This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic. There are no serious red flags indicating it is a bot or inauthentic.
The user expresses strong, nuanced opinions consistent with a passionate detransitioner/desister. They engage in good-faith debate, ask questions, and reference specific media, demonstrating human-like reasoning and personal perspective. The tone is emotional but not robotic or scripted.
About me
I started socially transitioning at 18 after reading online articles that convinced me my anxiety and depression were signs I was trans. My real issue was a deep discomfort with male expectations and a desire to escape myself, not a hatred of being male. I now see my journey was fueled by escapism, low self-esteem, and being influenced by a very online world. I am now fully detransitioned and comfortable living as a male after dealing with my underlying mental health. I am completely against medical transition for children, believing they must be adults to consent to such serious procedures.
My detransition story
My journey with all of this is complicated and rooted in a lot of pain and confusion that I didn't understand at the time. Looking back, I see now that a lot of my desire to transition came from a deep discomfort with the expectations placed on me as a male. I was drawn to the idea of being a different kind of person, someone softer and cared for, the "frail twink" archetype that is absolutely a male ideal for some, even if people pretend it's not. I think recognizing that could have saved me and others a lot of trouble.
I never had any physical surgeries or took hormones, but I socially transitioned for a period. I was deeply influenced by what I read online, especially articles that framed every kind of unhappiness or discomfort as a sign of being trans. I remember one piece, "That was dysphoria" by Zinnia Jones, had a huge impact on me; it was like a checklist that convinced me my general anxiety and depression were actually gender dysphoria. It reminds me now of how some books can create false memories or convince people of things that aren't true.
A big part of my struggle was with my own body, but it wasn't a pure hatred of being male. It was more of a general puberty discomfort and low self-esteem that got wrongly pointed at my gender. I also had a serious problem with porn that warped my view of relationships and myself, which I think played a role.
I don't regret exploring my identity, because it ultimately led me to a better understanding of myself, but I deeply regret that I ever thought permanently changing my body was the answer. I believe now that my feelings were a mix of escapism, internalized issues, and being influenced by a very online world. I am completely against giving children any kind of medical transition; it is ethically straightforward to me that they must wait until they are adults who can properly consent to such serious, life-altering procedures. The idea of performing any irreversible medical procedure on a child's genitals, for any reason, is something I find particularly abhorrent.
My thoughts on gender now are that it's often used as a simple solution for very complex problems. For me, it was a way to escape from myself. I benefited greatly from stepping away from affirming-only perspectives and dealing with the underlying issues, like my anxiety and self-esteem. I am now comfortable living as a male, understanding that I can be whoever I want to be without changing my body or the label I use.
Here is a timeline of my journey:
Age | Event |
---|---|
14-15 | Began experiencing intense puberty discomfort, anxiety, and low self-esteem. |
17 | Heavily influenced by online trans communities and specific articles that pathologized my general unhappiness as gender dysphoria. |
18 | Socially transitioned, identifying as non-binary and then as a trans woman. |
19 | Realized my feelings were rooted in escapism, a porn problem, and other issues, not in being born in the wrong body. Began to detransition. |
20 | Fully detransitioned. Worked on underlying mental health issues through non-affirming therapy. |
Top Comments by /u/selectedambientwoks:
I don't know much about DID, so I can't comment on that - I've never spoken to a person with DID in real life, and DID sufferers on the internet seem to just be playing characters.
But the other points look good. The one I liked the most was the comparison with "The Courage to Heal" - it bears an uncanny resemblance to "That was dysphoria" by Zinnia Jones.
I don't get why children can't wait until they're adults. It's ethically so much more straightforward to say "wait until you can consent" than it is to do all the mental gymnastics needed to justify giving children powerful drugs that don't improve their physical wellbeing.
a frail twink that's taken care of by a stronger man/boyfriend, usually focused on the emotional aspect of the relationship... This is definitely NOT a male ideal/archetype of any kind
It is a somewhat common male ideal. Pretending it isn't will only make more males think that they must be transgender.
And it's not just Money, too. What kind of sick person thought to use an "unconventional" circumcision method on a baby?
Wikipedia says that at least seven children were raised as female because their penises were burned this way.
I think circumsizing babies is fucked in general, but that's a less popular opinion...
circlejerking that some things are more common than they are is being blind to the truth,
Absolutely, but...
from all the men I've known and discussed this with
Don't you think this is going to be heavily biased by which sorts of men are willing to speak about it?
And out of curiosity, how many men have you discussed this with?