This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or a bad-faith actor.
The comments demonstrate a consistent, nuanced, and deeply personal perspective that aligns with a genuine desister/detransitioner. The user shares specific, lived experiences (e.g., PCOS, past binding, the process of re-embracing womanhood) and offers complex, multi-paragraph advice that reflects real emotional insight. The passion and criticism are consistent with someone who has experienced harm.
About me
I started as a confused teenager who found a lot of positive feedback online for identifying as trans. My discomfort with my female body and the pressure of gender roles made it feel like an escape. I took testosterone and identified as a man for a few years before my perspective changed. I realized I didn't need to change my body to be happy and that I am simply a woman. I'm now at peace, living my life without obsessing over gender.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender started when I was a teenager. I was a really insecure kid, and I think I was looking for something solid to build my identity around. Being trans, especially now when there's no gatekeeping, can feel really addictive because you get so much positive feedback from the community when you're first "discovering" yourself. It felt a bit like being love-bombed, almost cult-like, because it promised to fix everything I was unhappy about.
A big part of my discomfort was with my body during puberty. I really hated my breasts. They didn't feel like they belonged to me. I started binding, but I didn't do it for very long because I quickly realized how dangerous it is. I feel terrible for people who bind for years because the damage can be permanent. It's something that shouldn't be normalized the way it is.
I also had a lot of internalized issues. I think a lot of girls, including me, want to be feminine and desirable but feel uncomfortable with the idea of conforming to traditional gender roles. It feels like you're being forced into a box. For me, it felt more freeing to think of myself as a gender nonconforming man rather than a woman who was just not very feminine. It was a way to distance myself from the parts of being a woman that felt oppressive. I was definitely influenced by what I saw online, especially on platforms like Tumblr back in the 2010s.
I started identifying as non-binary first, and then later as a trans man. I took testosterone for a while. But over time, I started to see things differently. I realized that my sex as a female was a biological reality, and my gender identity was something else. I remember when the trans community used to see sex and gender as separate, but that seems to have changed. I began to feel like the community was denying reality, and I saw how detransitioners like me were often ignored or used as political pawns by both sides. That's what really started to push me away.
My detransition wasn't because of politics, though. It was a personal journey. I came to understand that I am a woman. I don't have to do anything special to be one; I just am. I exist. I fill my life with my own goals and values that have nothing to do with my sex. I don't obsess over masculinity or femininity anymore because life is so much bigger than that. You aren't a woman or a man because of how you behave or what you like.
I do have some regrets about my transition, mainly about the time I lost and the mental energy I spent on something that wasn't the real solution. I regret ever binding my chest, even for a short time, because of the risks. I don't regret the journey itself because it led me to where I am now, which is a much more peaceful place. I'm comfortable just being a woman, with all the quirks that come with it, like having PCOS. I'm just a normal woman.
Looking back, I think I was confused and influenced by the people and spaces around me. I needed to find my own way, and I'm glad I finally did.
Here is a timeline of my journey:
Age | Event |
---|---|
14-15 | Started feeling intense discomfort with my body and breasts during puberty. |
16 | Began identifying as non-binary, influenced by online communities. |
17 | Socially transitioned to identifying as a trans man. Started binding my chest (for a short period). |
18 | Started taking testosterone. |
21 | Began questioning my transition, feeling disconnected from the trans community's rhetoric. |
22 | Stopped taking testosterone and began the process of detransitioning. |
23 (Present) | Living comfortably as a woman, with a better understanding of myself and my identity. |
Top Comments by /u/moonmodule1998:
Because it makes them dysphoric and feels invalidating to them.
Imo, this is a totally normal, but not something to be encouraged. My problem is that people encourage this behavior to the point of denying reality and being proud of it. To the point where you can't call a female person female or it's an intentional hate crime. Someone's SEX was never meant to be interpreted this way, I can remember when the trans community was still sane and sex and gender were widely considered two seperate topics...
Insecure people (esp young) want something to latch onto that they can build an identity and purpose around. Something like being trans (which now, anyone can be and theres no gatekeeping for) is even more addictive because there's a lot of positive feedback from other people in that group. I think THAT is what hooks people and why is appears contagious. Esp in the early phases where you're "discovering" your transness. I know this is overplayed but it is cultlike in a way, because cults will also lovebomb the shit out of you at first and promise you everything you've ever wanted.
