This story is from the comments by /u/keycoinandcandle that are listed below, summarised with AI.
User Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the comments provided, the account "keycoinandcandle" appears to be authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic. The user demonstrates deep, consistent, and passionate engagement with the topic over several years, sharing personal experiences and detailed, nuanced arguments that reflect a genuine perspective of a desister/detransitioner. The language is human, varied, and contextually appropriate, with no signs of automated posting or scripted responses.
About me
I'm a man in my mid-thirties who once believed my sensitive, feminine traits meant I was trans. My confusion was fueled by social pressure and a porn addiction that warped my view of womanhood. I realized my idea of being a woman was based on stereotypes, and that it was better to just be a feminine man. I'm now happily married with a daughter, completely at peace with my biological sex. My journey taught me that accepting my body, not changing it, was the key to my happiness.
My detransition story
My journey with gender started when I was young. I was a nerdy kid on the autism spectrum, and I always struggled to fit in with the other boys. They didn't want to play with me, so I ended up making friends almost exclusively with girls. I was quiet, reserved, in tune with my emotions, and a good communicator—traits that people often call "feminine." Because of this, people always thought I was gay. I carried myself in a feminine way, and that social conditioning made me think, for a while, that I might be trans. Thank god that didn't stick.
I got really into the goth scene, which had a lot of androgynous aspects to it. For a time, my goth era and my questioning era overlapped. I experimented with an androgynous version of my name and played with my appearance. I even passed as female when I wore dresses and makeup. But I was still miserable. I liked the attention I got from looking a certain way and having cool people flock to me, but it felt like being in a cult. You get company, but it's built on a performance.
A huge part of my confusion came from a porn addiction I developed when I was 17. I couldn't get a date, and I had unlimited internet access. Porn warps your brain—it conditions you to see women and femininity as inherently sexual. For a porn-addicted man, what could be more sexual than becoming the object of that sexualization? That’s what happened to me. It took me a long time to shake that addiction.
I eventually realized that my idea of womanhood was entirely based on stereotypes and a male gaze. I was reinforcing the very sexist idea that liking clothes and makeup is what makes you a woman. I thought about my butch lesbian friends who don't attach their womanhood to those things. It occurred to me that it would be so much easier—and more honest—to just expand what’s acceptable for men to look like and do than to make everyone accommodate my subjective interpretation of myself. I realized I was a man, and that being a sensitive, gentle, kind, and androgynous man is a perfectly valid way to be a man. People like David Bowie and Brian Molko showed me that.
I met my wife, and when we started dating, I was straightforward with her. I told her I used to think my feminine traits made me trans, but I realized I was just buying into stereotypes. She loved that I was comfortable wearing a woman's jacket and not thinking twice about it. We’re now married and have a baby daughter. Being a father has given me a new perspective on biology and womanhood.
I don’t regret exploring my identity, but I deeply regret ever thinking I could change my sex. I am biologically male. That’s a scientific fact. "Male" means an organism that produces sperm gametes. An adult human male is called a man. That’s me. "Female" means an organism that produces egg gametes. An adult human female is called a woman. That’s my wife. Everything else—masculine and feminine—is just social conditioning and stereotypes that change across cultures and time periods. Pink used to be a masculine color, for crying out loud.
Transitioning wouldn't have solved my problems. It would have been a performative lie. The high suicide rate in the trans community, I believe, is because people go too far into the performance and feel they can't back out. Detransitioning was my first step toward self-acceptance. It was embarrassing and lonely at first—people from that community shunned me—but it was necessary. I had to accept the body I’m in. I’m bald, hairy, and getting older. I can’t change that. I can work on what I can, like my weight, but otherwise, I have to accept that I look like a man in his mid-thirties, and that doesn’t determine my value.
My thoughts on gender are simple: sex is biological and immutable. Gender is a social construct. Denying biological sex just reinforces harmful stereotypes and stops us from expanding what men and women can be. I benefited from stepping away from affirming therapy and looking at the science. I also benefited from cutting out porn and focusing on real human connection.
I work in the mental health field now, and I see how politicized and broken the system is. Therapists are afraid to question someone’s trans identity for fear of being sued or called bigoted. It’s a mess. I see detransitioners every day who have been irreversibly harmed, and it breaks my heart.
I am at peace now. I am a man. I am feminine. And that’s okay.
