genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Selrisitai's Detransition Story

male
low self-esteem
porn problem
autogynephilia (agp)
depression
influenced online
heterosexual
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears to be authentic.

There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor. The comments demonstrate:

  • Personal, detailed narratives about the user's own experience with dysphoria and resolution.
  • Consistent ideology focused on embracing one's biological sex and critiquing transition.
  • Varied engagement on different posts, offering both personal advice and broader cultural critiques.
  • Emotional nuance, including fear of being banned for his views, which aligns with the described stigma.

The user identifies as a male desister who considered transition but rejected it, which is a valid and common perspective in the detrans community.

About me

I started feeling like a failure as a man and wished I was a woman, thinking it would solve my loneliness and dissatisfaction. My feelings were heavily influenced by online content that made transitioning seem like a real solution, but I realized my unhappiness wasn't about gender at all. I came to understand my desire was largely a sexual fantasy and that I needed to stop living in my head. I decided to embrace being a man, started working on my self-esteem and my actual life, and now I’m comfortable in my own skin. I’m grateful I never medically transitioned, as I see now my problem was never my body, but my lack of appreciation for it.

My detransition story

My whole journey with this started from a place of deep dissatisfaction with myself. I never felt like I was good enough as a man. I looked at women and thought they had it so much easier, that life would be better and I'd be less lonely if I were one. For a long time, I genuinely wished I had been born a girl. I spent a lot of time agonizing over it, feeling like a complete failure of a man.

A lot of my thinking, I realize now, was influenced by what I was consuming online. Porn was a big part of it. Mainstream media and podcasts were pushing trans ideology pretty hard, and it reinforced these thoughts I was having. It made this idea of being a woman feel like a real possibility, not just a fantasy. I think if this whole trans thing had been as big back then as it is now, I might have been fast-tracked into transitioning. It’s scary to think about.

But for me, it never got to that point. I didn't take hormones or have any surgeries. I started to see that a lot of what I was feeling wasn't really about gender at all. It was about me being deeply unhappy with my life. I had no accomplishments, no real prospects, and too much time on my hands to just sit and fret. I was comparing my life to idealized versions I saw online and feeling like my own existence was a tragedy. I was living too much in my head, pining for a life that wasn't mine instead of working on the one I had.

I came to understand that for me, a lot of it was a sexual fetish—what some call autogynephilia (AGP). My fantasies about being a woman largely revolved around sex. It was an insidious thing that tried to convince me it was more than that, that I "belonged" in that world. But the truth is, from my DNA to my skin, I am male. Wishing to be a woman is about as useful as wishing to be a willow tree.

What really helped me turn a corner was a shift in my thinking. I decided that I not only wanted to be a man, but that I was a man. I stopped seeing masculinity as a failure and started to see it as something good. I leaned into it. I started working out, enjoying time with my male friends, and just letting myself be a man. I began to appreciate my inherent characteristics—being taller and stronger than most women, having broader shoulders. These aren't bad things; they're just part of being a man.

I also had to confront my own low self-esteem and depression. I realized my problem wasn't that I was in the wrong body; it was that I didn't appreciate the body I was in. I had to learn to embrace what I am without pretense. I am wholly a man, and that brings me comfort now.

I don't regret transitioning because I never medically transitioned. But I do regret all the years I spent in misery, hating myself and wishing I was someone else. I regret the time I wasted. I now have a girlfriend and I'm comfortable in my heterosexuality. I see now that transitioning would have been a farce for me. At best, I would have been a second-rate woman, and no one ever really sees you as a full woman no matter what you do. I would have been a mutilated man, and that's a horrifying thought.

My thoughts on gender now are that we've really confused everyone. When we pretend men and women are exactly the same, it makes men feel like big, stupid brutes and women feel weak and worthless. It's narcissistic to think the other gender has it easier. We need to appreciate our biological reality and focus on being good people, not on trying to change something so fundamental.

