This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, this account appears to be authentic.
There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor. The comments demonstrate:
- Personal, detailed narrative: The user shares a specific, multi-year history with transition, detransition, mental health, and psychedelic therapy.
- Internal consistency: The story and views are coherent and consistent across multiple comments over several months.
- Complex and nuanced thought: The user acknowledges different perspectives (e.g., distinguishing transsex from transgender) and avoids simplistic, copy-pasted rhetoric. The language is analytical and self-reflective.
- Emotional resonance: The tone conveys genuine personal struggle, reflection, and a passion born of lived experience, not performative outrage.
This is a credible account of a desister/detransitioned individual.
About me
I'm a man who transitioned for a full decade because I thought my social struggles as a feminine man meant I was a woman. I spent nine years on hormones, but the effort to be seen as female became an exhausting performance that wore me down. Losing my job and starting antidepressants gave me the space and clarity to stop the act, and psychedelic therapy helped me see my transition was really about my autism and social anxiety. I now understand I was trying to solve a problem of self-acceptance with a medical solution, and I’ve stopped my transition to live as a man again. While I don't regret the journey, I've found true peace by addressing my mental health and learning to be comfortable in my own skin.
My detransition story
My entire journey started because I never felt like I fit in. I was a feminine man and I always felt like my presence was unwanted, like people saw me as different. It was easier to socialize with women, and because I was already gender non-conforming, I eventually explained all of these uncomfortable feelings as gender dysphoria. I now understand that these were actually autistic experiences. I was misinterpreting social situations and my own awkwardness. Gender wasn't the real problem.
I transitioned socially and then medically for a full decade, taking hormones for nine years. I passed well, but it became more and more exhausting to maintain that presentation as I got older. I felt like I constantly had to add more layers to be seen as a woman. Every little way I was seen as less-than, or not quite a "real" woman, really took its toll over time. It was an exhausting performance.
Getting laid off during COVID was a huge turning point. Suddenly, I didn't have to present myself in an office every day. I stopped doing all the things I thought I had to do to pass, and I realized, to my surprise, that I actually felt more at ease in social situations without all that pressure. Around the same time, I started an anti-depressant, which helped me break free from the harmful thought patterns I’d been stuck in for so long.
The biggest breakthrough, though, came from psychedelic therapy. I started taking psilocybin mushrooms a few times a year with the intent to meditate and work on my depression. It completely changed my perspective. It allowed me to honestly dig into my reasons for transitioning without the ideological lens I had been using. I saw the roots of my journey simply as they were: I had transitioned because I thought it would make me more comfortable socially and help me fit in. I realized the judgement I thought others had towards me for being a feminine man was my own insecurity. People don't hate me for being myself; they disliked me when I was trying to act like someone I wasn't.
I’ve come to believe that for many people, a transgender identity is a symptom of more deeply rooted issues, like autism, depression, anxiety, or low self-esteem. Medical transition can feel like a solution, but if the cause is poor mental health, it's only a temporary cure. The high eventually wears off. I'm convinced that true self-acceptance is the only solution without problems.
I don't regret my transition because it was a necessary part of my journey to get to where I am now, which is a place of much greater self-understanding. But I have permanently made my life more difficult in some ways, and I've had to learn to accept that. My thoughts on gender now are that it wasn't the issue for me; my struggle was with social connection and self-esteem. I see now that the people who seem most stable in their transition are those who did it due to severe body dysphoria about their sex, not their gender. For them, it's a medical event. For me, and I think for many others, it was a social one.
Age | Event |
---|---|
20 | Began my social transition. |
21 | Started hormone replacement therapy (HRT). |
30 | Lost my job due to COVID; stopped actively trying to present as female daily. Started antidepressants. |
30 | Began using psilocybin for meditation and therapy, which led me to question my transition. |
31 | After a decade of transition and 9 years on HRT, I fully stopped and began living as a man again. |
Top Comments by /u/kirraq:
After a decade of transition with 9 years on HRT, I've called it quits. I passed fine, but it got more difficult with age. I kept having to add more layers to pass. Doing just a little more never felt like a big deal at the time, but that's the sunk cost fallacy. Getting laid off because of covid and not having to work in an office every day, I suddenly stopped doing all those things and realized I was actually feeling more at ease in social situations. Starting an anti-depressant was when I finally started to break free from harmful thought patterns. Since then, psychedelic therapy has helped me truthfully dig into my reasons for transitioning, and like you, as a feminine man, I found I did it because I thought it would be more comfortable socially. The judgement I thought others had towards me for being a feminine man was my own insecurity. People don't hate me for being myself, but they did hate me for trying to act like someone else.
