This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.
The comments display a consistent, nuanced, and deeply personal perspective over a two-year period. The user shares specific, complex life experiences (e.g., attending autism support groups, parental conflicts, exploring "supra-binary" identity) and expresses emotions like anger, confusion, and relief that align with the stated passion and pain of the detrans/desister experience. The writing style is conversational, self-reflective, and shows internal contradiction, which is more indicative of a genuine person working through complex issues than a scripted narrative.
About me
I was born male but never fit the rigid stereotypes of what a man should be, which made me think I might be trans. I explored that identity online but found it came with its own set of restrictive rules I had to follow. I realized my discomfort wasn't with being male, but with the pressure to conform to any label at all. I never medically transitioned and instead worked on accepting myself as a man who is simply a mix of masculine and feminine traits. Now, I embrace my "bothness" and am learning that it's okay to just be a fluid, messy me.
My detransition story
My journey with gender started a long time ago, not because I felt like I was born in the wrong body, but because I never felt like I fit into the narrow boxes everyone said I had to. I was born male, but I never felt like a "real man" according to the rules I grew up with. My mom would scream at me to "stop crying or I'll give you something to cry about" because boys weren't supposed to cry. That kind of thing sticks with you.
For a while, I thought the problem was me. I got diagnosed with autism, which they called Asperger's syndrome back then, and I heard that having autism could be a sign you're trans. I went to an autism support group for adults, but it was full of activists and people who self-diagnosed, which made me really suspicious. One person said they were obsessive-compulsive because they liked a clean bedroom, and I tried to explain that's not what OCD is. It felt like people were just grabbing onto identities to make their lives more interesting.
I started exploring the idea that I might be trans or non-binary because it seemed like a way to explain why I felt so different. I liked things that weren't considered "manly." I took home-ec in middle school because I wanted to and to be near a girl I liked, and all the other boys thought I was stupid for it. I play female characters in video games. My voice is naturally higher, and I can make it sound female if I want to. I felt pressured to pick a label, any label, just to have an answer.
But the more I looked into it, the more I saw that the trans movement had its own set of narrow boxes you had to fit into. It wasn't about freedom; it was about trading one set of rules for another. I realized I wasn't "gender fluid"; I was "me fluid." The whole concept of "you" is fluid. Who I am changes over time, and that's okay. Some things about me are constant, and others change a lot.
I never took hormones or had any surgeries. For me, it was a social and ideological exploration that I eventually walked back from. I came to understand that my discomfort wasn't with being male, but with what everyone told me a male had to be. I had a lot of low self-esteem and anxiety, and for a while, I thought transitioning was the solution. But I benefited from stepping back and working on self-acceptance instead. It's a messy, hard process. I don't live on an "ocean of self-acceptance," but I have moments where I feel okay about being a mess. And it's okay to be a mess.
I think a lot of my struggle was also related to internalized ideas about sexuality. There's a lot of pressure, and I wonder if some people use transitioning as a way to escape dealing with being gay. If you're a guy who likes guys, but you transition to a woman, then suddenly you're straight, right? It can be a way to avoid homophobia.
I don't regret exploring my gender because it helped me figure all this out, but I deeply regret how much time and energy I spent thinking I was the problem that needed to be fixed. The real problem was the pressure to conform to any rigid ideal. Now, I just try to be myself, a mix of masculine and feminine traits. I tell people to embrace their "bothness." You don't have to choose.
The most frustrating part has been the reaction from others. I've been called hateful and a transphobe just because my path didn't lead me to transition. I've faced abuse online for questioning things. It seems like you can't even exist without choosing a side, and that's exactly what I wanted to get away from.
Here is a timeline of my journey based on my experiences:
Age | Event |
---|---|
~12-13 | Felt strong discomfort with puberty and male gender roles. Took home-ec class against social norms. |
Early 20s | Diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder (Asperger's). |
Mid-Late 20s | Explored trans and non-binary identities online and in communities. |
Late 20s | Attended adult autism support group; became disillusioned with identity-focused activism. |
Late 20s / Early 30s | Realized the concept of a fixed "self" was flawed; embraced the idea of a fluid "me." |
Early 30s | Stopped identifying as trans/non-binary; began working on self-acceptance as a male who doesn't conform to stereotypes. |
Present (30s) | Continue to navigate life embracing both masculine and feminine traits without a label. |
Top Comments by /u/mattumanu:
There were signs they were becoming delusional from the get-go. In the early days of the modern trans movement there were people questioning if it could continue to coexist with the rest of LGBT. The contradiction that first appeared was the problem of being "born this way", where someone is innately gay rather than it being a learned behavior. I think it all started when Marxism infected the movement and inserted the "social construct" idea into the mix. That would mean that even being gay, lesbian or bi would also be a social construct.
