genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/merinaspic's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 16 -> Detransitioned: 20
female
porn problem
hated breasts
regrets transitioning
influenced online
body dysmorphia
homosexual
puberty discomfort
started as non-binary
only transitioned socially
benefited from psychedelic drugs
eating disorder
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears to be authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.

The user's comments are highly detailed, emotionally nuanced, and show a consistent, deeply personal narrative of their experience with dysphoria, transition, detransition, and feminist analysis. The advice is specific, varied, and includes personal anecdotes (like climbing and psychedelics) that are not typical of a scripted bot. The user also demonstrates the expected passion and complex perspective of a desister/detransitioner who is critical of both trans activism and right-wing ideology.

About me

I started feeling a deep discomfort with my female body when I was 15, which led me to identify as trans and then non-binary. I socially transitioned, but it trapped me in a new way by making me avoid anything feminine to prove I wasn't faking. My journey made me realize that transitioning was reinforcing the very stereotypes I wanted to challenge as a masculine woman. I detransitioned to reject labels entirely and now I just live my life, doing what I want without worrying if it's for boys or girls. I found peace through activities like rock climbing and finally feel comfortable just being myself.

My detransition story

My journey with gender started around the time I was 15. Puberty hit me hard, and I went from being a happy, gender-free kid to feeling completely alienated from my rapidly changing body. I hated my breasts and felt a deep discomfort with being seen as a woman. This feeling was my dysphoria, and it was very real.

I spent a lot of time online, on places like Tumblr and YouTube, immersed in trans communities. I now believe this kept my dysphoria at the forefront of my mind, constantly feeding it. I started to identify as trans, and then later as non-binary, because the idea of "identifying as a woman" made no sense to me. I wasn't feminine, I was uncomfortable in my body, and I felt no connection to what society said womanhood was. I concluded that I must not be a woman.

This thinking started a vicious cycle. Believing I was trans made me resent my female body even more because it could "give me away." This heightened my physical dysphoria, which got tangled up with an eating disorder, body dysmorphia, and an addiction to exercise. It also created a social dysphoria I never had before; I became hyper-aware of how people perceived me and hated being seen as female.

I socially transitioned. In some ways, it was liberating. It gave me the confidence to do things society labels "masculine" and to feel I had a right to do them. But the cost was high. I became trapped in a new way. I was so terrified of being seen as "faking" that I avoided anything remotely "girly," even if I might have enjoyed it. The thought made my skin crawl. I was still a prisoner to stereotypes, just from the other side.

I started to realize that transitioning was perhaps the worst thing a gender-nonconforming person could do if they truly wanted to challenge stereotypes. I felt like I, as a lesbian, had two choices: I could be visibly gender-nonconforming and unapologetically female, owning my choices, or I could use a trans identity to explain my non-conformity, effectively saying, "I'm allowed to be masculine because I'm actually a man." I came to see the second option as reinforcing the very sexist idea that masculinity belongs to men. My biggest motivation for detransitioning was the realization that I could serve my feminist principles better by owning my sex and rejecting the roles forced upon it.

Detransitioning for me was about moving past identity politics altogether. I stopped announcing who I was to the world and just started living. The best thing to come out of this whole journey is that I now barely think about whether something is for boys or girls. I just do what I want. I have the confidence to do "masculine" things and the freedom to enjoy "feminine" things without my sense of self being threatened.

I never took hormones or had any surgeries, so I don't have physical health complications or infertility to deal with. My struggles were primarily psychological and social. To cope, I found activities that made me feel at home in my body. Rock climbing was a lifesaver; it made me feel powerful and capable. Yoga and meditation taught me to be calm and present. I also benefited greatly from psychedelic drugs, which helped me process my traumatic experiences with transition and make peace with my body in a way I hadn't before. It helped me see things in a new, less constrained way.

I also had to address my relationship with porn. I realized it was skewing my view of gender and sex and damaging my body image. Giving it up and cultivating a healthy, porn-free relationship with my own body was incredibly important.

Looking back, I don't regret transitioning. It was a necessary part of my journey to get to where I am now. It gave me the confidence I needed, and detransitioning gave me true freedom. I regret the time I spent in that self-destructive, self-obsessed cycle of dysphoria, and I regret the pain I caused my family when I came out, but I don't regret the path itself because it made me who I am today—someone who is finally comfortable just being me.