Here is a timeline of my journey:

Age Event
Early Teens Started feeling like a failure as a man, began wishing I was a woman.
Mid-Teens to Early 20s Intense period of dysphoria, consuming online porn and media that reinforced these feelings.
Mid-20s Had a major shift in perspective. Decided to embrace being a man. Started working out and leaning into masculinity.
Late 20s Found comfort in my male identity, began a relationship, and overcame the desire to transition.

Top Comments by /u/Selrisitai:

13 comments • Posting since July 7, 2022
Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) comments on the confusion caused by equating men and women, arguing women are taught to value male-defined strength over their own.
30 pointsOct 17, 2023
View on Reddit

Personally, I think the problem is that women are being taught that they should be "strong," but strong in ways that men are strong instead of ways that women are strong.

Sorry, you will never beat men in arm wrestling, but why the EFF is that any woman's barometer for value?

I believe there's an issue where, when you equate men and women, and pretend they're exactly the same, you end up confusing the ever-living out of everyone, men and women.

Men think they're big, stupid, ugly brutes that women hate.

Women think they're weak, worthless children who will never match up to men.

It's insane how we never stop to think, "Isn't it narcissistic and presumptuous to think that the other gender has it easier and that my life would be better if I had been born a girl/guy?"

The gall we have!

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) comments on parents allowing an 11-year-old to lead his own transition, comparing it to letting a child play with loaded guns or jump into a lake.
23 pointsJul 20, 2023
View on Reddit

At eleven, why are his parents allowing him to take the lead?

It's a tired, tired argument, but it's just agonizingly true: If you're child wants to remove his limbs or jump into a lake (even though he can't swim) or play with the knives or play cops and robbers with your actual, loaded guns, do you actually let him?

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) explains their view that MtF individuals may target gay men over lesbians because lesbians are a threat to autogynephilic MtFs, who they describe as straight men attracted to their own femininity.
23 pointsJul 2, 2023
View on Reddit

I think it's because homosexual men don't threaten MtF people, but female homosexuals are a threat to MtF, specifically those of the autogynephilia persuasion who are really just straight men lusting after their own perceived femaleness. But pass-the-baton is more fun with two players and lesbians aren't into sticks.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) explains why they chose not to medically transition, arguing that biology is in every cell and that transitioning can result in feeling like a "weak half-man and a mutilated woman."
19 pointsDec 16, 2023
View on Reddit

Different person here:

Biology. Your body doesn't merely have the superficial parts. Every single cell and program in your body is geared toward the female.

You don't need to necessarily conform to any specific thing to continue being the sex that you definitionally are.

As a man who wished to be a girl at one point, I had a "I've failed as a man" mentality. I actually grew into appreciation of my masculinity, even my hairy knuckles, but even if I hadn't, looking back now I'd have to advise my past self to not pursue this unnatural alteration.

There's every likelihood that you will never feel like more than a weak half-man and a mutilated woman. That's the kind of reality that the psychiatrists and sex-change doctors are not going to even mention as a possibility.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) explains potential reasons for transition, citing feelings of failure, loneliness, and fetishism for MTF individuals, and a general "something missing" for others that was misdiagnosed as a sex problem.
17 pointsDec 14, 2023
View on Reddit

I've wondered this too. As a male who feels that he pretty thoroughly understands MTF feelings, I'm not sure how it translates to female-to-male transition.
For males, it's a combination of feeling like a failure as a man, feeling lonely and thinking you'll be less lonely as a woman, and sexual fetishism.

A lot of detrans people who don't fit this precise mold, both MtF and FtM, seem to report a general depression, dissatisfaction or otherwise felt that something was "missing," and that insecurity was used by others (maliciously or not) to convince them that it was their sex that was the problem. "You're actually a X in a X's body," and it sounded right to them.

