genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/iridescentnightshade's Detransition Story

male
suspicious account
This story is from the comments by /u/iridescentnightshade that are listed below, summarised with AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
User Authenticity Assessment: Suspicious Account

Based on the provided comments, this account is inauthentic as a detransitioner or desister.

Red Flags:

  • The user consistently identifies as a therapist or counselor, not as someone who has personally detransitioned or desisted.
  • Every comment is from the perspective of a clinical professional offering advice, resources, and opinions on therapeutic practices, with no personal narrative of a detrans/desister experience.
  • The account functions primarily to promote specific organizations and a "gender exploratory" therapeutic model, not to share a personal journey.

About me

I am a therapist who became concerned about the pressure in my field to only provide one type of care. I felt I couldn't explore my clients' full stories, so I sought out training in neutral, exploratory therapy. This approach allows me to help people look at all the factors in their life that might be influencing their feelings. I believe the current medical path is not evidence-based and that my duty is to do no harm. Now, I am committed to offering a safe, ethical space for people who are questioning.

My detransition story

I am a therapist, and my journey with this topic is professional, not personal. I have never identified as transgender or experienced gender dysphoria myself. My interest began because I was deeply concerned as a counselor about the pressure to provide only one type of care—affirmative therapy—and I wanted to be better informed to help my clients.

I feel a tremendous amount of pressure in my field to conform to trans-affirmative therapy. I attended a conference where I heard the Southern Poverty Law Center say they were "hunting down" therapists who don't conform, which I found chilling. It felt like I wasn't allowed to explore my clients' stories in depth or ask challenging questions without risking my license. I believe we've drawn a false binary between "Affirmation Therapy" and "Conversion Therapy." There are many other ways to approach therapy, and this pressure tells therapists they can only do one type.

Because of this, I went looking for other ethical approaches. I studied under Mark Yarhouse through the Institute for Sexual Wholeness, which trains Christian counselors. I also connected with the Gender Exploratory Therapy Association. These resources helped me learn to provide a neutral, exploratory space for clients questioning their gender, rather than immediately affirming an identity. This type of therapy allows for a deeper look into all the factors in a person's life, like trauma, autism, or internalized homophobia, that might be influencing their feelings.

Reading stories in communities like this one has been invaluable. It has made me a better, more thoughtful therapist. One comment that really stuck with me was about our bodies being shrines. It reminded me that even when we don't like how our bodies look, they are still incredible and deserve our respect. That’s a message I think everyone needs to hear.

My professional view is that "gender-affirming" treatments are not evidence-based. The recent Cass Report and the leaked WPATH files show a shocking lack of evidence that these medical interventions reduce dysphoria or suicidality in the long term. As a clinician, my ethical duty is to do no harm. I believe informed consent for these experimental procedures is often impossible, especially for young people whose brains aren't fully developed. I've had to tell clients "no" to other harmful requests, and I believe clinicians have that same responsibility here.

I don't have a personal transition or detransition story to share, but I am committed to supporting those who are questioning or struggling by offering a therapeutic space that is exploratory, ethical, and neutral.

Age Date (YYYY-MM) Event
N/A 2020-02 Began voicing professional concern about the limitations of affirmative-only therapy.
N/A 2022-02 Started recommending and providing resources for gender exploratory therapy.
N/A 2023-09 Formally began studying and practicing gender exploratory therapy after training.

Top Reddit Comments by /u/iridescentnightshade:

13 comments • Posting since February 10, 2020
Reddit user iridescentnightshade (verified therapist ✅) shares resources for gender exploratory therapy, including a Christian-based training organization they are part of.
34 pointsSep 4, 2022
View on Reddit

https://www.sexualwholeness.com/current-therapist-list and

https://genderexploratory.com/business-directory/

are both places people can find therapists who offer gender exploratory therapy. I am a therapist with Sexual Wholeness, which trains Christian counselors in the field of sex therapy. We are trained to utilize the gender exploratory model for clients with gender dysphoria.

Based on the provided comment, here's a concise title incorporating key details:**"Reddit user iridescentnightshade (verified therapist ✅) explains why gender affirmation treatments lack evidence (citing WPATH files and Cass Report) and constitute malpractice under ethical codes."**### Key Details Included:- **User identity**: Highlights their verified therapist flair for credibility - **Core argument**: Explicitly states that gender affirmation treatments are not evidence-based - **Critical sources**: Mentions both the WPATH files and Cass Report as evidence - **Professional stance**: Notes that compliance via "informed consent" is malpractice - **Ethical context**: References clinicians' duty to refuse harmful requests - **Conciseness**: Keeps essential claims intact while avoiding minor examples (e.g., repressed memories) This title maintains neutrality while accurately summarizing the comment’s central thesis and evidentiary basis.
33 pointsJul 3, 2024
View on Reddit

I just want to chime in here and say that this is not at all the standard clinicians are held to. All of our ethical codes instruct us to use evidence based practices. "Gender Affirmation" treatments are not considered to be evidenced based at this point in time. We also now have proof that even WPATH members admit this in secret in the WPATH files. One clinician even noted specifically that Informed Consent isn't really possible when working with this vulnerable population.

"Gender Affirmation" treatments are considered to be the Standard of Care by WPATH, but it is not evidenced based because we have no evidence showing us that they help reduce dysphoria or reduce suicidality. In fact, the Cass Report delineates the shocking lack of evidence in these practices.

Clients ask me to do a lot of things that could potentially harm them and as their therapist, it is my job to tell them "no." I've been asked to do things such as trying to recall repressed memories, provide conversion therapy, and to enable abusive spouses in marriages. I have expressly told all of these clients "no" since all of these have significant likelihood of harm and there is no evidence to back up the practice.