Age Event
15 Intense dysphoria began with puberty. Hated my developing breasts and female body.
16-17 Immersed in online trans communities, identified first as trans, then as non-binary.
18 Socially transitioned. Felt liberated to express masculinity but became trapped avoiding femininity.
19 Began to question my transition, realizing it reinforced gender stereotypes I wanted to reject.
20 Detransitioned. Stopped identifying with any label and focused on activities like climbing and yoga to feel at home in my body.
21 Used psychedelics as a tool to help process my experiences and found greater peace with my body.

Top Comments by /u/merinaspic:

14 comments • Posting since June 19, 2020
Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) explains how to cope with regret after top surgery by finding activities that make you feel at home in your body, suggesting climbing, running, yoga, meditation, and body painting.
41 pointsJun 24, 2020
View on Reddit

Find activities which make you feel at home in your body. Focussing on your chest itself probably won’t help, so try to find ways to feel comfortable in your body, and as you get used to that over time it will become easier to accept your body in its new form. Some suggestions: Sports which involve your whole body (climbing is amazing, running might work for you, just see what you like. An added bonus with climbing is that, in my experience, being (nearly) flat chested makes the whole thing a lot easier) Yoga and meditation Body painting (literally just get some paints and paint beautiful colours and patterns onto your skin) Maybe psychedelics - might not be your thing, but they definitely are mine I’ll edit if I can think of any more! All the best my friend, peace XX

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) explains why she feels politically homeless, finding mainstream trans activism harmful to women and GNC people but rejecting the right wing's harassment of LGBTQ+ individuals.
30 pointsJun 30, 2020
View on Reddit

I hear you and I feel this. You're not alone. I've come to believe that the ideology surrounding gender which most trans activist groups hold is really harmful to girls, women, and particularly gender non-conforming people, so I can't feel at home there. Equally, I don't want to be associated with the right wing, who harass gay, gnc and trans people for failing to conform. There isn't a good middle ground, but I really hope this sub survives because it's one of the few places I've found people who understand.

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) advises that coming out as detrans on social media isn't obligatory and suggests moving past identity politics by keeping one's journey personal.
18 pointsAug 26, 2020
View on Reddit

Are you sure you want to come out as detrans? You don't have to make an announcement, and if you do want to make an announcement you needn't do it via social media, unless you want to. For me, detransition is about moving past identity politics, and part of that involved moving past the need to announce to the world all of the feelings which I had about my body/my feminism/my sex/my gender. I feel a lot more comfortable just doing me without bringing the rest of the world in on it, unless it's on a person-by-person basis. You might not feel the same as me - I'm just commenting to let you know you don't *have* to come out on social media! All the best pal xx

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) advises questioning individuals to focus on the practical consequences of transitioning rather than an abstract identity.
11 pointsJan 27, 2023
View on Reddit

The q ‘am I rlly trans?’ is probably less helpful than ‘do I rlly wanna transition?’ - like, taking a good long look at the realistic consequences of transitioning, is that the way you want your life to go? Maybe you do sincerely want them, and you’re happy to take the risk that you might be wrong and regret it because you think that you could ‘win big’ if you’re correctly assessing what you want; maybe you’re not sure after all, or you’re not sure the potentially bad consequences are ‘worth the risk’, in which case… don’t do it. It’s straightforward tbh. Hang around with trans people, and if possible with detrans people or at least gnc people, first. Imagine yourself in their shoes. Take some time to sort your sexuality out before you try to make big decisions about reconfiguring ur sex/gender. Idk, just take your time, and if you do wanna transition all the best, but otherwise.. that’s ok too

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) explains how transitioning and then detransitioning freed her from gender stereotypes, allowing her to enjoy both 'masculine' and 'feminine' activities without her identity feeling threatened.
9 pointsAug 26, 2020
View on Reddit

Yes! I relate to this so strongly. When I IDd as trans, I would actively avoid doing things that I would probably have enjoyed, effectively just for the sake of keeping up appearances. I hated the idea of coming across as if I was faking being trans (I had so much insecurity about my gender presentation oh my goodness), to the point where it didn’t even matter if I was with other people or by myself - if something was typed ‘girly’, I felt horrified by the idea of being associated with it, in case it undermined my whole gender facade. Transitioning was a good experience for me in some ways, because it liberated me to do things which were typed ‘masculine’, and to feel like I had a right to do them, but the cost was that I felt unable to do ‘girly’ things - the thought made my skin crawl. Since detransitioning, I have maintained the confidence I developed doing things which might be considered gender non-conforming, but I’ve regained my ability to relax and genuinely enjoy things that are more aligned with stereotypes for my sex. I thought that, when I IDd as trans, I had freed myself from gender stereotypes because I was doing all the things that women weren’t meant to do. In retrospect, I can see that I was still trapped by those stereotypes, because I saw so many of the things that women were meant to do as ‘off-limits’ for me. Now that I’ve abandoned gender identity and gender politics, I barely even think about whether something is ‘girly’ or ‘boyish’ or whatever - I just do it if I want to. The result is that I sometimes enjoy feminine things, and I often enjoy ‘masculine’ things, and whatever I’m doing my sense of self/identity isn’t bothered. Honestly it’s one of the best things about having transitioned and detransitioned.

