This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or an inauthentic persona.
The comments demonstrate:
- Internal Consistency: A coherent, deeply personal narrative of transitioning (FTM), detransitioning, and the reasons behind it (e.g., misogyny, the failure of transition to resolve dysphoria).
- Emotional Complexity: A range of genuine emotions—anger, pain, loneliness, hope, and hard-won peace—that align with the stated experience of a detransitioner.
- Specific, Plausible Details: References to personal life events (e.g., a butch coworker transitioning, a supportive fiancé, specific books that helped) that are not generic and fit the narrative.
- Engaged Conversation: The user tailors advice and shares personal anecdotes in response to other users' specific situations, which is atypical for bot behavior.
The account represents a gender-critical perspective common in some detransition spaces, and the passion and criticism present are consistent with a genuine individual who feels harmed by their experience.
About me
I desperately wanted to be male and started testosterone at 18, believing it would solve all my problems. I realized at 20 that it wouldn't make me male, and I had to face my deep self-hatred and internalized misogyny. Learning about butch women who were happy without transitioning was what finally started my detransition. I've made peace with being female and am now in a happy, straight relationship with a man who accepts me. I'm happier and more at peace than I ever was during my transition.
My detransition story
My whole journey with transition and detransition started because I desperately wanted to be male. I thought if I could just become a man, all my problems would be solved. I believed it would make me confident, handsome, and finally allow me to fit in. I started identifying as trans when I was around 17 and began taking testosterone when I was 18. I was on it for two years.
But transition didn't give me what I wanted. It didn't make me male. I finally realized that around age 20, and it sent me into a real crisis. I felt like I was stuck being female, and it seemed like a cruel joke. My coping mechanism had stopped working, and I had to face reality without it.
I came to understand that a lot of my dysphoria was rooted in internalized misogyny. I had been taught to hate my female body and to see male as better. I never had any butch or gender-nonconforming female role models growing up, and I discovered feminism too late. If I had seen women living happily with dysphoria without transitioning, it might have changed my path sooner. The first time I encountered a woman like that, it started my questioning, which led me to detransition.
I don't regret my transition because I think I had to go through it to get to where I am now. But I also know it was an escape hatch that didn't actually work. The self-hatred didn't go away. When people knew I was trans, they often treated me worse, and when they didn't know, it felt hollow. The only real option was to make peace with being female, which felt impossible at the time.
Now, I see my body as a normal female body, not a deformed male one. That shift in perspective was huge for me. I stopped comparing myself to men and trained myself to redirect those painful thoughts. I even found a strange sense of connection when my menstrual cycle returned after stopping testosterone—it felt like a link to other women.
Socially, it's been a journey. I moved in very liberal, pro-trans circles, and detransitioning there was lonely. I often felt like an outsider, especially when another butch woman at my work decided to use they/them pronouns, leaving me as the only one not identifying as trans. I've found that I generally prefer friendships with men because they seem to care less about all this stuff.
I'm in a straight relationship now with a man who accepts me as I am. We met after I detransitioned, and he's been wonderful about everything. I'm happier and more at peace than I ever was during my transition. I still have moments of dysphoria, but they're manageable now. I'm just living my life.
Here is a timeline of my journey:
Age | Event |
---|---|
17 | Started identifying as transgender. |
18 | Began taking testosterone. |
20 | Stopped testosterone after realizing it wouldn't make me male. |
20 | Officially detransitioned and began to accept being female. |
21 | Menstrual cycle returned. |
22 | Met my future fiancé. |
Top Comments by /u/catchbinkill:
Oof I remember that feeling. Coming out the second time was so, so much harder than the first. Like you say, the guilt & humiliation of admitting I put my mother through all that pain for “nothing,” and that she was right about it being a phase. She took it incredibly gracefully, all things considered.
You’re strong OP, you can do this! ❤️
It sounds like you would benefit from talking to a therapist. If you go that route, just be careful not to end up putting faith in one who will encourage you to transition. That conversation would just be a waste of your time and cause you even more distress. It’s clear you don’t want to transition and so I hope it’s reassuring to hear from a stranger on the internet — you’re not trans, and you’re not going to become trans against your will.
I used to be trans. As far as I’m concerned, “being trans” = identifying as trans. Nobody is ACTUALLY born in the wrong body/supposed to be the opposite sex; you either have dysphoria or you don’t, and how you conceptualise it/deal with it can change over time.
Ew, I’m so sorry that happened to you. Thank you for raising the alarm.
