This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or an inauthentic detransitioner/desister.
The user demonstrates:
- Personal, detailed experience with taking and stopping testosterone, including specific timelines and physical/emotional effects.
- Internal consistency in their story across multiple comments over time.
- Emotional depth that aligns with the expected passion and distress of someone grappling with detransition, including frustration, grief, and hope.
- Supportive engagement with others that is nuanced, personalized, and reflects a shared community experience.
About me
My journey started when I was 12 and I became really distressed by my female puberty, especially when my breasts developed. I later identified as trans for years, influenced by online communities and a confusion between my identity and not fitting feminine stereotypes. At 18, I tried testosterone but stopped after three months because the rapid, permanent voice drop was terrifying and made me realize it wasn't right for me. I've learned that I can be a masculine person without changing my body or identifying as male. Now, I'm accepting being female while defining what that means for myself, and I'm focusing on healing from the effects of my short medical transition.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender has been confusing, but I think I’m finally starting to understand myself. It all started when I was around 12. I hated going through female puberty. I remember my chest starting to hurt and I thought I had an infection, but it was just my breasts developing. I was really distressed by the changes. I couldn't even lay on my stomach comfortably anymore, and I’ve never been a big fan of my breasts because of that.
For about six years, my whole life revolved around being trans. I think a lot of my feelings were tied up in not wanting to fit into a feminine stereotype. I felt like I couldn't be taken seriously as a woman. I started identifying as non-binary first, and then later as a trans man. I was influenced a lot by what I saw online and by my friends who were also transitioning. It’s hard to separate what I actually felt from what I felt pressured to feel. Looking back, I think I had a hard time distinguishing between being attracted to men and wanting to be a man. It was like my aesthetic attraction and my own identity got mixed up.
When I was 18, I decided to start testosterone. I was only on T for a total of three months, with a break in the middle. The effects on me were really fast and intense. My voice dropped a whole octave in just the first month. It was terrifying. I was in my college choir at the time, and suddenly I couldn't sing the songs I’d been practicing. Mornings became scary because my voice would be even deeper when I woke up. It felt so unfair because I had friends who had been on T for years and their voices were higher than mine. I became really impatient and impulsive, wanting to fix it immediately.
I realized pretty quickly that medical transition wasn’t the right path for me. I stopped the testosterone because I understood that I didn't need to change my body to be myself. I realized that I was perfectly content just dressing and acting masculine. I didn't need to be a man to do that. What was most important was feeling comfortable with myself, body and identity. I learned that being female doesn’t define anything beyond what I decide for myself. My lived experiences and perspective as a female are still there, and nobody can take that away.
Since stopping T, I’ve been medically detransitioning. I’m not taking any hormones now. My body has been readjusting. My voice has lightened up a bit; I got my falsetto range back, though it's not very strong for singing yet. My aunt told me she didn't see much difference in my speaking voice except that I sounded a little under the weather, which was reassuring. I still bind my chest most days because I feel uncomfortable with other people seeing my female anatomy, but I’m trying to be more neutral about my body. I see both my male and female experiences as parts of me now.
I don’t regret exploring transition because it helped me learn these things about myself, but I do regret the permanent change to my voice. If I could go back, I would have explored these feelings in therapy instead of rushing into medical steps. I’ve benefited hugely from the support of my parents, my partner, and my friends. My partner sees me for who I am and loves me, and that means everything. I’m trying to see my voice change as a challenge that will push me to become a better singer than I was before.
I don’t think there’s one way to be. You can act and dress however you want. The goal is to be true to yourself, not to fit into a box. For me, that means accepting that I am female, but that my expression doesn’t have to be traditionally feminine. I’m just me.
Here is a timeline of my journey:
Age | Event |
---|---|
10 | Female puberty began, experienced distress from breast development. |
12 - 18 | Identified as trans (non-binary, then as a trans man). Felt my life revolved around this identity. |
18 | Started testosterone (T). |
18 | Stopped T after 1 month due to rapid voice drop (an octave lower), then restarted. |
18 | Stopped T permanently after a total of 3 months (on-and-off) and began medical detransition. |
18 | (2 months off T) Noted some voice resonance recovery, falsetto range returned but weak. |
Top Comments by /u/machineboys:
It’s not as much “living as a woman” as it is being comfortable with being female. You can act, dress, be however you want. What’s most important is feeling comfortable with your self, body, and identity. Hormones or not, you are you. Just be sure to not dislike who you are. No need to fit yourself into a box.