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) discusses when transition might be the right choice, arguing it can relieve dysphoria and make life easier for GNC people in a sexist world, but believes self-acceptance leads to greater fulfillment for most.
8 pointsDec 11, 2020
View on Reddit

Sometimes transition is going to relieve dysphoria, and make a gender non-conforming person’s experience in our highly sexist and homophobic world easier, in a way that can’t be paralleled by doing the difficult work of self-acceptance, to the extent that they can’t be happy without it. For those people, go ahead and transition. I believe pretty strongly that most people will live more fulfilled lives, with a greater degree of self-acceptance and comfort in their own bodies, if they are able to stand up against the pressures towards gender conformity, and learn to love themselves with the bodies and minds that they already have, rather than editing those bodies because of a problem which is ultimately psychosocial and not physical - but I know that that isn’t going to work for everyone. I have no real interest in denying people the chance to transition, once they’ve had a decent shot at learning to be comfortable with who they are without transition. It’s a cruel world for gnc people, especially butch women. Sometimes it’s just easier to live stealth as a trans guy. Who am I to stop you?

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) discusses using psychedelics to process transition and detransition trauma.
8 pointsJun 24, 2020
View on Reddit

Don't pressure yourself, but yeah if you can find exercise that feels good I hope that helps! Re. psychedelics, I've only got experience with acid but I think shrooms are quite similar. I think they help me process things - my experience of transition, and to a lesser extent detransition, was unsurprisingly kinda traumatic, and reflecting on it with the help of psychedelics has helped me make peace with it in a way that I don't think I really had before. That being said, psychedelics aren't 'inherently' wonder-molecules - it depends hugely on how you use them (and tbh I have a lot to learn there too). Have a look online to see what you can find out! I realise there's a legality issue, though, so don't do anything you aren't comfortable with. (Besides being really helpful for thinking about things in a new and less constrained way, I also think psychedelics can be a lot of fun!) I have no idea if you'd be interested in this, but my fave bit of research into psychedelics is Hewitt's paper on Psychedelic Feminism (it's not actually about the science, but it's got some really interesting comments on how psychedelics can be used). I'm not sure if any of this is your thing, though, so feel free to take it or leave it!

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) explains how to alleviate gender dysphoria, advising a 15-year-old to leave trans-focused online spaces, find empowering physical activities like climbing, practice yoga/meditation, seek non-affirming therapy to find root causes, read women's history, and emphasizes that time and self-acceptance are key healers.
7 pointsJun 20, 2020
View on Reddit

Read in the comments that you’re 15 - that’s about when my dysphoria was at its worst. The answer is emphatically yes, it will get better. Here are some things that helped me, and some things to avoid.

If you’re on trans tumblr, Twitter, YouTube or anything else similar, leave. When you’re immersed in conversations about gender and dysphoria, it’s going to be at the forefront of your mind. Even if you don’t realise it, you’re effectively going looking for these feelings, even if it feels good at the time.

Find a sport or outdoor activity which makes you feel powerful in your body, and which makes you feel able. In my experience, things like running or going to the gym have never been particularly helpful, but I fell in love with climbing and bouldering. Nothing has helped me feel at home in my body like that did.

It might feel clunky and awkward to begin with, and you might feel self conscious about it, but yoga and meditation can work wonders. Yoga teaches you to move your body in ways which feel right, and meditation asks you to sit with your thoughts and cultivate a calm and empty mind. I can’t recommend highly enough.

Assuming you’re female: if you can, it might help to try to surround yourself with independent and inspiring women who are not involved in trans politics. Being in same-sex spaces is liberating and might help you understand on a deeper level that there is space for a whole range people in the category of ‘womanhood’, including gender non conforming people, and people who feel like you do.

Read women’s history (again, assuming you’re a woman). This is a great time to be alive, but our culture is deeply misogynistic and increasingly porn-sick. There have been other ways to be a woman throughout history besides the ways which we are encouraged to perform womanhood today. I’m not sure if you’re gay/attracted to women, but if you are then I recommend reading Stone Butch Blues. It changed my life, and showed me that there have always been dysphoric women and butch women, and that while it might not be easy it doesn’t detract from your womanhood.

