This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.
The user's comments show:
- Personal, nuanced experience with detransition, recovery, and mental health.
- Consistent perspective over a three-year period, with a focus on caution and healing.
- Emotional investment and passion that aligns with the stated harm and stigma faced by detransitioners.
The account does not exhibit the repetitive, simplistic, or agenda-driven posting that would indicate inauthenticity.
About me
I was born female and my discomfort with puberty led me to online communities that convinced me transition was the only answer. I took testosterone and had surgery, but it only made my underlying depression and anxiety harder to manage. I eventually realized my problems weren't about gender but were tied to low self-esteem and internalized sexism. After detransitioning, I lost friends but found peace by disconnecting from social media and embracing being a masculine woman. I now believe you must heal your mental health and meet your basic human needs before making any permanent changes.
My detransition story
My whole journey with transition and detransition was complicated and, looking back, I think a lot of it was driven by things I didn't understand about myself at the time. I was born female and as a teenager, I felt a strong discomfort with my body, especially during puberty. I hated my breasts and felt a real disconnect from what was happening to me. I now see that feeling a disconnect with your body as a teenager is a much more common experience than people think.
I was influenced a lot by what I saw online. I spent a huge amount of time in online communities that, I realize now, were echo chambers. These spaces made transitioning seem like the only answer to my discomfort. I also think I used the idea of being a different gender as a form of escapism from my other problems, which included depression, anxiety, and very low self-esteem. I was trying to fix internal issues with an external solution.
I ended up taking testosterone and I got top surgery. The testosterone had a big effect on me, both physically and emotionally, and it made working through my underlying issues much harder because I wasn't in a stable, natural state. I wish I had focused on healing from my trauma before making any permanent decisions that altered my body. I would advise anyone considering this to find their natural baseline first.
After a while, I realized that my problems weren't really about gender. Femininity isn't an innate part of being a woman, and I didn't need to change my body to be okay with who I am. A huge turning point for me was cutting my screen time and disconnecting from social media. It did wonders for my mental health and helped me see things more clearly, away from those online pressures.
I lost my entire friend group when I detransitioned. It was painful, but it showed me that if their existence feels threatened by my personal choice to live authentically, that's their problem, not mine. Their reaction came from their own insecurity.
I don't think there's one single way to be trans or to detransition. Our experiences are all unique. For me, a lot of my body issues were tied up with low self-esteem and internalized ideas about sexism and what a woman should be. I’ve found peace in understanding that there's nothing wrong with being a masculine woman.
I do have some regrets about my transition, specifically about the permanent changes to my body. My fat distribution still isn't completely back to normal, and it's a constant reminder. I've had to learn to be upfront with potential partners about my past, understanding that anyone who isn't accepting isn't worth my time.
Ultimately, I believe you have to meet your basic human needs—like social connection and safety—before you can really figure out things like identity. For anyone struggling, my advice is to focus on building a real-life support system, invest in a good therapist, and give yourself time. Your brain is still developing, and there's no reason to rush into irreversible changes.
Age | Event |
---|---|
14-15 | Started experiencing intense puberty discomfort and hated my developing breasts. |
16 | Spent increasing time in online trans communities, which influenced my perspective. |
17 | Began socially transitioning and using a new name/pronouns. |
18 | Started testosterone (T) hormone therapy. |
20 | Underwent top surgery (double mastectomy). |
21 | Began to detransition, stopping testosterone. |
21 | Lost my entire friend circle after detransitioning. |
22 | Focused heavily on disconnecting from social media and online echo chambers to improve my mental health. |
Top Comments by /u/cicatrizzz:
The "egg" phenomenon is a flagrant projection of insecurity, imo. Most who headcanon characters (or real people) as trans can't tolerate the fact that someone can be comfortable in their own body, so they literally create a fantasy to cope. To that group, detransitioners are somewhere in the same level; they can't cope with the fact that someone might've regretted their transition, and therefore it makes them feel insecure over their own. I genuinely think that's where a big chunk of the hate comes from.
Yeah, the mindset of "well, you weren't REALLY trans" is super toxic. I don't even think trans activists can agree on one single definition of 'being trans' these days beyond the label itself. I suppose that makes it easier to deny our experiences. 🤷
I lost my whole friend circle after I detransitioned, sadly. The only real answer is to find some better friends. If their existence feels threatened by your own personal choice, that's on them. Just goes to show how insecure they are in themselves, and it doesn't reflect on you whatsoever.
There's no single "checklist" for detransitioners, tbh. All of our experiences are unique and highly circumstantial. They'll vary pretty broadly based on who you ask specifically, especially between men and women.
Calling this subreddit a "hive mind" is a bit bizarre, though... Could you elaborate on that?
You desperately need to focus on healing from any trauma before making permanent decisions that drastically alter your body. I would even advise taking a break from HRT, if you're able to; though I'm obviously not a psychiatrist or medical professional. Only speaking from experience. Recovery would've been so much easier for me to undergo if I hadn't been an emotional/physical mess from how testosterone was effecting me at the time. Think of your natural state as a "baseline" and strive to work from there before making any final decisions. You're still young. There's no reason to rush through a transition, especially for the changes that aren't reversible.
You sure are making a lot of assumptions about this person's health, and how she's possibly been advised by medical professionals.
Also, if you took five minutes to look over her social media, you wouldn't have needed to make your initial assumption about how she's a "grifter".
This is a gross over-simplification of several issues, but I'll bite.
Nobody has "held anyone at gunpoint" to transition. Pretending as though social coercion and medical malpractice don't exist is completely disingenuous.
'Gendies' is a term referring to people who harbor extremist views regarding transgenderism, such as medically transitioning children and claims of body dysphoria not being a prerequisite for being trans. It can be used for cis individuals as well. People on this sub often refer to them a cult *because* extreme ideologies frequently operate in similar fashions. It's a mindset that you have to unshackle yourself from in order to view these problems through an objective, non-biased lens.
It's an unfortunate reality.
Over time, it might decrease in size slightly; but nobody here can give you guarantees or methods on how to speed up the process. I really wish there was.
I recommend being upfront with potential sexual partners about your experience. Anyone who isn't accepting of your past trauma isn't worth your time, tbh.
You look just fine. Maybe a standard level of slight chubbiness, nothing more. I wouldn't assume you'd been on HRT at all otherwise, even as a fellow detransitioner.
I think fat distribution can take a few years to fully normalize, so don't lose hope!
Living as a biological male, and injecting male hormones as a biological female are two completely separate things. You aren't even comparing apples vs. oranges, you're comparing apples vs. juice boxes. The two instances are nothing alike.
Please, if you don't want to keep being an embarrassment to the trans movement as a whole, I implore you to actually do research on how HRT alters body chemistry.