Age | Event |
---|---|
17 | Developed a porn addiction that warped my view of women and femininity, leading to gender confusion. |
Young Adult (Goth Era) | Identified as trans for a period; experimented with an androgynous name and presentation; overlapped with my time in the goth scene. |
Young Adult | Realized my idea of womanhood was based on stereotypes and a male gaze; began to understand that being a feminine man is valid. |
Adult | Met my wife; was open with her about my past gender questioning. |
Adult | Stopped identifying as trans; embraced being a gender-nonconforming man. |
Mid-30s | Married; had a baby daughter. |
Now (Mid-30s) | Fully at peace with being a biological male who is feminine; working in mental health and advocating for a scientific understanding of sex and gender. |
Top Reddit Comments by /u/keycoinandcandle:
People with personality disorders tend to have manipulative tendencies as a symptom, as well as attention-seeking behaviors.
As such, identifying as trans tends to get you a lot of attention (people are always looking at you), sympathy, a community of enablers, and a victim/persecution complex by which one can imagine themselves as being exempt from the accountability of past transgressions.
First, stay out of the women's room, even if your f*g-hag friends try to drag you in. Tell them, "No, I'm male. Period." Women fought hard for sex-segregated spaces, and it's your duty as a gentleman to respect that, even upon invitation.
Second, if the men try to get you out of their bathroom, tell them, "No, I'm male. Period." The idea that you are getting forcibly kicked out of men's rooms is absolutely bonkers and smells like a lie; in those scenarios, you tell a manager. No one is so desperate to validate a guy's sense of gender that they wouldn't let a man choose to use the men's room.
The short answer I can give is this:
Trans-identifying women tend to transition as a result of internalized misogyny, or internalized homophobia. That can go away more easily with some self-reflection. Irriversible surgical steps are also more common with trans-identfying women.
Most trans-identifying men are motivated by sexual ideal, and pursuit of sexual interest is common for men in general. As long as he's getting sexual gratification out of it, he keeps it going with no foreseeable end. Note that moat trans-identifying men tend to only do hormones and maybe breast implants (reversible), and tend to be the ones championing the idea that a male who identifies as a women therefore has a "female" body. Hense the term girldique™️.
There are a lot of people who kermitted sewer-slide because, after irriversible surgeries, they felt lied to about trans ideology. Because they were.
In biology, living organisms that have the genotype to produce ova (egg) gametes (barring injury, genetic defect, or deterioration) are called "female" and those which have the genotype to produce spermatozoa (sperm) gametes (barring injury, genetic defect, or deterioration) are called "male."
In humans, the term for child and adolescent males is "boy," the term for adult males is "man," the term for child and adolescent females is "girl," and the term for adult females is "woman."
That's all the terms male/female, boy/girl, and man/woman mean.
In sociology, when a population is being studied, the behaviors that are observed to be more common amongst the males are given the label of "masculine," those more common amongst the females are known as "feminine," and those that are found equally are known as "unisex," and the outliers are known as "androgynous."
Part of our society's systemic sexism is the belief that what our society considers to be "masculine" and "feminine" is fixed/innate/unchangeable for males and females. The idea that a woman is inherantly predisposed to like dresses, wearing makeup, or being passive, for example.
This is where trans ideology comes into play. Trans ideology confuses "masculine" with "male" and "feminine" with "female." They believe that to be feminine is to be female and to be masculine is to be male.
Which is sexist and incorrect.
And before you go into the whole "sex is a spectrum" thing because of intersex people, know that intersex conditions are still divided into male intersex conditions and female intersex conditions because of gametes genotype. We know which is which. There is no third gamete. And intersex people hate being appropriated for trans rhetoric.
Plus, if being trans was an intersex condition, everyone claiming to be trans would be required to test for it, especially before surgery. But we don't. We tell a shrink we're trans, they have to use the affirmation-only model otherwise they can get fired, and then everything gets put in the hands of the trans-identifying person, who is operating under an empirically verifiable delusion. Like homeopaths and chiropractors, snakeoil surgeons will take your money, give you surgery, and tell you you're on your own if yoy have any difficulties.
If none of that gives you pause, then have fun yaaslighting people towards their doom, I guess.
In biology, living organisms that have the genotype to produce ova (egg) gametes (barring injury, genetic defect, or deterioration) are called "female" and those which have the genotype to produce spermazoid (sperm) gametes (barring injury, genetic defect, or deterioration) are called "male."
In humans, the term for child and adolescent males is "boy," the term for adult males is "man," the term for child and adolescent females is "girl," and the term for adult females is "woman."