If you have the option, see if you can find a counsellor or therapist. You will have to be explicit with them and explain that you want to work through your dysphoria and find it’s root causes, because if you aren’t clear about this you run the risk of someone just ‘affirming’ you and pushing you into a transition which may not be right for you, but if you can find a professional to talk through these things with that could be fantastic.

Finally, time is a great healer. Puberty completely screwed my mental health and body image up, because I went from being a happily gender free child to having a body changing faster than I could keep up with. Over time, I learned to live in my body and to accept it as it is. You can do this too, when you find the strength in yourself to stop fighting it and grow.

I’ll add to this if I think of anything more, but for now, you can do this, friend. If you want to message me, go ahead. Peace xx

Edit: additions! Here we go:

I’ve realised you’re amab now, so some of the above advice may not be relevant, but I have a new piece of advice - I would recommend that, if you are watching porn at all now, you try to give it up. It may not be easy, but it really skews the whole way we see gender (as well as sex), and will probably be doing damage to your body image too. See if it helps, although even if it doesn’t I’d recommend going porn free because the industry is systematically exploitative.

I’d also suggest that you cultivate a healthy and porn-free masturbation habit. It might not work for you, but for me taking the time to work out what makes my body feel good (by myself, not with a partner!) did amazing things for my sense of being at home in my body. It might feel weird and awkward at first, if you’re used to wanking to porn or to never wanking at all, but I think it’s worth it.

One of the things that helped me feel more at home in my body is body painting - literally just painting in bright colours patterns all over my skin. It might help you?!

Generally working on your mental health is a good idea, but one of the things that might be a particularly easy fix is paying attention to what music you listen to. If you listen to angry or angsty music, I understand that it’s cathartic but try switching it up for something upbeat or happy. It might change your mood, and thereby a lot of the thoughts and feelings you have about your body.

If you’re 15, your brain is too underdeveloped for this, but to anyone else who might be reading: psychedelics have been incredible for my body image and my sense of being at ease in my body. I can’t tell you how much I recommend them.

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) discusses the therapeutic potential and proper use of psychedelics, citing current research and clarifying common misconceptions about hallucinations.
7 pointsJun 24, 2020
View on Reddit

Re. this, you’re right- thanks for mentioning it. I’m probably a bit too quick to recommend something just because it’s been good for me personally. I am mostly with you on this - drugs shouldn’t become a way to hide from your trauma, and shouldn’t become habitual. I think psychedelics should actually be viewed quite differently to many other drugs, because they modify your consciousness and brain activity in completely different ways - it’s worth looking at the research that is happening in this, esp. the current Imperial College research into using MD (I think) to treat PTSD and other conditions, and research from the 60s and 70s before psychedelics were banned as a part of counterculture repression. I’m not suggesting that you should conduct research on yourself or try to be your own doctor, but it’s good to know these things for context and can help you use them in a way which is productive. Thank you for adding this though - psychedelics are at most a complement to other healing, and should be used sensibly! Used in a good way, they definitely don’t need to become a new coping mechanism. Re. the hallucinations stuff, there’re a lot of misconceptions out there around this (e.g. psychedelics don’t actually make you see things which aren’t there - they just add movement, pattern and flow to the things which are there).

Reddit user merinaspic (detrans female) explains her journey from physical dysphoria to social dysphoria, detailing how transitioning trapped her in a cycle of enforcing gender stereotypes and how detransitioning allowed her to reclaim her identity as a gender non-conforming woman.
7 pointsAug 26, 2020
View on Reddit

Hello! I can't help you with the trauma side of things, but here's my best attempt at helping you with the stereotypes/social dysphoria/physical dysphoria side of things.

My physical dysphoria predated my social dysphoria, but once I'd identified the discomfort I felt about my sexed body as gender dysphoria, I found that social dysphoria accumulated, so that I felt crap being perceived as a woman, whereas before I was uncomfortable with my body but had no issues with being perceived as a woman.