It wasn't right, of course.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) comments on a post by Miku, drawing a parallel between their own experience and the "legal mutilation" resulting from what they describe as "teen angst."
16 pointsJan 3, 2024
View on Reddit

Take teen angst and add in a side of legal mutilation and this is what you get.
I can see myself, in the right circumstances, ushered through this same process.
I'm sorry, Miku (I hope you don't mind me using your first name) I understand the horror.
I know that you can improve though, if only you don't succumb to your despair.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) explains how embracing his inherent masculinity and rejecting the influence of porn and trans ideology helped him overcome his desire to be a woman.
13 pointsJun 18, 2023
View on Reddit

"Where could I have gotten these thoughts from?"

Well, you mentioned a few in your own post. Porn, not the least of which. Podcasts. Mainstream media. Trans ideology is being pushed quite heavily right now.
A lot of your experience sounds like mine. I assume I'm older than you though, because when I was going through the experience of hating myself, wishing I were a girl, agonizing about it, the trans thing hadn't happened yet, so I had very little to reinforce my delusion other than porn itself, and only a madman would make life decisions based on that.

I have no idea what you should do. I know what worked for me, but I suspect that it was a combination of what I did, who I was and where I was in life at the time that allowed it to work:

I decided that I not only wanted to be a man, but that, actually, I was a man. I had felt for a long time that I was a failure, that I had let down mankind and would be better off as a woman. Never mind the arrogance and ignorance of this thinking (is a woman just a man but without responsibilities?).
But there was a point where I decided that being a man was fine. It was good, even. Masculinity is good. It's O.K. to have hair on my knuckles and 60% greater upper body strength on average. Men are great!
So I leaned into it. I let myself be a man. I also made myself be a man. I worked out, I enjoyed time with my male friends. I looked at women as women, and at myself as a man in relation to them. I'm taller than most women, stronger than most women. Broader shoulders. I have inherent characteristics that they will never be able to match.
I AM a man. And that's a good thing.

If I were to transition, I would be a second-rate woman at best, and trust me, NO ONE will EVER see you as a full woman no matter what you do. And every time I think about what I would do as a woman, I realize that it largely revolves around sex. It's just a sexual fetish for the most part. It's insidious, and tries to tell you it's more. You feel like you "belong" to that "world," yet you know nothing really about it. From your DNA to your skin, literally your SKIN, you are male. You may as well wish you were a willow tree.

Anyway, that's what helped me.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) comments that most women don't strongly believe in gender roles but adhere to absorbed social norms, advising the OP to focus on being a good person and let biology take its course.
12 pointsSep 28, 2023
View on Reddit

I think most women today really don't strongly believe in gender roles anyway. Oh, they adhere to them, but it's just whatever they absorb from those around them, or, best-case scenario, what their mothers teach them.

I don't think you need to worry. Biology will take care of most of it. Focus on being a good person, instead.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) expresses fear of being banned for discussing negative aspects of the modern trans movement, citing over-diagnosis, fast-tracking, and potential grooming.
8 pointsDec 24, 2023
View on Reddit

Shoot, I'm afraid to say anything negative about the trans movement IN THIS VERY SUB, for fear that I'll be banned for "hate-speech," despite the fact that many people indicate that it's been harmful due to over-diagnosis and fast-tracking, not to mention people (am I allowed to say this?) being groomed into it.

You think it's perfectly reasonable that a record number of people are chopping off their genitals and feeling this kind of "dysphoria" these days? Like, it's just a coincidence?
There's a push for it. Whether that's grassroots or something else, I ain't here to say, but it ain't normal.

Reddit user Selrisitai (desisted) comments on their introduction to Warrior Cats and shares their own childhood favorites, Animorphs and Babysitters Club.
7 pointsJun 28, 2023
View on Reddit

I actually did a Youtube video reading the first chapter or so of the first Warrior Cats book. It was my introduction to the series and I got a good laugh out of it. I'm willing to bet I'd have been into it as a kid, but I didn't get the introduction.
It was animorphs and Babysitters Club for me, all the way.