genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/Shoddy-Exchange-9055's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 24 -> Detransitioned: 26
male
low self-esteem
internalised homophobia
took hormones
regrets transitioning
escapism
depression
influenced online
anxiety
benefited from non-affirming therapy
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic.

The user's language is nuanced, personal, and emotionally charged in a way consistent with a genuine detransitioner/desister. They share specific, lived experiences (e.g., being on HRT for 8 months, internalized feelings about gender) and express complex, passionate opinions that reflect the deep personal stakes of the topic. The comments do not exhibit the repetitive, generic, or scripted patterns typical of inauthentic accounts.

About me

I was born male and my gender questioning began from a deep discomfort with social expectations of men, not my body. I started hormone therapy hoping for peace, but I realized my idea of womanhood was a fantasy and stopped before any surgeries. I came to understand that my journey was an act of escapism from depression and a poor self-image. I regret not questioning my motivations sooner and being influenced by online communities. Now, I've stopped hormones and I'm focused on learning to live as a man on my own terms.

My detransition story

My journey with gender started from a place of deep discomfort, but not necessarily with my body. I was born male, and my main issue was with the social expectations of what a man should be. I thought men were seen as creepy and bulky, and I admired women because I thought they were cooler and more respected. A lot of this was tied up in low self-esteem and a kind of internalized hatred for my own gender.

I decided to try HRT, thinking it might help me find peace. For the first eight months, it did seem to help my mental state. I felt calmer. But I never went through with a full social transition. I didn’t change my name or pronouns publicly, and I canceled plans for facial feminization surgery. I started to realize that my idea of womanhood was based on a fantasy, not reality. I didn't have many close women friends to ground me in what being a woman is actually like day-to-day.

A big turning point for me was questioning the medical side of things. I kept seeing people online talk about hormone therapy as if taking estrogen would make me biologically identical to a woman. I started to understand that it’s not the same; injecting synthetic hormones doesn't give you the same health profile or biological reality as someone who produces them naturally. This was a major wake-up call.

Seeing the experiences of female detransitioners also impacted me deeply. I read about women who regretted losing their breasts to mastectomy and were seeking reconstruction. It made me realize that for me, a potential desire to regain something like penis size or function after stopping hormones wouldn't be any different. These are defining features of our bodies, and altering them is a massive, permanent decision.

My transition was largely an act of escapism. I was trying to escape from being a man because I had a negative view of masculinity. I now see that my feelings were less about gender dysphoria and more about depression, anxiety, and a poor self-image. I benefited from stepping back from affirmative therapy and instead questioning why I felt the way I did.

I don’t regret exploring transition because it led me to a place of greater self-understanding. However, I do have regrets about not questioning my motivations more deeply from the start. I was influenced by online communities that presented transition as the only solution for anyone unhappy with gender roles. I now believe my path was more about finding peace with myself as a male person, rather than becoming a female person.

I stopped hormones after realizing they weren't the solution for me. I’m now focused on building a life where I can be a man on my own terms, without buying into the stereotypes I once hated.

Here is a timeline of my journey:

Age Event
24 Started questioning my gender identity due to discomfort with male social roles.
25 Began Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT).
25 Experienced a period of mental peace for the first 8 months of HRT.
26 Canceled plans for Facial Feminization Surgery (FFS). Realized my idea of womanhood was not based in reality.
26 Stopped HRT after questioning the medical narrative and understanding the permanence of changes.
26 Began to understand my journey as a form of escapism from depression and low self-esteem, not true dysphoria.

Top Comments by /u/Shoddy-Exchange-9055:

5 comments • Posting since December 1, 2024
Reddit user Shoddy-Exchange-9055 (detrans male) comments on the flawed assumption that synthetic hormones are identical to natural ones, pointing out the health risks of cross-sex HRT.
43 pointsFeb 14, 2025
View on Reddit

The worst thing for me is that they also seem to assume that exogenous, cross-sex synthetic hormones are the same as endogenous, same-sex natural ones. "Woman age better than men" yeah because your health risk profile is EXACTLY the same as women just because you inject yourself some E...

Reddit user Shoddy-Exchange-9055 (desisted male) comments on a friend's FFS-first plan, relating their own experience of finding mental peace on HRT and advising exposure to cis women's socialization for grounding.
15 pointsDec 1, 2024
View on Reddit

Sounds exactly like me, although that I managed to find mental peace by month 8 of HRT and never reached a FFS consultation (nor serious social transitiom tbh)...I hope they come to their senses...do they even have cis women friends so they can expose themselves to actual women socialization?? That should ground them a little.

Reddit user Shoddy-Exchange-9055 (detrans male) comments on the desire for breast reconstruction in female detransitioners, questioning why the desire to regain lost penis size would be any different as it is a defining feature of the male body.
15 pointsApr 24, 2025
View on Reddit

Well the same female detransitioners do with having lost their breasts after mastectomy, I keep seeing posts about urging for breast reconstruction. Why the desire to re-gain lost penis size would be different? It's a defining feature of the male body.

Reddit user Shoddy-Exchange-9055 (desisted male) comments on the political climate, explaining how detransition is often seen as "glamourization of trans conversion therapy" by some, while others in the trans community view it as a "second transition."
10 pointsDec 2, 2024
View on Reddit

I think it can happen but unfortunately given the current political climate, such things would be seen as "glamourization of trans conversion therapy".

There are tons of detrans-positive people in the trans community that see detransition as a "second transition" or "further finding authenticity" which I agree but then you have the legions that see anything that is non-affirmative of medical and social transition as "transphobic" and a "menace".

It will just enter cultural battle hell imo.

Reddit user Shoddy-Exchange-9055 (desisted male) explains that part of his transition was motivated by a belief that women could be cool and respected without having to look like "creepy bulky creatures."
7 pointsJan 6, 2025
View on Reddit

As a male dealing with similar things but in the exact opposite way you are feeling, I just wanna say that part of my transition was motivated because I thought women were capable of being absolutely cool and respected without looking like creepy bulky creatures.

I don't know if it's even a positive response, but just wanted to share it, you are not alone in your internalized feelings against your own gender!