When I was transitioning, one of many motivations for me was that I didn't have any strong association with 'womanhood' or 'girlhood'. I kept reading (online) that being a woman involved identifying as a woman, or identifying with womanhood. Reading that, I knew that I wasn't feminine, that I felt very uncomfortable in my female body, and that I had no idea whatsoever what it could even mean to 'identify as' a woman. Taking these three things together, I concluded that I must not identify as a woman, so (by what I assumed to be the definition), I couldn't possibly *be* a woman. Once I'd formed that belief, I had even more reason to resent my female body, which was constantly at risk of 'giving me away' as a woman, which heightened my physical dysphoria (and created a vicious cycle with an eating disorder, body dysmorphia, an exercise addiction, and self-harm). It also gave me reason to resent anyone who assumed my gender (i.e. observed my sex...), which created and heightened my social dysphoria. Heightened social dysphoria made me spend more time trying to avoid looking female, which made me spend more time thinking about my appearance and trying to defeminise myself, which triggered yet more physical dysphoria, which was made even worse when people observed me to be female, and the cycle continued. In retrospect, I can see how self-obsessed/self-destructive/narcissistic/pointless it all was, but at the time it felt crippling, and yet simultaneously like I was fighting the most important feminist battle to be 'seen for who I truly was'.

Gonna copy and past a couple of paragraphs here from a different post on this sub, which have some thought which I guess you might be interested in relating to stereotypes, transition and detransition. They're a bit out of context here, but I'm hoping you might still be able to make sense of them!

'When I IDd as trans, I would actively avoid doing stereotypically feminine things that I would probably have enjoyed, effectively just for the sake of keeping up appearances. I hated the idea of coming across as if I was faking being trans (I had so much insecurity about my gender presentation oh my goodness), to the point where it didn’t even matter if I was with other people or by myself - if something was typed ‘girly’, I felt horrified by the idea of being associated with it, in case it undermined my whole gender facade. Transitioning was a good experience for me in some ways, because it liberated me to do things which were typed ‘masculine’, and to feel like I had a right to do them, but the cost was that I felt unable to do ‘girly’ things - the thought made my skin crawl. Since detransitioning, I have maintained the confidence I developed doing stereotypically masculine things, but I’ve regained my ability to relax and genuinely enjoy things that are more aligned with stereotypes of femininity. I thought that, when I IDd as trans, I had freed myself from gender stereotypes because I was finally doing all the things that women weren’t meant to do. In retrospect, I can see that I was still trapped by sexist stereotypes, because I saw so many of the things that women were meant to do as ‘off-limits’ for me. Now that I’ve abandoned gender identity and gender politics, I barely even think about whether something is ‘girly’ or ‘boyish’ or whatever - I just do it if I want to. The result is that I sometimes enjoy feminine things, and I often enjoy ‘masculine’ things, and whatever I’m doing my sense of self/identity isn’t bothered. Honestly it’s one of the best things about having transitioned and detransitioned.'

'Honestly, all of this just convinces me that transitioning is about the worst thing that gnc people can do if we want to challenge gender stereotypes rather than enforcing them. I understand that some people will want to transition anyway, e.g. because obviously transitioning makes your life easier if the stuff you wanna do is stereotypically only acceptable for the opposite sex. To be honest, I think that's fair enough - nobody should be expected to sacrifice their happiness or safety for abstract feminist principles - but it's become clear to me that it's not the right way forwards if you're serious about wanting to embody feminist principles and/or dismantle the rigid gender norms that hold women back.

It feels like a lot of gnc people, especially lesbian/bi gnc women, face a difficult choice. Our first option is to be visibly gnc AND unapologetically female, to acknowledge that being gnc is a choice that we make because it makes us happy, and to know that anyone who tells us we shouldn't do gender our way is sexist and doesn't deserve our attention. Our second option is to explain away our gender non-conformity using trans identity, and to fit ourselves back into the sexist stereotypes that harm women, by claiming that we reject gender norms prescribed to people of our sex because 'we're men, actually, so we're allowed to perform masculinity - we're just *trans* men!' (or, equivalently, 'I'm actually non-binary, so you shouldn't expect me to be feminine!') At the end of the day, though, it's not true that being a man or being non-binary gives you a right to masculinity which women don't have - it's just that, in our culture, men are rewarded for performing masculinity, whereas women are punished for it. One of my biggest motivations for detransition was realising that, if I chose the first option, I could serve feminism and help break down/subvert the regressive gender stereotype that disproportionately harm women. If I chose the second option, I was effectively admitting that it was okay to correlate masculinity with being male: I was saying that, since I felt comfortable performing many 'masculine'-typed things, I should be a man. Arriving at the belief that I serve feminism better by owning my sex and rejecting gender roles anyway gave me the motivation and confidence I needed to detransition.'

I hope you don't mind the long response! Whatever you decide is best for you, I hope it all works out as you want it to. Don't rush anything, make sure that you understand the full long-term repercussions of any medical decisions you make, and don't let anybody (patriarchy or person!) tell you how you should live your life. Genuinely, I wish you the best xx