genderaffirming.ai 

Reddit user /u/tumblinweeds's Detransition Story

Transitioned: 19 -> Detransitioned: 35
female
took hormones
regrets transitioning
got top surgery
body dysmorphia
retransition
puberty discomfort
doesn't regret transitioning
This story is from the comments listed below, summarised by AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, our AI gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Authenticity Assessment: Not Suspicious

Based on the provided comments, this account appears to be authentic. There are no serious red flags suggesting it is a bot or inauthentic.

The user demonstrates deep personal insight, nuanced understanding of complex issues, and a consistent, evolving narrative of their long-term experience with transition and subsequent questioning. The language is natural, emotionally varied, and shows critical self-reflection over time, which is not typical of bot behavior. The account fits the profile of a detransitioner/desister who is critically re-evaluating their transition while continuing to use HRT.

About me

I'm a masculine female who started transitioning in my late teens because I felt like a freak and thought I had a male brain. Transitioning solved my social problems and felt like it saved my life. Now I realize my reasons were more complicated and rooted in escaping the pressure I felt for being different. I tried to go off testosterone but became so miserable I had to go back on it. I live as a man now, but I'm left confused and grappling with the what-ifs of my past.

My detransition story

My whole journey with gender started when I was a teenager. I was always gender non-conforming from a young age and felt a deep sense of discomfort when puberty hit. I felt alien in my own skin and in the world. The only explanation I found back then was that I must be trans, that I had a male brain in a female body. I held onto that belief for a very long time.

Socially, it was incredibly hard before I transitioned. I was harassed for trying to use the women's bathroom because of how I looked. I felt like I was constantly doing something wrong and was treated like a freak. I tried my absolute best to fit in as a girl. I tried wearing girls' clothes and it felt awful. The only women I saw who were as gender non-conforming as me were lesbians, so I even tried to force myself to have crushes on girls, but it just didn't work for me. I was miserable and honestly didn't think I would make it to 30.

Transitioning felt like a lifesaver. I started testosterone and had top surgery. My quality of life improved dramatically. Once I started passing as a male, all those social problems just melted away. I could finally get on with my life. I even tracked the changes from my weekly testosterone shots, like how my singing voice would drop two days after a shot and then lighten up a bit just before the next one.

But my thinking about all of this has completely changed. The foundation I built my life on crumbled. I used to believe in those studies that said trans people have brain structures matching their gender identity, but those have been discredited. Without that, I’ve had to completely re-evaluate my experiences.

I’ve come to realize that my reasons for transitioning were more complicated. A lot of it was about escaping the social pressure and stigma I faced for being a masculine female. It was a solution to a social problem. I’ve also learned from being in this community that there are many different causes for gender dysphoria and body dysmorphia, and being trans is only one of them. Things like a history of trauma, eating disorders, OCD, and autism can play a huge role in latching onto transition as a solution. I tell people now that if they have serious doubts or other mental health concerns, they should work through those first before starting any medical interventions.

I tried to medically detransition once. I quit testosterone for several months, but it made me so miserable that I had to go back on it. At this point, upending my life again doesn't make sense for me. Socially, I operate as male. Historically and chromosomally, I'm female. Physically, I'm somewhere in the middle. Mentally, I'm just confused. I'm left with so many "what ifs." What if it wasn't inevitable? What if I could have learned to be happy as that person instead of changing my body?

I don't have major regrets about my transition because it did save my life and give me a life worth living. But I do regret not having a better understanding of all the different factors at play. I regret that I didn't explore my feelings of dysphoria more deeply without starting from the assumption that "I am trans." I wish I had known that it's okay to just be a woman with masculine interests, that you don't have to suppress parts of your personality to fit an idea of what a man should be.

Now, I just see myself as a person, floating in the middle, trying to make sense of it all.

Age Event
Teenager Felt severe discomfort at puberty, was gender non-conforming.
Late Teens Came out as trans and began identifying as male.
Early 20s Started testosterone (T) hormone therapy.
Mid 20s Underwent top surgery.
35 (approx.) Quit testosterone for several months in an attempt to detransition medically.
35 (approx.) Resumed testosterone after becoming miserable off it.
Present (late 30s) Live socially as male, but am confused about my identity and grappling with the "what ifs."

Top Comments by /u/tumblinweeds:

5 comments • Posting since February 1, 2020
Reddit user tumblinweeds advises a person questioning their gender transition to confide in close friends about their doubts and embarrassment, arguing that open dialogue provides support and prevents future surprises.
9 pointsFeb 27, 2020
View on Reddit

Why don’t you tell your close friends that you’re questioning and having some doubts? If you’re embarrassed, you can tell them you’re embarrassed. this is how I approach feeling embarrassed and it cuts way down on my worries about what other people think about it. Embarrassment is a feeling everyone has. Pretending you’re feeling confident is for meetings and job interviews, not for friendships.

If you tell them you’re feeling confused then it won’t be a sudden switch from “100% sure” you want to transition to “100% sure” you don’t. It will probably make you feel better to have them on your team while you’re trying to work through all of this, instead of trying to work it out in isolation. Talking to them about their thoughts and feelings on gender in open dialogue might surprise you with perspectives you never considered. And that way no matter what you decide, they won’t be surprised about your choice.