So I'll just jump to the end: wouldn't that mean that the religious fundamentalists were right all along? Being gay, lesbian, bi, or trans are all social constructs, learned behaviors, and therefore "lifestyles"? And doesn't that also mean that you are allowed to criticize the "lifestyles" that are inherently unproductive, in other words, produce no children?
We were much better off when each of these letters in the LGBT movement were considered subcultures with their own unique characteristics. Each one was internally consistent and content to be separate subcultures. Now it's melting into a glob of crazy shit that no one can make sense of.
They can test for all kinds of conditions, including brain diseases, tumors, chemical imbalances, electrolytes, do encephalograms, echo-cardiograms, MRIs, Cat scans, CT scans, Pet scans, examine everything from saliva to feces to urine, detect heart valve defects, aortic aneurysms, ulcers, internal bleeding, gastrointestinal malformations, lung abnormalities... but not whether you're trans or not, which is pretty convenient, don't you think?
I don't know what your life is like right now, but I think I can safely say that you did it because the people around you insisted it was a good idea. There might be reason why they thought it was a good idea, but I don't know what that might have been.
In the meantime, you've probably got a lot of confused feelings, but if you can, please don't go through it alone.
I'm not saying this towards anyone in this subreddit, and it's something I say all the time.
"These are little kids or teens. You're the grownups. What do the kids know about anything other than what you tell them? Why are you blaming your kids for the things that have gone wrong?"
The answer to that is they want to deflect responsibility off themselves onto anyone else. Anyone else. Parents do it all the time when their kids don't turn out like they wanted. In their minds they can't be wrong because that means they are responsible.
By the way, I had to learn to say that to my mother. "I was the kid mom. You were the grown up. How all this turned out is your fault. Stop trying to blame me because I wont accept that anymore."
This has always sounded to me like the "no true Scotsman fallacy". It works like this. "No Scotsman hangs out with a Londoner!" Then someone says, "my uncle Angus is a Scotsman and he hangs out with Londoners." Then the Scotsman says, "No TRUE Scotsman hangs out with Londoners".
It's also moving the goalpost. It's a way of cheating. Like when they say you can't just be Gay, you have to have the correct political stance in order to be Gay.
"No Gay person would vote republican".
"Dave Rubin is Gay, and he votes republican".
"No TRUE Gay person would vote Republican".
Some asshole asked me if I identify as a girl So I spiraled
That's the reason all of this is so dangerous. Making people question the fundamental reality of who they are is so hurtful it's mind boggling. "Do you identify as..." Why even ask? It keeps people off balance and tears their sense of self all apart.
You look fine and I can't understand why someone would think you weren't a girl.
Back after I was diagnosed with "autism spectrum disorder otherwise not specified", which was long for Asperger's syndrome, I found out that if you attend an "Adults with Autism" group, you find it loaded with "self-diagnosed" and activists. You could even find self-identifying trans people at those meetings. I got into it with people about this self-diagnosing situation because I believe that it robs real people with real problems of resources.
Imagine there's a finite amount of a cancer cure, but for someone reason people who don't have cancer want to take the cure, using a lot of it up and leaving real cancer patients with nothing. What's going on right is some of the most selfish shit I could ever hope to see, and it's not showing any signs of getting better.
And they say we're the hateful ones.
I took a break from this as well, only to find when I come back it's way worse than it was before. I'm the transphobe because I want to live my life the best way I know how? I'm the bad guy because it didn't work out for me? WTAF?
Abusive people are generally abusing everyone they meet. I'm sure the guy has more problems than just he's transphobic, especially if he left without demanding his money back.
I work close with people who have behavioral health problems. That's quite a group of people who don't know how to get along with other people, even if you were to threaten them with bodily harm. I have a coworker whose dad fits the description of the guy you talked about, and his dad, at one point, even tried to run him over with a car.
I try to remember that after someone has treated me like shit, they not only have a trail of people they've already mistreated behind them but will mistreat more people today until something makes them stop.
I know, right?
You can't even be a disister without encountering abuse. I'm on my second Reddit account here, basically on my second life. I used to be in those communities, and as long as you agreed with the group you were fine. Question the group mentality, and all bets are off.
To be honest, these days you find this in a lot of circles. One example I could use is talking with anti-science types. If I point out that they are using a science-based device to claim that science is fake, they deliver abuse. This attitude is across the board in domains that you wouldn't expect it to be. It's in sports, in gaming (board games and video)... it's in quilting, for crying out loud! The day I saw that quilters were having arguments and abuse was being dished out... IN THE QUILTING 'COMMUNITY'... I thought, what the actual hell? Are they actually telling me that people who create colorful and artful bed coverings are actually attacking each other over quilting beliefs?
It's doubly worse in the hottest hot-button topics because the stakes are so high. When you base your core identity on something where social, material, and monetary domains are all stacked on top of each other: where your friendships, your body, and money are all at risk at the same time, it gets hyper-dicey. Still not an excuse to abuse people.