This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious
Based on the provided comments, the account appears authentic.
There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or an inauthentic actor. The comments demonstrate:
- Consistent, nuanced viewpoints on gender, identity, and medical intervention.
- Personal experience (e.g., with birth control).
- A natural, conversational tone with varied sentence structures and personal anecdotes.
The user's passion and criticism of certain trans-related ideas align with the expected perspective of a genuine desister or detransitioner.
About me
My journey started as a teenager when I felt a deep discomfort with my female body, especially when I developed breasts. I found an answer online, thinking I must not be a girl, and I eventually took testosterone and had top surgery. But the hormones worsened my mental health, and the surgery left me with permanent physical and emotional scars. I finally realized my problem wasn't with being female, but with the stereotypes and limitations society places on women. Now, after stepping away from that online world, I'm learning to accept my body and have found peace by just being myself.
My detransition story
My whole journey with gender started when I was a teenager. I was deeply uncomfortable with my body when I hit puberty; I hated the changes and I especially hated developing breasts. I felt like my body was betraying me. At the same time, I was struggling with depression and really low self-esteem. I spent a huge amount of time online, and that’s where I first learned about being transgender and non-binary. It felt like an answer. I thought, maybe I’m not a girl. Maybe that’s why I feel so awful.
I started identifying as non-binary. It felt like a way to escape the pressure of being a woman. I felt like society had all these rules for how I should act and look, and saying I wasn't a girl felt like a way to break free from that. Looking back, I think a lot of it was internalized misogyny. I saw the stereotypes about women being weak or less than, and I wanted no part of it. I thought that to be strong and respected, I couldn't be a woman. I was influenced a lot by what I saw online and by friends in similar communities. We all kind of reinforced each other's feelings.
I eventually moved from identifying as non-binary to wanting to fully transition to male. I started testosterone. I was told it would solve my problems and make me feel at home in my body. But messing with my hormones was not a joke. I had a terrible experience with birth control in the past—it made me gain weight, killed my libido, and made me severely depressed—so I should have been more cautious. On testosterone, some of those feelings came back. My mental health didn't magically get better. I also started to see the changes, like a lower voice and facial hair, as permanent and serious, not the simple solution I had imagined.
I got top surgery. I thought it would finally fix the discomfort I had with my breasts. And for a while, it did feel like a relief. But it was a major surgery, and it left me with scars, both physical and emotional. I am now infertile, which is something I didn't fully process the weight of at the time.
My turning point came when I finally stepped back from the online world. I unplugged and just tried to live. I listened to music I liked, wore clothes I found comfortable, and got into hobbies like painting and DIY projects. I stopped trying to label everything I did. I realized that my problem wasn't with being a woman; it was with the box society tries to put women in. I started to see amazing women everywhere—leaders, inventors, friends—who were breaking stereotypes just by being themselves.
I came to understand that being a woman isn't a prison sentence. I don’t regret my journey because it led me to this understanding, but I do have profound regrets about the permanent changes I made to my body. I regret that I wasn't encouraged to explore my discomfort with puberty and society's expectations in a different way. I wish someone had been real with me about the seriousness of hormones and surgery instead of just affirming me. I benefited from therapy that wasn't just about affirming a transgender identity, but about digging into my depression, low self-esteem, and the reasons I wanted to escape my body in the first place.
Now, I see gender as a social construct with too many rigid rules. Why can't people just be people? I believe my discomfort was a mix of normal puberty awkwardness, body dysmorphia, and societal pressure. I'm learning to accept my body as it is now, with its scars and its history.
Age | Event |
---|---|
13 | Started puberty. Felt intense discomfort with my body, hated developing breasts. |
15 | Spent a lot of time online. Discovered non-binary and trans identities. Began identifying as non-binary. |
17 | Started testosterone therapy. |
18 | Underwent top surgery (double mastectomy). |
19 | Stopped testosterone. Began the process of detransition. |
20 | Started therapy focused on underlying depression and self-esteem, not gender affirmation. |
Top Comments by /u/soundsfromoutside:
No one takes me seriously when I talk about how awful BC effected me to the point where I refuse to take it now. I gained so much weight, I broke out, I lost my sexual libido and when I forced myself to have sex I would be drier than the Sahara, and to make matters worse I got terribly depressed. Messing with your hormones is not a joke.
(Not to scare anyone, i know plenty of women who had the complete opposite experience when they took BC)
What even is identity?
I know it’s hard but get off the internet, unplug for a bit (or just use the internet for a certain amount of time a day) and just live. Listen to whatever music you feel like listening to, read whatever books you want to read, wear whatever makes you comfortable, be friends with people who you get along with. Get into a hobby like exercising, baking, painting, DIY projects, anything that keeps your hands busy.
Why smack a label on everything you do or follow rules as to what you can do and what you can’t do? The less you stress about who you should be, the more the true you comes out.
I watch Kalvan Garrah and he’s got some pretty good points in top of being hilarious. He calls out trenders and predators using the trans movement to push their own agenda. He also talks to other trans people and detrans peeps.
He can definitely be an asshole but, honestly, it’s refreshing to see someone just lay it out there without apologizing for every little remark they make.
I feel like the emergence of “non-binary” is, in a way, reviving the old Puritan beliefs that women and men need to act a certain way. Women need to be meek, love children, nurturing and men need to be burly, tough, and stoic. Why can’t people just be people?
Not a parent but I was one of those “do it because they said I can’t” type of kids.
Support her. Don’t go crazy and put her on medication but let her cut her hair, say she looks good, go boy clothes shopping with her. Don’t freak out on her, don’t lecture her on anything, but when she asks about the serious part of transitioning, explain that it’s a long process of therapy. Be real about the changes her body will go through, even if the topic is uncomfortable, if she were to take puberty blockers or T (low voice that might never go away, facial and chest stubble, temperament issues, enlarged clit, etc). Be real and say it’s not a trend and that people who actually have gender dysphoria need that doctors time and those medications more than she does but never flat out say ‘no’ to her.
Good luck.
Being a woman isn’t a prison sentence if you don’t let it be so. Women have come a long way from being categorized as chattel, to servants, to what we are now: workers, leaders, inventors, organizers, helpers, friends, and equal. There are so many women proving gross stereotypes wrong every single day.
Society told you to be ashamed. Fuck society. Be a woman and be a damn good one.