Clinicians who only do as asked by their patients or clients under the guise of Informed Consent are almost certainly committing malpractice and should have their licenses to practice taken away from them through the appropriate governing body.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade (verified therapist ✅) explains that non-religious and Christian-affiliated therapists can provide quality care for gender-questioning individuals from all backgrounds.
26 pointsSep 4, 2022
View on Reddit

Genderexploratory.com is not religious at all. And most Christian counselors through the Institute for Sexual Wholeness are going to be fully capable of providing excellent therapy to people who are not Christian. I have seen several clients over the years who come from various religious backgrounds and it was still a quality fit.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade comments on a post about questioning transition, explaining that the body is a shrine that fights to keep you alive and deserves respect regardless of appearance.
22 pointsFeb 22, 2020
View on Reddit

Lastly, it took me having some sense knocked into me that yes, our bodies are shrines. Just because you don't like the way it looks doesn't mean that it's a bad body. Your body, the way it is, is the reason you are alive right now. It fights with all its strength when you are ill, it helps you feel all the pleasures you've felt in your life. It will try to fight, tolerate and endure all the physical and emotional damage that you experience until it's last breath.

Even as someone who isn't trans, this still resonates so much! It is a shrine worth my respect, and I need to remember that when I don't especially like the way it looks. Thank you for the reminder and encouragement :)

Reddit user iridescentnightshade (verified therapist ✅) lists resources for finding non-affirming, neutral, and ethical therapy for gender dysphoria.
13 pointsFeb 1, 2022
View on Reddit

They do exist! I am actually one of those therapists. I would recommend a few resources to find someone like myself.

If you are open to someone who views gender through the lens of the Christian faith, then ISW would be the place to go. This is where I was trained and Mark Yarhouse is the resident expert on all things LGBT+ for us. We are trained in utilizing methods that are ethical and neutral regarding gender identity and are also not going to prosthelytize our clients.

Gender Exploratory Therapy Association is a place that lists mental health professionals around the world who do not affirm and are willing to take a more neutral stance about gender identity.

Partners for Ethical Care is a place that has a multitude of various types of resources, including therapy resources all over the world.

Thoughtful Therapists is a group of therapists from the UK and Ireland who question affirmative care and promote a neutral approach to trans and GD issues.

I hope that helps. If you need more help, feel free to DM me. I believe very strongly in people getting the ethical help for their gender dysphoria that they need and I will do my best to find you help meets your needs.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade, a counselor, explains their subscription to the subreddit stems from professional concern and skepticism about the recent wave of people identifying as trans, and that reading the stories here helps them become a better therapist.
12 pointsFeb 20, 2020
View on Reddit

I'm a counselor, not trans. I'm subscribed because I'm concerned, and a bit skeptical, about the wave of people newly identifying as trans. I like to be informed about all approaches to an issue as a therapist and this is an excellent forum for that.

I will also add that I find tremendous encouragement to be a better quality therapist when I read everyone's stories here.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade (verified therapist ✅) recommends Gender Exploratory Therapy and the genderexploratory.com website for mental health professionals.
8 pointsDec 14, 2022
View on Reddit

I would encourage you to look into Gender Exploratory Therapy. The website https://genderexploratory.com has lots of helps on how to incorporate this type of treatment into your repertoire and provides an ability to advertise yourself this way. I am one of their providers and I get tons of contacts all over the country pretty regularly for this type of treatment. They also offer trainings and meetings for its members.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade, a therapist, explains feeling pressure to only provide trans-affirmative care and fears lawsuits or losing their license for exploring or challenging a client's gender dysphoria, citing a threat from the Southern Poverty Law Center to hunt down non-conforming therapists.
8 pointsFeb 10, 2020
View on Reddit

I will tell you that, as a therapist, I feel tremendous pressure to conform to trans affirmative therapy. I would love to be allowed to explore my trans client's stories in more depth and even challenge them some, but I risk lawsuits and my license if I engage in that type of therapy. Some might say I'm being overly dramatic, but I have listened as the Southern Poverty Law Center said at a conference I attended that they were in the process of "hunting down" therapists who don't conform. Talk about chilling.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade explains why Oklahoma's proposed ban on non-gender-affirming therapy creates a false binary between affirmation and conversion therapy, arguing it limits therapeutic options for transgender individuals.
5 pointsFeb 14, 2020
View on Reddit

Strangely enough I think we are drawing a false binary when it comes to "Affirmation Therapy" and "Conversion Therapy." There are a myriad of other ways to approach therapy with the LGBT+ community. This ban tells therapists they can only do one type of therapy when the issue is transgender.

Reddit user iridescentnightshade (verified therapist ✅) explains why patients bear no responsibility for transgender medical treatments, arguing that true informed consent is impossible due to the experimental nature and lack of long-term research.
5 pointsJun 7, 2025
View on Reddit

I just wanted to chime in to speak up about the responsibility that a clinician holds when providing their services. 

The whole idea that a patient bears any kind of responsibility in engaging in transgender medicine is blatantly false. There is something called "Informed Consent" that is required when I engage with any patient. I have to review the pros, cons, and boundaries of any kind of treatment with them. 

I specifically remember when the WPATH files dropped, there was an account of one professional talking about how informed consent is impossible with many patients. I'm still astonished that transgender medicine is allowed to be performed on anyone under the age of 25 when the frontal lobes of the brain have finally developed.

To answer your question, OP, medical and healthcare ethicists would say you bear no responsibility whatsoever since informed consent was not secured. It couldn't be because trans medicine is still experimental. We have no reliable research on long term effects of these types of interventions. But you weren't told it was experimental, which also means you weren't given informed consent.