This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.
The user's comments demonstrate:
- Personal Investment: They reference specific, nuanced cases (e.g., post-orchiectomy regret) and use language like "I'm haunted by..." which suggests genuine emotional engagement.
- Consistent, Developed Views: Their perspective on AGP, trauma, and the social complexities of detransition is consistent and shows a depth of understanding that aligns with a real person's lived experience or deep research.
- Community Interaction: The tone is that of someone offering advice and sharing observations within a community, not just repeating slogans.
The passion and specific viewpoints expressed are well within the expected range for a genuine detransitioner or desister.
About me
I'm a man who transitioned because I felt weak and hated the expectations placed on males, thinking becoming a woman was the answer. My journey involved hormones and surgery, which left me feeling hollow and caused permanent changes to my body, including infertility. Hearing another person's story of devastating regret was the turning point that made me stop and finally confront my underlying trauma and internalized homophobia in therapy. I've since detransitioned and now understand my problems were never about my body but about my mind, which needed healing instead of alteration. I am now at peace simply being myself, though I live with significant regrets about the permanent choices I made.
My detransition story
My journey with gender started from a place of deep discomfort, but looking back, I see now that it was never really about being born in the wrong body. It was about trauma, confusion, and trying to escape from myself.
I was a feminine boy who never fit in with other guys. I felt weak and vulnerable, and I hated the expectations that came with being male. I thought all men were aggressive and problematic, and I wanted no part of it. This feeling got much worse during puberty; I hated the changes and felt completely disconnected from my developing body. I now see this was a mix of body dysmorphia and a deep-seated anxiety about growing up and the world.
I found a lot of comfort online in trans communities. They gave me a new identity and a clear path to follow: I was a woman trapped in a man's body. It felt like an answer to all my problems. I latched onto this idea completely. I started to believe my attraction to women was actually a form of autogynephilia (AGP), a fetish where I was imagining myself as a woman. This, combined with internalized homophobia—I was uncomfortable accepting I was just a gay man—pushed me further down the transition path.
I began socially transitioning in my early twenties, asking people to use a new name and she/her pronouns. It felt good at first, like I was finally becoming someone else. But that feeling was fleeting. I started estrogen and testosterone blockers. The hormones changed my body, but they also did something I didn't expect: they killed my sex drive. At the time, I thought that was a good thing, that it was calming the "AGP" feelings. I now realize that sex drive is a fundamental part of who a person is, and removing it was like removing a part of my core self.
I kept moving forward because I felt I had to. I'd told everyone, changed my name, and invested so much into this new identity that turning back felt impossible. I was terrified of being wrong and of what people would think. I had top surgery to create breasts. After the surgery, there was no moment of joy or relief. Instead, I felt a hollow emptiness. I had done this huge, permanent thing and felt nothing. It was a major wake-up call.
The real turning point was hearing other people's stories. I read about a young man who had an orchiectomy and the moment he woke up from surgery, he was flooded with instant, devastating regret. His story haunted me because I understood it. His sex drive, which had been a driving force for him, vanished after the surgery, and with it went his desire to transition. It made me see that I was on the exact same path, heading for the same painful realization.
I started to detransition. I stopped the hormones. It was scary to tell everyone, again, that I had been wrong. Some people were understanding, but others in the trans community didn't take it well, which was hard. I think my questioning made them question their own choices. I started to see a therapist who wasn't just affirming but actually helped me dig into the why behind my feelings. That non-affirming therapy was crucial. We worked through my trauma, my low self-esteem, my discomfort with being a gay man, and my body issues. I learned that my problems couldn't be solved by changing my body; they had to be solved by healing my mind.
I don't identify as a woman anymore. I'm just me, a man who has been through a lot. My thoughts on gender now are that it's become far too complicated. I wish the intense focus on pronouns would go away; it causes more stress than it's worth. I think "they/them" is a fair option for anyone who is unsure.
I have significant regrets about my transition. I regret the permanent changes I made to my body, especially the breast implants, which I now want to have removed. I am now infertile because of the hormones, which is a permanent loss that I have to live with. My body is forever altered. But I don't regret the journey itself because it led me to a much deeper understanding of who I am. I had to go through that to finally come back to myself.
Age | Date (Approximate) | Event |
---|---|---|
23 | Early 2019 | Began socially transitioning, using a new name and she/her pronouns. |
24 | Mid 2019 | Started taking estrogen and testosterone blockers. |
25 | Late 2020 / Early 2021 | Underwent top surgery (breast augmentation). |
25 | Mid 2021 | Realized I had made a mistake, began detransitioning by stopping hormones. |
26 | 2022 | Started therapy to address underlying trauma, anxiety, and internalized homophobia. |
Top Comments by /u/kabloona:
You are still pretty young. Give yourself a couple of years to mull it over. I'm haunted by the post of a young MtF who had an orchie and as soon as he came to he knew right away that he'd made a horrible mistake and was absolutely devastated. Thankfully he was able to connect with another person who had had the exact same reaction years previously and they were able to talk privately. I think for them, their sex drive had been a big factor and after the orchie their sex drive was gone and they were devastated. There is a lot of rose tinted stories out there so maybe look for the honest ones.
Trauma is often at the root of many young trans explorer stories. Oftentimes they don't realize it until they are much further down the path and have done serious damage to their bodies. People often think they can't go back because they changed so many things and came out to their friends as trans but you are you. I think when you've had a chance to look around you will find other trans explorers making their way back to their original path or a new, different one. Safe journey.
You should see an experienced psychologist. Your upbringing would screw anybody up but especially someone who is gay. Maybe you are one of the small number of gay transexuals who need to transition so you should probably get to the bottom of your so called AGP......or maybe you've paid too much attention to the trans narrative we all keep seeing in society these days. I would look for a referral to a good psychologist who has experience with gay clientele.
I know plenty of outgoing men who can befriend any stranger on the street but if you are not outgoing and also non-threatening looking you are going to be ignored, and people, particularly women are going to avoid eye contact. Men get a bad rap but it’s deserved. Maybe if they called out the assholes amongst themselves things would improve, but I think men themselves can be scared of their own sex group.
Good for you to have this realization. I recently saw an interesting case here where a young man in his twenties had an orchiectomy and immediately regretted it and part of that was because without his testes his hormones had changed and the sex drive that had pushed him along the trans path disappeared and he no longer wanted to change. So, often when it's AGP you perhaps should just accept it for what it is and don't follow the promoted trans path because there's a Catch 22 waiting for you.
It will take time. If you are honest about your reasons for doing it people will probably try harder. Other trans may have a difficult time with it but it may open up some new conversations. Maybe some of them are questioning their choices? We never really know what struggles other people are having. Personally I wish the whole pronoun thing would go away and that is why I think that they/them is a fair choice for anyone who is unsure. A lot of people who struggle with the pronoun thing just learn to use people's names a lot