genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/ponyclub2008's Detransition Story

male
took hormones
regrets transitioning
depression
puberty discomfort
started as non-binary
anxiety
only transitioned socially
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on this comment history, the account appears authentic.

There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or an inauthentic user. The comments demonstrate:

  • A consistent, nuanced, and personal narrative about a forced detransition and ongoing gender exploration.
  • Self-reflection and emotional depth, including personal struggles and coping mechanisms.
  • A natural variation in topics, from personal experience to philosophical and psychological musings (Jung's anima).
  • A writing style that is conversational, uses personal pronouns, and includes casual asides, which is typical of a human user.

The passion and intellectual engagement displayed are consistent with a genuine desister/detransitioner.

About me

I was born male and never fit the rigid expectations for men, so when I found welcoming online communities, I believed transitioning was my answer. My medical transition was cut short when I had to move to a small town with no access to care and an unsupportive family. Being forced to stop made me realize my urge to become female was strongest when I was depressed or anxious, which felt like a feminine part of me asking for care. I now believe I needed to integrate that softer side and give myself permission to be a sensitive man, rather than change my body. My biggest regret is not questioning that first explanation more deeply and exploring my mental health and social pressures before jumping to transition.

My detransition story

My journey with gender has been complicated and, in the end, was something I never got to fully explore. I was born male, and from a young age, I never felt like I fit the typical idea of what a man should be. I was a sensitive kid and I often felt a deep discomfort with the expectations placed on me. I now believe a lot of my initial feelings were tied to a simple dislike of the rigid roles society has for men, rather than a need to actually be female.

I started to look into transition online. The communities I found were very welcoming and offered a clear, straightforward path to feeling better: you are a woman trapped in a man's body, and medical transition is the solution. At the time, that explanation felt like an answer to all my confusion and pain. It gave a name to my feeling of being an outsider. I began to socially transition, but my medical transition was very short-lived.

My transition was stopped not because I had a sudden realization that it was wrong for me, but because of my life circumstances. I had to move back in with a family member who was completely against any form of transition, and I ended up in a very small town where there was no access to gender-affirming care. I was forced to stop. I never got to take hormones for more than a short period, and I never got to grow my hair out or fully present as female to see how it felt. That lack of closure has been hard. I’m still growing my hair out now, partly just to finally see what that’s like for myself.

Being forced to stop made me think much more deeply about what was really going on with me. I started reading a lot of psychology, especially Carl Jung. His idea of the “Anima” really struck a chord with me. He describes it as the feminine part of the male psyche. I started to notice a pattern: my urges to transition would get really strong when I was completely burnt out, depressed, or anxious. It was during those low times that this more feminine side of me would surface, almost like it was asking for care.

I’ve come to see that instead of trying to become a woman, what I might have needed was to acknowledge and integrate that feminine side. Society tells men they can’t be soft, emotional, or nurturing—that those things are “girly.” But maybe my need wasn't to change my body, but to give myself permission to be a man who is also sensitive, who enjoys self-care like a hot shower, watching a comforting movie, or just being gentle with himself. Those things aren’t inherently female; they’re just human needs that I felt ashamed of having as a man.

I don't know if I regret transitioning because I feel like I never got to truly start it. My biggest regret is probably not questioning the first explanation I was given more deeply. I wish I had explored other reasons for my feelings—like my depression, my anxiety, and the pressure I felt to conform to a masculine ideal I never liked—before jumping to the conclusion that I was trans.

I don't think transition is wrong for everyone, but I do think my story shows why we need way more research and better, unbiased support for people questioning their gender. We need to be able to talk about all the reasons someone might feel this way—like trauma, mental health, or social pressure—without it being a political issue. People should be able to explore every avenue, including therapy that isn’t just about affirmation, to find what’s truly right for them.

Age Event
? Born male.
? Felt early discomfort with male social expectations.
? Found transition communities online; began to socially identify as trans.
? Started a short-lived course of hormones.
? Moved back in with unsupportive family and to a town with no access to care; forced to stop transition.
Present Currently detransitioned and growing hair out to explore personal expression.

Top Comments by /u/ponyclub2008:

5 comments • Posting since May 21, 2025
Reddit user ponyclub2008 (detrans male) explains that the search to be "man enough" is a futile quest, arguing that true self-acceptance is the only way to appreciate one's unique self.
50 pointsJun 2, 2025
View on Reddit

What does “man enough” actually mean?

Maybe a better question to ask is what does “enough” actually mean? Because I think we both know that enough is never enough no matter what it is. Acceptance is the only way to appreciate the unique aspects of yourself. The only boxes we need to fit into are the ones we create for ourselves. Maybe the truth is you don’t need to be man enough you just need to be you. Maybe the world just needs “you.” As simple as that is.

Reddit user ponyclub2008 (detrans male) comments on the lack of unbiased research into transition and detransition rates due to the subject's political sensitivity and fear of backlash.
13 pointsMay 21, 2025
View on Reddit

It bothers me so much that people will not touch the subject because of potential backlash. I think transition/detransition needs to be studied way more but because of how political and touchy the subject is for so many people it’s hard to get unbiased data.

Reddit user ponyclub2008 (detrans male) explains how Carl Jung's concept of the "Anima" helped him integrate his feminine urges through self-care instead of transitioning.
5 pointsJun 15, 2025
View on Reddit

I’ve been reading a lot of Carl Jung lately who talks about the “Amina” which is like this female part of the male psyche. It is the personification of all feminine psychological tendencies in a man’s psyche.

Personally I started to notice that the urges to transition happen a lot for me when I’m burnt out. My more feminine nature starts to bubble up to the surface when I’m exhausted and worn out. Meaning I recognize usually that I need to slow down and do self care, take a hot shower, take a break for exercise and diet and routine and just allow myself to be comfy, maybe watch a movie and hang out with my dog. Do “girly” things for myself. By girly I just mean things society tends to view as more feminine. Things that traditionally sometimes aren’t seen as “appropriate” for masculine people to do.

Anyways this revelation from Jung has me thinking that maybe instead of having to “say goodbye” to the girl identity maybe there is a way to integrate it within the Psyche. Maybe instead of transitioning we just need to recognize the unconscious nature of the “anima” and try to realize that it has its own needs and desires.

Reddit user ponyclub2008 (detrans male) comments on the lack of research into gender transition and detransition, noting early studies were destroyed by Nazis and modern research is difficult to conduct.
3 pointsMay 21, 2025
View on Reddit

Quality information brings us closer to the truth. Which can really help inform the way patients with gender dysphoria are treated before transition, during, or in some cases after detransition.

There’s still so much we don’t know.

There’s maybe been less then a century of hard core research on gender and transition, much of the early research destroyed by nazis, and currently because of the stuff you mentioned it can be incredibly difficult to study accurately today.

Hopefully that changes.

Reddit user ponyclub2008 (detrans male) explains his detransition was not a choice, but was forced by moving to a small town without gender-affirming care and living with a family member opposed to his transition. He wonders if his persistent dysphoria stems from never being able to fully explore his gender identity or even grow his hair out.
3 pointsJun 7, 2025
View on Reddit

I guess the thing about my choice to detransition is that it wasn’t really a choice. I was forced to stop transitioning for my own safety, because I moved to a small town without any gender affirming care, and because I had to move back in with a family member who is VERY against me transitioning.

So I wonder if a part of the persistent feelings is because I never got to fully explore my gender identity or fully transition in the first place. I never even got to grow my hair out to see what that is like. One of the reasons I guess I’m still trying to grow it out.