I agree. I also think it's common because a lot of women/girls WANT to be feminine (which is also associated with desirability) to a degree but they want to distance themselves from conformative feminity, feeling like they're conforming to gender roles, stereotypes, or just a general feeling of being a "traditional girl/woman." This feels like something forced onto them and uncomfortable, and yet they're still attracted to it as well. So to a lot of women it feels mentally more comfortable to be girlish if they can completely divorce themselves from their own womanhood—I'm not a feminine, girly woman conforming to patriarchal gender roles; I'm a gender nonconforming MAN. This feels empowering and freeing rather than submissive. I went through similar feelings myself so I'm very familiar with them, and tbh I think a lot of teen girls do at some point, but now it's socially acceptable to throw away your gender entirely for any reason, so ofc people do so at the drop of a hat.
Its veryyy common to the point where even people within the trans community mock it.
Personally I think they're very confused individuals who aren't trans 99% of the time, but in my experience this is a discussion than could go in circles for weeks.
I'm a woman and I don't do anything special to be a woman nor act like a woman. I simply am and I exist same as anyone else. I fill my time with an even mix of obligations and things I like to do. I try to keep goals and stick to them and live my life according to a general set of values that are unrelated to my sex. I do not obsess over femininity or masculinity because life and existance is much bigger than that. Deep in your heart, this is the mindset you need to have: you are not a woman/man because of how you behave or what you like.
As for feeling/looking feminine, wrt fashion etc., that requires some trial and error. What clothing styles do you like? Have you tried different kinds to make sure? What level/type of feminity are you trying to achieve? Do you have a mall near you? (Really great for quickly trying on different styles) Who are you doing this for, yourself or others? Really going to any clothing store can be a food start... well okay not any, some of them are terrible, but you will figure that out quickly. Online is an option too but beware of scams and that clothes almost never fit right.
Also if you're interested makeup tutorials on youtube are good, but dear god start with the basics, don't freak yourself out with stuff like contouring or "10 step morning makeup routines" if you aren't used to makeup at all. In fact, you never have to do that if you don't want to. There are no hard and fast rules. I'm feminine but I almost never wear makeup at all, I hate makeup lol, but it's an option for people who want it.
Also, if you go for a specific style or dress very feminine please don't beat yourself up feeling like you're feeding into stereotypes of womanhood. Emo, preppy, highly feminine women, etc. aren't making a mockery of women. You ARE a woman doing normal things, it might just not feel that way at first, there will be a dissonance in your head for a while, but over time with practice and self assurance you won't feel awkward anymore. I've gone through that myself, and it's actually normal even for woman who have never transitioned. I do believe the hill will be bigger for you because of your experiences, but I also believe you can walk past it same as anyone else. And if you decide in the end you're just not a very "feminine" person (because really, that can mean different things to different people anyway) that's fine too.
Sorry for the mini essay <3
Well, on tumblr, where a lot of this modern gender discourse started in the 2010s, I remember it was eventually found out a lot of the crazier debates were actually people on 4chan starting drama and infighting on purpose. So, maybe it's really not that out of the question.
So I didn't bind for very long but I will tell you, unfortunately I think the affects of ten years of binding (which, WOW!!) are probably very permanent without some sort of corrective surgery. You might need to discuss that with a Dr.
I'm so sorry. Honestly binding shouldn't be normalized the way it is because it's so dangerous.
As a woman with PCOS honestly it's kind of funny the way some people describe it. It's like they think we all look like we naturally take testosterone. Like, I don't even have high testosterone first of all, T isn't the only androgen in the human body. And the levels aren't even close to "manly high" and I still have a normal level of estrogen. I'm just a normal woman with a few slight quirks really.
Nope and it's a real and serious problem that people aren't talking about. Detransitioners have been co-opted on both sides of the political spectrum. The only people who are paying attention to them want to use them as an example for their own ideology. Realizing this is what actually drove me away from that part of of the trans movement. Treating people's real life stories like they're problems to be disposed of, or claiming they're inherently political propaganda meant to harm your cause, is deplorable.
Seems like an extremely biased and modern take on a very natural and normal experience.
I also find the idea that a woman's body SHOULD be "an enigmatic source of life and allure" to be much more degrading, misogynistic and alienating than a man seeing the true, raw reality of childbirth. This is venturing into woowoo "divine feminine" territory.
Also a lot of weird assumptions about the feelings of the opposite gender that aren't necessarily realistic or helpful.
I do find this funny as a I believe the more patriarchal the society/group the less willing men are to be witness to childbirth. I would sooner make the argument that men who view women as sexual objects want to continue doing so and thus the idea of witnessing a woman giving birth is more unappealing to them. I think that argument is flawed as well, but it honestly makes more sense than this.