing online and got swept up in something without thinking it through. I think a lot of young people are being brainwashed into this, and it breaks my heart. If I had seen an honest therapist at the start, I never would have gone down this path. My transition damaged my relationship with my adult son, and it’s been incredibly lonely. I lost friends over it. I’m now married to a wonderful woman who accepts me, but it was a close thing; she nearly left when I told her about my past.

I believe my desire to transition was related to autogynephilia (AGP)—a sexual interest in the idea of myself as a woman—and a form of escapism. It was also a way to shock people, something I’ve enjoyed since I was a teenager dressing as a punk. But it wasn’t worth the cost. The constant discrimination, the health worries, and the loss of my old life have been devastating. My main thought on gender now is that it’s all nonsense. We don’t need labels. You can be a man who likes feminine things without trying to become a woman. We’re just men and women playing with image. The most important thing is to be true to yourself and not get caught up in ideologies that demand everyone agree with you.

Age Year Event
52 ~2018 Started self-medicating with estrogen.
52 2018 Had a disturbing vision on cannabis about my future transitioned self.
54 ~2020 Stopped cannabis use to avoid confronting doubts about transition.
54 2020 Seriously considered bottom surgery but decided against it after seeing post-op pictures and discovering gender-critical perspectives.
55 ~2021 Began to detransition socially, presenting more masculinely but continuing hormones.
56 ~2022 Stopped hormones completely for several months while travelling.
56 2022 Restarted a low dose of estrogen, preferring the emotional effects.
57 ~2023 Legally began the process to change my name and gender back to male on official documents.
57 2023 Married.

Top Reddit Comments by /u/PachaDub:

156 comments • Posting since March 14, 2020
Reddit user PachaDub (detrans male) explains why they think the book's author effectively exposes experts who become angry when questioned on camera.
157 pointsNov 14, 2022
View on Reddit

A lot of comments here are attacking the author. The question was, what do you think about the book? I think the doc asks a very simple question, which a whole lot of so called experts get angry about. I think it's fantastic to see them squirm as they realize they're on film and are trapped in their own lies.

Reddit user PachaDub ([Detrans]🦎♂️) explains why taking estrogen won't create a female body, warning it will only result in breasts and a lifetime of being stared at and laughed at by strangers.
83 pointsSep 9, 2022
View on Reddit

Seems to me like you should get off the internet. You've been bombarded with all this transitioning nonsense and it's not helpful at all.

Taking estrogen is not going to give you a female body. It will only give you breasts and then you'll spend the rest of your life getting stared at and laughed at by strangers, everywhere you go. That is my reality.

Reddit user PachaDub ([Detrans]🦎♂️) explains his belief that trans women are instinctively identified as male by others, that dating is nearly impossible for them, and that social media heavily influences young people to transition.
73 pointsSep 9, 2022
View on Reddit

You asked for advice so I gave you some. You're only 19 and you've obviously been heavily influenced by social media.

I spend time on the lgbt group on 4chan and they're always talking about how beautiful all the trans girls are. But to me, every single one of them just looks like a guy. I can't see them any other way now.

You can convince yourself that you look like a woman and your supportive friends will tell that too but everybody else has a built in radar and they all know instinctively that you're not. I used to lose respect for anyone who called me ma'am because I knew they were just being politically correct.

You said you're a virgin. Well, my opinion is that you'll probably always be a virgin if you start hormones because women are not interested in trans women. I was rejected by every single woman I wanted to date while I was in transition. Now that I look straight, I've got my first girlfriend in years but I nearly lost her for the sole reason that she didn't want to date a trans person.

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted) comments on the importance of therapy for questioning youth, recounting being downvoted and banned from a trans sub for their view.
66 pointsApr 9, 2023
View on Reddit

I think you hit the nail on the head.

I posted something similar in the trans sub once, saying that young people should see a good therapist as soon as they start saying they're trans and I bet most of them wouldn't go any further.

I got so many downvotes and I think I ended up getting banned.

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted) comments on the rising number of detransitioners, attributing it to young people realizing transition was a phase driven by group mentality and a desire to live a normal life without social ridicule.
59 pointsJun 19, 2023
View on Reddit

You're probably right that the detrans numbers are going to go right up when all the young people realise that it was just a phase and actually, all they want to do is live a normal life. Group mentality is very powerful when you're young but once you're on your own in the big wide world, it's not much fun getting laughed at everywhere you go.

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted male) comments on the importance of sharing detransition stories to warn young people about the potential for regretting gender-affirming surgeries like top surgery.
55 pointsDec 19, 2021
View on Reddit

This is the trans subject which I find the most disturbing. I'm an old guy so if anything goes wrong I only have myself to blame but I really believe that you should share your story with as many young people as possible to try and help them avoid making the same mistake.

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted) comments on a post about questioning gender identity, advising a young person to wait and be sure, noting that concepts like being trans or gender fluid are recent social phenomena.
51 pointsNov 13, 2023
View on Reddit

You're young and keep changing your mind. Take that as a sign to give it a few years to make really sure. All these thoughts like maybe I'm trans or maybe I'm gender fluid, practically didn't exist in people's heads until a few years ago. That's something else you should be aware of.

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted male) comments on the majority's view of trans issues, stating most people oppose men in women's sports, prisons, and the grooming of kids, but support personal freedom if others aren't forced to comply.
45 pointsAug 4, 2022
View on Reddit

I'm active in all kinds of groups and I see a wide range of opinions every day but from what I've seen, the majority of people have nothing against anyone doing whatever they want to themselves as long as they don't expect everyone else to comply. The men in women's sports and prisons and safe spaces are all issues and the grooming of the kids is too.

I spent loads of time with so called right wingers when I was presenting female and never had any problems.

People always mock anyone who dares to be different, especially online so that's to be expected. And because it doesn't affect them personally, they get nasty. A very common reply on 4chan to anyone trans is kys

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted male) comments on the painful and worrying side effects of hormone use, warning others not to mess with the body's intricate system.
45 pointsOct 10, 2021
View on Reddit

I had some similar worrying experiences, which made me want to stop recently. It can be extremely painful.

Nobody talks about this side of hormone use but when it happens, it seems really obvious that you probably shouldn't mess with such an intricate system.

Reddit user PachaDub (desisted) explains that the high suicide rate among trans individuals is not due to being denied transition, but rather the profound emptiness and apathy they felt after successfully blocking testosterone.
42 pointsNov 4, 2023
View on Reddit

I don't believe the suicide rate is actually related to people being stopped from transitioning. I think if anything, it's related to the feeling of emptiness which comes when you realise that your whole existence has become meaningless. Once I'd successfully blocked all my testosterone, I just felt really empty and apathetic.