Reddit user tumblinweeds explains that a voice will likely not continue to drop after stopping testosterone, based on their experience with weekly shots. They detail how their voice lowers to its deepest point two days after an injection and then lightens slightly by day six, suggesting the post-shot T spikes are responsible for permanent changes.
9 pointsFeb 1, 2020
View on Reddit

Based on personal experience i think it will not keep dropping. With a weekly shot, my voice drops to its lowest about two days after the shot. Not generally noticeable in conversation, but I can definitely track it in my singing range. Then I might lose the lowest two notes of my range (and gain two notes in my upper range) by day 6. Over many doses, the whole voice drops. But at this point you have less and less T in your system every day. My subjective experience is that it’s those spikes right after the shot that seem to do the lowering work, so my guess is that your voice has dropped as low as it will and is already lightening up.

Reddit user tumblinweeds comments on a detransitioner's regret, offering support and hope after only 7 months on testosterone.
7 pointsFeb 1, 2020
View on Reddit

There are always worse mistakes. :) it’s great you realized after only seven months on T. Try not to be too hard on yourself if you can help it. You have the opportunity to connect with yourself on a whole different level now, even if it’s hard and scary and painful in the process. Wishing you all the best.

Reddit user tumblinweeds (questioning own gender transition) explains their struggle with identity after the science supporting their transition was discredited, detailing their social alienation as a GNC female, the relief found in passing as male, and the current conflict between a successful physical transition and a dismantled ideological framework.
3 pointsOct 1, 2020
View on Reddit

This resonates so much with me. I have a very typical trans narrative too, always gender nonconforming from a young age, dysphoria at puberty, definite improvement to my quality of life through transition. When I was first coming out/identifying as trans in my teens I believed an oft-cited study about trans people having brain structures more similar to their gender ID than others of their birth sex. I thought I must have a male brain in a female body—it was the only explanation I'd found for how alien I felt in the world. But those studies claiming material differences between "male" and "female" brains have since been discredited. And without that, I've been struggling to make sense of my experiences.

I faced so much social pressure and stigma from a young age. I was harassed going into female public bathrooms. It was constantly made clear that I was doing something "wrong," and after coming out as trans I used to joke that I had tried my best but failed at being female. I tried wearing girls' clothes and felt so, so uncomfortable. The only women I saw who were anywhere near as GNC as me were lesbians, so I tried to cultivate crushes on girls, which didn't work at all. When I dressed and acted the way I wanted, I got treated like a freak—even though I knew I was smart, and funny, and a worthwhile person, I was always stuck on the outside looking in. And lo and behold, once I reached the point of transition where I passed as a cis male, those social problems melted away and I was able to get on with my life just fine.

Before I transitioned I was so miserable I thought I wouldn't be able to make it to 30. Now I have a lot to live for, but the reasoning I built my life choices around has crumbled under my feet. After much reading of this subreddit, conversations, and consideration, I've decided I can't see detransitioning and upending my life again—to what end? I tried quitting HRT for several months to medically detransition but it made me miserable, so I went back on. Having my mental framework shift drastically after 15 years is hard to grapple with. I'm not even sure whether to think of myself or male or female. After all socially I operate as male, historically/chromosomally I'm female, and physically I'm floating somewhere in the middle. Mentally I'm...confused. Those big "what ifs" are everywhere. What if it wasn't inevitable? What if, as OP says, I could have learned to be happy as that person instead?

Reddit user tumblinweeds explains why those questioning their gender should explore mental health, dysphoria causes, and personal interests before considering medical transition.
3 pointsFeb 1, 2020
View on Reddit

I’m trans. Answering based on my experiences and on and talking to people in this community.

-first: if you have serious doubts, don’t start medical interventions. They will always be an option later and it’s not a race.

-if you have other mental health concerns, work through them and try to get to a stable place before making a decision. Especially OCD and any personality disorders, history of eating disorders, trauma history etc. seem to play a role in attaching to transition as a “solution.” Autism can also play a role. this is all based on my reading of others’ posts here, not personal experience. Explore more and try to talk to actual detrans folks if any of this resonates.

-the main thing I’ve learned from this community is: there are different causes of gender dysphoria and body dysmorphia. Being trans is one cause, but not the only one. It’s great you’re in therapy. If you can, in your sessions don’t start with “i am trans” and work backwards from there. Focus on your feelings of dysphoria and explore the different potential causes and solutions. Maybe some practices borrowed from eating disorder treatments would help you with body dysmorphia, for example. Even if you end up transitioning you will almost certainly still struggle with some dysphoria and dysmorphia (I do) so tools to deal with that will be helpful regardless.

-you don’t have to go by your birth name forever. I have a friend who goes by a typically male name just because. It confuses people sometimes (they sometimes ask if she’s trans) but who cares?

-You said that as a kid you suppressed some interests because they didn’t match with wanting to be a boy. There is a very mixed-up narrative that sometimes bubbles up in trans communities when we focus too much on “passing.” But being trans is not about suppressing parts of your personality. And that kind of suppression is not an easy path towards a satisfying life. Explore your interests, even if they seem “femme” or embarrassing. You don’t have to tell anyone, just honestly explore what you like to do in private. Maybe let yourself do the stuff you held back on as a kid. Every person—trans or cis—has a mix of feminine and masculine interests and traits. If you are considering transition as a way to excise the feminine parts of yourself, you should explore why you feel that’s necessary.

Hope some is this is helpful. And good luck, whatever you end up deciding.