Thank you so much… This has genuinely helped me. It’s only been a month for me, after all, so maybe I do just need to give it time. Did your register go back up, or did the timbre of your voice just change to that of a more feminine sound, if you don’t mind me asking? Again, thank you for the reassurance! I don’t feel so alone anymore.
Thank you… I’m going to Australia on Wednesday to visit my partner for 3 months, and they said they’d support me and do most of the talking for me and just give me a safe, quiet place to heal and be loved. My parents said that once I get back, if my voice hasn’t changed still, they’ll look into ways to fix it. I’ve just always been an impatient and impulsive person.. I hope I can get through this. I hope my voice goes back. Most people who have been on T for years don’t have as deep of a voice as me, and my voice dropped an octave in a MONTH. It’s crazy.. I don’t know why it happened to me. It doesn’t feel fair.
This is…. incredibly inspiring, actually. When your voice returned the first time, did your low register go away? Like, did you lose the ability to hit the same low notes? And did your register get higher, even if not as high as it was pre-T? I’m just wondering if I’ll see pitch changes as well as timbre changed, this is the #1 thing I’m thinking about. But, seriously, this really does give me hope. If you have any more info about what’s happened to your voice, I’d really appreciate it!
I still have the same problem. What I’ve done is I’ve stopped medically transitioning, but try to remain as gender neutral in my presentation as I can. Since how I feel depends on the day, I have the versatility to adapt to either identity. They’re both a part of me, after all. I still bind most days, but that’s just because I feel uncomfortable with other people seeing my female anatomy. Just try to take a neutral stance on it and adapt to whatever you feel in the moment, without the need of medical transition to achieve it.
It’s not that I was like.. super offended by the screenshot or anything. I was mostly just shocked with this massive influx of people then going into my DMs and such (all mostly supportive, at least.) I’m glad that the post got taken down, and I’m even more grateful towards the mod here that reached out and requested for it to be taken down, but my shock mostly just came from an already-bad mood.
Don’t see it as admitting you were wrong, but being your honest self. When you asked the people you know to call you by your new pronouns, that was you being honest. And so is you changing your mind about some aspects about yourself. Both you and the people around you will be happier if you are true to yourself.
Some thoughts from someone who had the exact same experience: once you transition and are perceived as male, society will start to treat you differently. Men are socialized differently, and their social groups can often be much more distant. People in general will treat you much more distantly, and it might be harder to befriend women. I found that I would always get weird looks when shopping for cute things. I realized that I was perfectly content just dressing and acting masculine. I’d recommend reading into the social effects of transitioning, and if you decide you’re perfectly okay with that, then go for it, but just be sure to consider everything.
Despite everything, you are still the same person that you were pre-transition. Your lived experiences and perspective as a female are still there. That’s something that nobody can take away from you. You are absolutely lovable and you can still go back. The longer you are off T, the more your body will readjust. Human bodies are incredibly malleable things. There are plenty of ways you can begin your detransition without money. Online voice training videos can be a huge help, and coming out to friends can offer you a larger support network. Later down the line when you do have more money, voice demonization surgery and laser hair removal are definitely options. If you’re referring to your face when you mention plastic surgery, I’d say not to as your fat redistribution will eventually return to female levels. Above all, there is an entire community here that has been through the same hardships you have. You are and will always be lovable for the person you are.
This has made me feel so, so, SO reassured… God, this is EXACTLY what I needed to hear. So your lowest notes were gone after you stopped T, or just not in your natural resting register? Either way, if your voice was able to return to female range, I hope mine can, too. I naturally spoke around “middle C” pre-T, and now I speak at the F below middle C. I’m the same way where I can sing high notes again but I can’t do it loudly or else my voice cracks back down. I can sing an octave above middle C, and up to the F above that. Pre-T, I was able to go to the A above that. (God.. I forgot if middle C was C3 or C4, otherwise I’d be referring to them as that.) This has definitely inspired me to wait a little bit before jumping immediately to surgery, though. I can’t thand you enough!
P.S. I was 18 when I started T 4 months ago before stopping a month ago. Well.. am. I still am 18.