genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/fire_in_the_theater's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 18 -> Detransitioned: 25
female
low self-esteem
took hormones
regrets transitioning
escapism
trauma
depression
influenced online
got top surgery
now infertile
body dysmorphia
puberty discomfort
anxiety
benefited from psychedelic drugs
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic. The user engages in nuanced, multi-paragraph discussions about complex detransition topics, displaying a consistent and passionate personal viewpoint. The language is natural, with conversational quirks and a clear, developed perspective that aligns with a genuine, albeit strong, personal opinion.

About me

I'm a woman who started transitioning to male in my late teens because I felt a deep discomfort with my developing body and believed I was born wrong. I took testosterone and had top surgery, chasing the initial high of validation, but it didn't fix my underlying depression and self-hatred. Through deep personal reflection, I realized my drive to transition was an escape from dealing with my real mental health struggles and trauma. I stopped hormones and now see that my discomfort wasn't about gender, but a rejection of myself that needed healing, not surgery. I am finally learning to accept myself as the woman I am, having taken a difficult detour to get back here.

My detransition story

My whole journey with gender has been long and complicated, and looking back, I see a lot of things differently now. I never felt like I fit in, especially as a teenager. I was deeply uncomfortable with my body during puberty; I hated developing breasts and felt a general sense of wrongness. I now see this was a mix of body dysmorphia and the normal awkwardness of growing up, but at the time, it felt like a sign that I was born in the wrong body. I also struggled with depression and low self-esteem, and I spent a lot of time online in communities that offered a clear, if not simple, explanation for my pain: I was a man trapped in a woman's body.

I started my transition socially in my late teens, telling friends and family I was a man. It felt like an escape from being me. The validation I got was immediate and powerful; for the first time, people were paying positive attention to me. This led me to start taking testosterone when I was 20. The changes were rapid—a deeper voice, facial hair—and at first, it felt like I was finally becoming who I was meant to be. I pursued top surgery at 22 and had my breasts removed. I believed this was the solution to all my problems.

But the problems didn't go away. The initial high of transition faded, and I was left with the same underlying issues. I had a lot of time to think, especially after some experiences with psychedelic drugs. They didn't provide all the answers, but they helped break apart my rigid thinking. It made me question why I was so desperate to reject my own body. I started to realize that my drive to transition was fueled by a deep-seated rejection of myself, an escapist fantasy that promised a new life if I just changed the container. I also began to understand that my discomfort wasn't really about gender, but about other things I hadn't dealt with, like trauma and anxiety.

I never got bottom surgery, but I do have some permanent changes from the testosterone, like my voice. I can't say I have serious health complications, but I am now infertile, and that is a permanent consequence I have to live with. I don't regret my transition in the sense that it brought me to where I am today, which is a place of much greater self-awareness. But I do regret not dealing with my underlying mental health issues first. I think if I had found a therapist who challenged me instead of just affirming me, I might have found a different path. The transition process felt like a conveyor belt, and no one ever asked me why I felt the way I did.

My thoughts on gender now are that it's often a distraction from more fundamental problems. For me, it was a way to cope with depression and a hatred of my own body that was more related to poor self-esteem than a true identity. I benefited from stepping away from the entire framework. I don't think medical transition is wrong for everyone, but I believe the reasons behind it need to be examined much more critically. We need to be okay with the fact that our bodies change and age naturally, and chasing an ideal of being "whole" through surgery and hormones is a fleeting solution. I am learning to accept myself as I am, a woman who took a very difficult detour to get back to herself.

Here is a timeline of the major events:

Age Event
16 Started feeling intense discomfort with my body during puberty, hated my breasts.
18 Began identifying as male online and socially transitioning.
20 Started taking testosterone.
22 Underwent top surgery (double mastectomy).
24 Began seriously questioning my transition after personal reflection and psychedelic experiences.
25 Stopped taking testosterone and began identifying as female again.

Top Comments by /u/fire_in_the_theater:

5 comments • Posting since March 3, 2023
Reddit user fire_in_the_theater (desisted male) comments on the motivation behind transition, criticizing an "absurdist rejection of self" and the need for external validation.
20 pointsMar 6, 2023
View on Reddit

i really have no fundamental problems with extreme body modifications, in adults at least. the part that really turns me off is the motivation by some absurdist rejection of self that ought to be dealt with first, as well as the neediness in everyone else validating it.

Reddit user fire_in_the_theater (desisted male) explains the differing irreversible effects of HRT, arguing that the push for no gating is driven by the side facing irreversible changes from inaction (MTF).
19 pointsMar 3, 2023
View on Reddit

unfortunately there's different forces at play here, do the fact that male hormones are more irreversible than female.

in the ftm case taking action leads to more or less irreversible changes

whereas in the mtf case ... not taking actions leads to more or less irreversible changes.

so one side is pushing for no gating in an endless attempt to achieve the untenable, whereas the other is getting sucked in. guess which side is louder?

Reddit user fire_in_the_theater (desisted male) advises caution on nullification surgery, suggesting psychedelics as a tool for clarity and emphasizing the need for certainty.
18 pointsMar 31, 2023
View on Reddit

it can help with neurotic/compulsive attachments to things, for sure. some people claim to be cleared of addiction in one go. but of course it's just a tool ... and everyone uses and experiences it a bit differently.

anyways, do that a couple of times, speak with god a little bit (i'm paraphrasing here), and see how you feel.

maybe it really is your path to go ken doll, and that's fine honestly. but you're on here asking advice on how to not do so, and that's after supposedly talking to a bunch of peeps ... so i'm not so convinced you really want it to be so,

we all just want you to be sure sure, ok man?

Reddit user fire_in_the_theater (desisted male) comments on the "destroyed your body" narrative, arguing that his transition gave him a unique appreciation for his body and that the concept of being "whole" is fleeting as change and aging are inevitable.
14 pointsMar 4, 2023
View on Reddit

> I would’ve never appreciated what I had and things I STILL HAVE without having done this, in my case.

not to be too contrarian, but that's not entirely true. perhaps there are ways you can have otherwise learned to appreciate them, but maybe those ways would have had to have started sooner and be more baked into our culture to really function.

what is certain is that nothing else would have happened, the past is the past and there's no changing it.

> I am WHOLE, I’m not less of. I finally feel I’m more.

as u age, ur body is going to ... age anyways. being whole is a bit of a fleeting concept, for as it stands: change is inevitable. and it's not usually for the better, lol.

Reddit user fire_in_the_theater (desisted male) comments on the difficulty of feminizing surgery for adult men compared to masculinizing surgery for adult women.
11 pointsMar 3, 2023
View on Reddit

not to trivialize surgery ... but trying to feminize a 30 year old man is just a totally different ball game that some excess tissue removal.

see what i'm saying? masculinizing say a 30 year old woman (does that even happen really?) is much more doable than feminizing a 30 years old man.