In sociology, when a population is being studied, the behaviors that are observed to be more common amongst the males are given the label of "masculine," those more common amongst the females are known as "feminine," and those that are found equally are known as "unisex," and the outliers are known as "androgynous." However, because behaviors are the result of cultural and historical context, and have almost everything to do with social conditioning, what makes something "masculine" or "feminine" changes depending on the population being studied. For example, pink was originally called a "masculine" color because it used to be a color primarily worn by males, but now it is primarily worn by females, so it is labeled as "feminine." Following me so far?
Part of our society's systemic sexism is the belief that what our society considers to be "masculine" and "feminine" is fixed/innate/unchangeable for males and females. The idea that a woman is inherantly predisposed to like dresses, wearing makeup, or being passive, for example.
This is where trans ideology comes into play. Trans ideology confuses "masculine" with "male" and "feminine" with "female." They believe that to be feminine is to be female and to be masculine is to be male.
The whole trans movement is built upon this fundamental sexist misunderstanding, and is tangled in a series of rhetoric and mental gymnastics.
How do you cope with being a man? Knowing that being a male doesn't mean you have to conform to traditional male stereotypes. Bowie, my friend. Felix Yongbok Lee. Chris Corner. Tilo Wolff. Boy George. Klaha. Rozz Williams. Miyavi. The list goes on. Just because you're a man doesn't mean you can't be a feminine or androgynous one. We, as a society, we're so close to understanding that back in the day.
"Non-binary" implies that there's binary people, and non-binary people, which is a binary. Which means non-binary people are still binary. The term wasn't very well conceived and is reflective of the pseudointellecutal nature of the concept; it entirely disregards biological sex and enshrines the idea that stereotypes are what make you a boy/man or a girl/woman and that having qualities of both make you "neither." It ignores that absolutely everyone under the sun has qualities of both, because gender isn't real, and that the only actual difference between males and females is reproductive function potential, hormones, and sexual dymorphism, which is biological sex.
It's so much easier to just call yourself an androgynous male or female; you don't have to conform to gendered norms and you don't have to cause a fuss by tripping people up with funky pronouns.
But even then, being androgynous isn't something that is fashion alone; you either look naturally androgynous or you don't. For example, people like Miyavi, Brian Molko, and Tilo Wolff.
Many people who identify as nonbinary only dress androgynously (sometimes) and don't actually look androgynous; I can almost always tell if they are male or female. Sam Smith looks blatantly like a bloke, Asian Kate Dillon looks like a woman with a shaved head, and Emma D'Arcy looks like a woman with a bowl cut.
It's just so much easier not to create a whole gender identity out of your personality and fashion sense.
An organism that has the phenotype to produce ova (egg) gametes, barring injury, genetic defect, or deterioration, is scientifically known as a "female." In humans, child and adolescent females of the species are known as "girls" and adult females of the species are known as "women." That's literally all female/girl/woman means. They are biological terms. Everything else is either social conditionong, a stereotype, or a lie.
In sociology, when a population is being studied, one of the things that is noted is external behaviors, styles, and roles, that are more common in one sex or the other, or found equally in both. The label given to features found mostly in male demographics is called "masculine," the label given to features found mostly in female demographics is called "feminine," and thouse found in both is known as "unisex." What is considered masculine, feminine, and unisex depends entirely on the populatipn being studied and the era. For example, pink used to be worn primarily by men, and was therefore considered a masculine color.
Trans ideology has lots of logical issues a fallacies, but the main one is confusing female/girl/woman with being the same thing as "feminine." As such you'll note that a lot of trans-identifying people think they're trans because they believe that external behaviors/tastes are what make them male or female.
Let me know if you have any more questions.
r/actual_detrans is a detrans subreddit for those who can't cope with any critical analysis of gender ideology, which makes it less than helpful.
So basically, if you want to detransition, but stay nice and cozy within the trans scene uncritically, it's for you.
You are absolutely falling into the same trap.
You're young, probably single, still working out your identity, and your main frame of reference for women is probably porn, which you are projecting onto your lonely hoemonal teenage self. That, plus our sexist society that doesn't think men can be anything but macho and sporty, is probably warping your perception of reality. That's how a lot of young men develop autogynephilia. It's how it happened to me.
Cut the porn and remember that being an androgynous male is valid, and that you can't actually be a woman unless you have the capacity to produce ova gametes, barring injury or genetic defect.
In the biological repoductivr classification known as sex, living organisms with the phenotype to produce ova (egg) gametes, barring injury, genetic defect, or deterioration, are known as female. In humans, child and adolescent females are known as girl and adult females are known as women.
That's literally all female/girl/woman means. Anything else is a stereotype, a social construct, a lie, or a misunderstanding.