As a trans teen I was twitter mutuals with some adult AGPs who would ask people to tweet at them in the third person using their pronouns/affirming their femininity. To “validate” them and “help with their dysphoria.” Like “Violet is a girl, she is so pretty” or whatever. Poor naive little me thought she was doing a good thing, she was really just feeding their fetish. 🤢
Detransition itself is also a burgeoning kink scene now. If you search it on tumblr you’ll find lots of trans people sharing their fantasies of being correctively raped and forced to conform to their birth sex role. Stay vigilant against perverts using our experiences this way. ✌️
One small piece of advice I’d like to offer, based on my own experience, would be to avoid thinking of “trans” and “cis” as things you just inherently are. They’re labels that broadly describe different ways of living, but neither of them is written indelibly on a piece of paper hidden deep inside your brain, if you see what I mean. You can never know what you really are deep down, because deep down you’re not anything very clear-cut or specific. We all just make choices based on how we feel, and then we label those choices after the fact — sometimes our feelings change, so our choices change, so our labels change.
I know this isn’t really answering the question you asked! Just something on my mind, that’s all. I hope you get lots of helpful answers OP, and I wish you lots of strength & luck, it sounds like you’re in a difficult place rn. ❤️
these are just things that have helped me and/or people i know! obviously everyone is different etc but my top quick recs are:
- avoid trans content, mute people who love to push how wonderful transition is etc
- spend more time with your body, admire the things it can do, accept the neutral objective fact of what it is
- exercise for fun + get fit
- if you’re female, get into 2nd wave feminism. read the scum manifesto, egalia’s daughters, herland, woman on the edge of time, the female man. you don’t have to pursue separatism but read about it and let it teach you something about your own value & capabilities
- some dysphoric women also get into witchcraft/occult/pagan stuff or goddess worship, so experiment if that interests you
- personally, celibacy really helps me. if you’re sexually active you could try it for a while or just cut back/be more selective about partners
Obviously nothing's changed except I got a better camera :P
I'd been on blockers for a while, started T when I was 18, took it for two years before stopping. My fiancé took this last photo in our living room a few weeks ago. Look close and you can see my scraggly little beard. I really don't regret anything.
I get it and I totally sympathise. This is a cliché and it’s easier said than done, obviously, but still: I think you should take the plunge and be true to yourself, regardless of what other people might say. Getting judged is an inevitable part of life, you can’t afford to keep living a lie because you’re worried what other people might think.
As to how to make it easier... tbh my experience was swift disillusionment with, and exit from, the capital-q Queer Community. That’s more specific than the lgbt community, I mean the social & political scene dominated by Trans and Queer politics, which I assume is what you’re talking about. I came to realise the politics are pretty bad and the scene, while fun sometimes, is actually kind of insane and not a very safe place for GNC women. Six years ago when I was a student all my friends were Queer, now that word is a red flag for me.
I’m bi but I’m in a monogamous straight relationship now, so I have had to go through that process of slowly losing my connection to lgbt identity. It is kinda sad, and something is lost, but that’s another inevitable part of life, to be grateful for the experiences you had and let them go. You stand to gain other things — identity and community with other women, a more authentic relationship with yourself and your sexuality. You can try to do it gradually — like, start reorienting your sense of self/community around other things, and don’t let go of Queer until you feel ready to do so.
I have always had dysphoria about my FEMALE traits. That’s WHY I transitioned in the first place. I only stopped because transition didn’t help.
Your underlying assumption is that, for everyone with REAL dysphoria, transition works. That’s one of the most harmful myths that detrans advocates are trying to counter.
It sounds like you’re having a very difficult time and I wish there was more I could do to help. All I can do is remind you of something you already know, since you’re on this sub: that you’re not the first person to have feelings like this and come out the other side alright, one way or the other. You wouldn’t be the first person with intense, long-term dysphoria to have a change of heart and go on to lead a happy, fulfilling life. 22 is very young, your brain is still developing, it is absolutely not crazy or improbable for you to go through big changes at this age.
Acknowledging the fact that I’m female used to make me feel worthless, wrong, invisible, unreal, like my life wouldn’t begin until I could transition. I don’t feel that way anymore, even though I still have dysphoria, and I’m doing really good. It didn’t happen overnight and it was certainly a hard, scary process, but it didn’t ruin my life. I’m only saying this in the hope it makes you feel less alone and a bit less anxious about the future. Wishing you lots of good vibes & good luck, I hope things start to clear up for you soon. ❤️