This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic and not a bot. The user demonstrates consistent, passionate, and highly specific viewpoints rooted in personal experience with detransition, female biology, and social dynamics.
The only potential red flag is the aggressive, gatekeeping comment from 2023-12-18, which uses inflammatory language. However, this kind of hostility, while extreme, is not uncommon in this highly charged community and aligns with a passionate individual lashing out, not an inauthentic bot pattern. The other comments are detailed, nuanced, and internally consistent.
About me
I started transitioning because I hated being female and felt my body was a trap, believing becoming male would solve my depression and social isolation. I took testosterone and had surgery, but it only gave me new problems and didn't fix my self-esteem or autism. I now see my desire came from internalized misogyny and a belief that being a woman was inferior. I deeply regret the permanent changes, especially the potential for infertility. I've realized I needed to make peace with being female, not escape it.
My detransition story
My whole journey with this started from a place of really hating being female. I felt like I was being punished every single day for my sex. I looked at men and saw all the things they had that I didn't, and all the things they were free from. They’ll never have to deal with a period, or PMS, or the pain of childbirth. They’re stronger, they can just pee standing up, and it seemed like the world was just easier for them. I felt like my own body was a trap.
A lot of this was tied up with the discomfort of puberty. When I was younger, before I was a teenager, I got along fine with boys. We were on the same level. But once puberty hit, everything changed. I started developing breasts, which I hated, and I felt like I didn't fit in anywhere. The boys started excluding me because I was female, and I found it impossible to connect with other girls because of my autism. I just didn't understand all the unspoken social rules. I felt completely alone and out of place.
I think this led to a lot of depression and low self-esteem. I started believing that if I could just become male, all these problems would go away. The female endocrine system felt like a curse, always in flux and making me feel unstable. I saw testosterone as a potential solution, an antidepressant that could make me feel more steady. I was also influenced by what I saw online, where transition was presented as the answer to these deep feelings of discomfort.
I did medically transition. I took testosterone and I got top surgery. For a while, it felt like it was helping. But the effects of testosterone weren't what I expected for me. I know for some guys it really mellows them out, but for me, it made my moods more extreme. I started to realize that a female body on testosterone is a very different thing, and in many ways, it's harder on us than the reverse. The changes are so permanent. It’s a lot harder to go back and "re-assimilate" after you've had surgeries and your voice has dropped.
Looking back, I think a lot of my desire to transition came from a place of internalized misogyny and a deep-seated belief that being a woman was inferior. I was trying to escape the realities of my female body. I regret not understanding this at the time. I regret the permanent changes I made, especially because I now worry about things like infertility. I see other people talking about having children and I feel a sense of loss, knowing that my choices have made that path much more complicated, if not impossible, for me.
My thoughts on gender now are complicated. I don't think transitioning solved my problems; it just gave me new ones. The issues I had with social connection, my autism, and low self-esteem were still there, just dressed up differently. I've come to believe that I needed to find a way to make peace with being female, not run away from it. I don't regret transitioning in the sense that it brought me to where I am now, but I deeply regret the permanent physical changes and the time I lost believing that changing my body was the only solution.
Age | Event |
---|---|
Before 12 | Had mostly male friends, felt on an equal social footing with boys. |
Around 12 (Puberty) | Started feeling intense discomfort with female puberty, hated breast development. Felt excluded by male and female peers due to sex and autism. |
Late Teens/Early 20s | Medically transitioned: started testosterone and had top surgery. |
Mid-Late 20s | Realized transition wasn't resolving underlying issues; began detransitioning by stopping testosterone. |
Top Comments by /u/ReturnLivid1777:
Honestly FTM transition is just harder on the female body than MTF transition is on the male body (unless you’re doing something insane like only taking spiro or cypro). And I think most MTFTM people can easily pass as male again after stopping injections, patches, whatever. Also, breast augmentation is not nearly as common as top surgery, especially for people early in their transitions. It really seems like more damage is done in two years to our demographic, so it’s a lot harder to re-assimilate…
I think you have to jump through more social hoops to be considered a normal woman. Female socialization has so many unspoken rules for verbal and nonverbal communication that I still don’t really get. Until puberty hit, boys and I were on the same level socially. Pretty much all of my friends were male before the age of 12. Now it’s like, I’m either being excluded by men due to my sex or excluded by women due to my autism.
Men will never experience menopause or menstruation. Men will never experience PCOS or endometriosis. Most men can ejaculate and have children without requiring someone else’s sperm. Men can have children without experiencing the trauma of childbirth. Men can piss standing up. Men outdo women in almost every sport. Men will never experience the ebb and flow of the female endocrine system and all the bullshit that comes with it (PMS, adult hormonal acne). The vast majority of women are only attracted to male genitalia.
The list goes on. Everyday I am punished for being female.
why do you think this is your only chance ? if you conceived once it can absolutely happen again. you should have a child when you are in a better state of mind and are financially stable. I know people here are saying everything will just fall into place for you, but you can’t trust that. I really hope you can rely on your mom because your boyfriend sounds completely useless.
in my opinion, it’s because the female endocrine system is always in flux. it’s just harder to be stable when your hormones aren’t stable! but ngl the effects of test kind of vary. for some trans guys I know, test mellows them out and is an anti-depressant. for others it makes them genuinely manic.
what exactly are you desisting from if you never transitioned, socially or medically? seems to me you’re just an autogynephilic schizo who doesn’t shower. I wish you would contain yourself to /r/askAGP because this community has nothing to do with men like you.