This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic.
There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor. The user's perspective is internally consistent, showing a nuanced understanding of detransition, gender dysphoria, and gender non-conformity. The comment expressing a personal struggle with dysphoria and the desire not to transition is a strong indicator of a genuine, lived experience. The tone is passionate and argumentative, which is consistent with the stated context of the community.
About me
My discomfort started during puberty when I hated the changes to my body, but I misunderstood that as a sign I wasn't female. I felt pressured online to identify as non-binary and even considered taking testosterone, but I knew deep down I didn't want a male body. I now realize my struggle was with society's expectations of women and my own autism and depression, not with being female. I am a gender non-conforming woman who is comfortable rejecting stereotypes. I am grateful I never medically transitioned and have found peace in understanding my true self.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender has been confusing and, looking back, I think a lot of it was based on misunderstanding myself. I never had what people call classic dysphoria. I didn't look at my body and feel a deep, inherent wrongness about being female. My discomfort started during puberty. I hated the changes, especially developing breasts. It felt invasive and uncomfortable, but it wasn't that I felt they shouldn't be there; I just didn't like the attention they brought and how they felt physically. I think a big part of my struggle was that I'm autistic. The world of gender roles and social expectations never made logical sense to me. Why should I have to perform femininity? I saw it as a chore. I didn't want to wear makeup because it felt weird on my skin, and I preferred comfortable, practical clothes.
A lot of my feelings were tangled up with low self-esteem and depression. I didn't feel like I fit in anywhere, and online, I found communities where people talked about transition as a solution for that feeling of not fitting in. I started to wonder if my discomfort with puberty and my rejection of feminine stereotypes meant I was trans. I spent a lot of time online, and I think I was influenced by the stories I read. I started identifying as non-binary for a while, but then I felt pressure to medically transition to be taken seriously.
I seriously considered taking testosterone. I thought about it for a long time, but I always stopped myself. I knew, deep down, that it wouldn't give me what I truly wanted. I didn't want a deeper voice or facial hair. I just wanted to feel comfortable in my own skin and have a body that felt right to me—slimmer hips, broader shoulders—but T doesn't work like a custom order. It was a difficult place to be stuck: feeling like I couldn't stay as I was, but knowing that medical transition wasn't the right path for me either.
I now see that my issues were more about body dysmorphia and the distress of going through puberty as an autistic person who didn't understand the social rules. I had internalized the idea that because I was a masculine woman, a "butch lesbian" type, I must not be a woman at all. I realize now that's not true. Gender non-conformity is perfectly valid. I can be a woman who doesn't shave, doesn't wear makeup, and dresses for comfort.
I don't regret that I never medically transitioned. I'm grateful I didn't take testosterone or have any surgeries. The whole process of questioning forced me to look at my mental health. I've come to understand that my problem was never with being female, but with the expectations placed on me because I'm female, and with my own struggles with depression and autism. I don't believe I'm mentally ill for being gender non-conforming. The illness was the depression and anxiety that made me think changing my body was the only way to find peace.
Age | Event |
---|---|
Around 12-13 | Started puberty; felt strong discomfort with body changes, especially breast development. |
Late teens (exact age unknown) | Began identifying as non-binary online, influenced by communities I was part of. |
Late teens / Early 20s | Seriously considered taking testosterone but decided against it because I didn't want the physical effects. |
Now (exact age unknown) | Realized I am a gender non-conforming woman; detransitioned socially. |
Top Comments by /u/QuantumBirds:
No, but if you have autism you're more likely to be confused about illogical conceps like "gender", and autistic women are more likely to show masculine behavior, because femininity is performative.
If you havr sensory issues, for example, why would you want to put a kg of stupid face paint on every morning? It all adds up.
I'm in a similar situation, and stuck at the same point. I don't want to transition, because I know it won't give me what I want (slimmer hips, bigger shoulders, no female reproduction system, ...) but at the same time, staying like this is also bad.
Being dysphoric is a mental illness, yes. If you detransitioned, because you turned out to be "cis" or just GNC, then no, you're not mentally ill. If you're dysphoric, transitioned or detransitioned, or just existing outside of that, yes, you're mentally ill.
Nah, I wrote that you never wanted any of the effects. That's why I was surprised that you actually took T.
Why did you take T then? If you didn't think it would change anything physically? And why didn't you look into it, or google search?
Age does have something to do with the law. It's more difficult to refuse you something if you're an adult according to the law. I wasn't talking about being mentally mature, sorry.
Gender non-conforming. It's a fancy word for women and men who happen to not conform to / fit into stereotypical expectations of women and men in any way. Basically feminine men who dress like women, and masculine women who don't shave, don't wear make-up and dress for comfort instead of for looking pretty / effeminate.
It's what "butch lesbians" are.
I'm sorry he was such an asshole. :/
Maybe that explains why trans women don't actually do housework, cook, clean, primarilt raise children, work in typical female dominated jobs or take up female familial responsibilities en masse like you would actually expect if they had female brains
I don't do those things either, and I'm actually female..
I'm sorry, but if you're above 18, you're considered an adult. I'm sorry about what happened to you, but can I ask why you started taking T in the first place? According to your post history you never had dysphoria and wanted none of the physical changes, so I'm curious?