Being open about this with trans friends, I'm finding that those who medically transitioned to try to achieve social conformity are also the ones that are unstable in their identity and consider detransitioning. Those who transitioned due to severe body dysphoria are the ones who are most stable. They consider themselves trans-sex, not transgender, and see transition as a medical event, not an identity... gender was not the issue, it was their sex. (i.e. transmed)
I'm convinced that transgenderism in most people is a symptom of more deeply rooted issues. Please, be honest about your reasons for wanting to transition and work on those issues. Medical transition is only a temporary cure if the cause is poor mental health... the high will eventually wear off. The fact that you're here asking about detransitioning tells us a lot.
The most important thing I learned is to understand other perspectives. An action or belief that may be a negative for you could be helping someone else move in a positive direction. There's a lot I disagree with on trans ideology, especially medically, but I don't blame anyone who goes in trying to improve their life. I just hope that we can do better in helping people understand the root of their feelings. Self acceptance is the only solution without problems.
A huge part of living day to day as a woman is being recognized as one without condition, and that's a tall hurdle for trans women. Every little way you're seen as less-than really takes its toll over time. It's an exhausting presentation to keep up and will not be the same as the life of cis women.
I think it's just the opposite. They lack the social skills to comfortably exist in reality, so the energy is turned inwards, in pursuit of crafting an identity that others will praise them for. The echo of praise exists in these already introverted online communities, reinforcing and encouraging the behavior. It's easier to control your appearance online, where you can proofread and edit your words to perfection. They're too adept at going inward, to a fault of not connecting to others in reality. I was one of them.
More than any change in political leaning, I'm now able to recognize black-and-white thinking. I'm willing to understand a differing view and find middle ground. Politicians are using rigid stances as currency to gain voters. I'll support whoever I believe has a genuine goal to do the most good.
Your situation is really difficult, and I'm sorry that these are your options.
Psilocybin-induced meditation has been the most transformational thing I have ever done. After about 5 years of transitioning, I ended up in a situation (construction work) where it was more convenient to present masculine, and I started realizing that it didn't bother me anymore. It took another two years of questioning my transition and waves of intense depression to seek a more permanent solution than antidepressants. I took mushrooms with the intent to cure depression, which they did, but it also unintentionally broke me out of entrenched trans reasoning and lead me down a path of exploring what led up to transition. Seeing the roots of my journey simply as they were, rather than through an ideological lens, allowed me to recognize what I was trying to solve with transition. Trans ideology requires believing that your natural existence is wrong, which is no longer how I view the world.
I'm very happy to answer any specific questions you may have.
I use a 2 gram dose about 4 times a year. This is considered moderate, unlike a 4g+ "ego death" type of dose. It's enough to get meditative without totally losing touch... I can remember to take a deep breath if I need to return to reality.
Absolutely, and at times have felt hopeless over that distress. I've permanently made my life more difficult, and I've had to learn how to accept that.
No, my transition was mostly socially fueled. Prior to transition I came to be distressed by male aging, but that was preceded by and dependent on a belief of being trans.
I occasionally have thoughts that I previously would have called gender dysphoria, but now they're better explained by other framing.
Easy. Send me a message if you want the source I've used... I bought chocolate edibles and a grow kit, which took about a month to receive. I've also foraged some wild ones since then. FYI the spores are legal, so grow kits are very easy to get online.
There's a much higher incidence of ASD in the trans population... something like 20% reported. The studies thus far don't indicate whether one causes the other, or if other factors are involved that cause the two populations to overlap.
I haven't sought out a diagnosis, because it's not clear how it would be beneficial, but literature and AQ indicate I am. I always described my dysphoria as social, not physical. It was a feeling of never fitting in, and a sense that others perceived me as different. It felt like my presence was unwanted, even though logic should say that's not true because those same people are the ones inviting me. It was easier to socialize with women, and I was already gender non-conforming, so I explained my experiences as gender dysphoria. I later came to learn that those are better explained as autistic experiences. Transition doesn't cure autism, so when those feelings never resolved it forced me to question whether I was doing the right thing. Trying to understand social interactions through an autistic lens has given me more accurate context for when those awkward social situations occur. Gender isn't the problem; it's mostly my mis-interpretation of other people.
Trans identity requires affirmation to persist, because there's no verifiable scientific basis to confirm it's real. There's incentive for trans people to pull others into it in order to add legitimacy, and egg culture is a seemingly playful way to plant that seed. The ones doing it likely aren't thinking about it that way, but they can probably acknowledge the positive feeling they get by recognizing someone of their group (even if what they're seeing is misattributed). Claiming to be able to identify a trans person and affirming their existence solidifies their belief in trans identity.