do detrans people see transition as having an end point or as an ongoing process?
Questions and answers for people who are questioning their gender identity.
The truth is that gender non-conformity will set us all free!
More questions related to "do detrans people see transition as having an end point or as an ongoing process?"
Featured Questions
The best questions to ask detrans people...
->
What does trans mean?
->
Have trans people always existed?
->
What is the difference between sex and gender?
->
Why do some people decide to detransition?
->
Is it common for detransitioners to regret transitioning?
->
Why do some people decide to retransition after detransitioning?
->
Why do trans narratives about why people detransition and retransition differ from those who have actually detransitioned?
->
What can detrans stories teach me, even if my transition is going well so far?
->
How would I know if doubts are just nerves or a sign that I should stop?
->
Do detrans people think transition itself is bad?
->
What are some false claims made about transgender people?
->
What are some false claims made about people who have detransitioned?
->
What early signs do detrans folks wish they’d noticed sooner?
->
Is gender a social construct? What does this mean?
->
How have feminist movements historically viewed the concept of gender?
->
Can gender-nonconformity reduce the pressure to conform to gender roles?
->
How do detrans people describe the feeling of being ‘born in the wrong body’?
->
What is gender-affirming care and what are its goals?
->
What is gender-exploratory therapy, how does it differ from gender-affirming care?
->
Why is gender-affirming care usually the only available treatment for gender dysphoria in most regions?
->
Why do some people hate the idea of gender-exploratory therapy?
->
What are puberty blockers and do they really pause puberty? Can they cause infertility or other side-effects?
->
Do detransitioners usually regret medical steps, social steps, or both?
->
What does the term ‘egg’ mean in trans communities?
->
What is an identity trap and how do people typically realise they are in one?
->
How can friends or family support someone who wants to start hormones?
->
Where can someone look for a therapist who offers open-ended, non-directive gender exploration? What red-flags should I look out for?
->
When does asking for pronouns help versus hinder gender-nonconforming people?
->
If a young girl with short hair is constantly being asked for her pronouns, what is the implication and how would this make her feel?
->
How do non-binary labels reinforce traditional gender stereotypes?
->
What is cancel culture and what effects does it have on public health discourse?
->
Do detrans people see transition as having an end-point or as an ongoing process?
->
Why might some adolescent girls experience distress about breast development?
->
How can online echo-chambers influence identity formation?
->
Why do detransitioners often report feeling like their stories and voices are silenced in both trans and mainstream spaces?
->
What demographic patterns are visible in referrals to gender clinics?
->
How do contemporary queer identities differ from the earlier LGB movement?
->
What does current research say about overlap between autism spectrum traits, gender dysphoria, and transgender identities?
->
What evidence standards exist for gender-affirming medical protocols?
->
Why is gender dysphoria no longer classified as a mental disorder in the DSM-5?
->
How has trans prevalence changed in recent times and what might explain this?
General Terms
Understanding the fundamental concepts
->
What is a man?
->
What is a woman?
->
What is gender?
->
What are pronouns and why are they significant to some?
->
What do trans people mean when they talk about 'trans rights'?
->
Why do some trans people say 'death before detransition'?
->
What is cancel culture?
->
What is gender dysphoria?
->
What factors are thought to cause dysphoria?
->
What is the 'gender dysphoria bible'?
->
What strategies (medical or non-medical) help people manage dysphoria?
->
What is transgender identity?
->
What is transphobia?
->
What is non-binary identity?
->
What is queer identity?
->
How is personality different from gender identity?
->
What is gender non-conformity (GNC)?
->
What is gender conformity?
->
What is detransitioning?
->
What is desisting?
->
Are intersex people automatically trans?
->
What is gender fluidity?
->
What do AFAB and AMAB mean?
->
What is a TERF?
->
What is deadnaming?
->
What is misgendering?
->
What is a cisgender person?
->
What is meant by biological sex?
->
What is the difference between social and medical transition?
The Medical Reality
Health, procedures, and biological truths
->
What physiological changes can hormones induce and what are their limits?
->
What is vaginal atrophy?
->
What are the documented health risks of gender-affirming hormone therapy?
->
How should someone weigh continuing versus discontinuing hormones?
->
What does vaginoplasty entail and what are typical outcomes?
->
What does phalloplasty entail and what are typical outcomes?
->
What surgical revision options exist for either vaginoplasty or phalloplasty?
->
How do different countries regulate public funding for gender surgeries?
->
What options exist for chest reconstruction after mastectomy?
->
What evidence exists for the timing of hormone initiation relative to mental-health assessment?
->
What does ‘puberty blocker’ mean and what is known about reversibility?
->
What long-term follow-up data exist for cross-sex hormone use?
->
What are the WPATH Standards of Care and how are they developed?
->
What is the Dutch Protocol?
->
What is rapid-onset gender dysphoria (ROGD) and how is it studied?
->
What are reported regret rates for various gender surgeries?
->
What does gender-exploratory therapy look like in practice?
Society & Culture
How gender beleif systems affects us all
->
Are there measurable differences in referral rates between males and females?
->
How is gender dysphoria distinguished from mental illness in diagnostic manuals?
->
What explanations exist for elevated suicide risk in trans populations?
->
What does ‘gender-critical’ mean and how does it differ from trans-exclusionary views?
->
How do online mantras or slogans affect critical thinking in any identity community?
->
How has the concept of gender evolved historically?
->
What does brain-imaging research say about ‘male’ versus ‘female’ brains?
->
Why might autistic people be over-represented in gender clinics?
->
How does contemporary gender discourse intersect with gay and lesbian identities?
->
What are documented outcomes for children who socially transition early?
->
How has trans activism interacted with earlier gay-rights activism?
->
Is the rise in non-binary identification a cohort effect, a fashion, or something else?
->
What is the ‘bathroom debate’ and what evidence exists for either harm or safety?
->
What are the main arguments in the sports-participation controversy?
->
How have schools handled gender-questioning pupils in different jurisdictions?
->
What do detrans people think about drag queen story telling?
->
What does ‘medicalisation of gender non-conforming children’ mean to critics and to advocates?
Psychology & Identity
Understanding the mental and emotional aspects
->
What is the neurochemical cycle of validation?
->
What is internalised misogyny and how might it relate to body distress?
->
What is internalised homophobia?
->
What is autogynephilia and how is it debated in the literature?
->
What is gender euphoria?
->
Can adopting a trans identity amplify dysphoria instead of relieving it?
->
Why is external validation important to some trans people?
->
What is the difference between body-dysmorphic disorder and gender dysphoria?
->
What role does social-media play in people adopting gender identities?
->
How might trauma histories interact with gender dysphoria?
->
Can someone be a woman without being feminine, or a man without being masculine?
->
What non-medical options exist for managing dysphoria?
->
What does ‘passing’ mean and why can it become an obsession for some people?
->
How do Jungian concepts of anima/animus relate to gender identity?
->
What is shadow work and can it be used in therapy?
The Detransition Journey
Healing, support, and finding your way back
->
Does detransition mean the original transition was a failure?
->
How can transition and detransition both be part of the same healing arc?
->
What parallels do clinicians draw between gender dysphoria and eating disorders?
->
Where can someone find therapists experienced in detransition support?
->
What evidence exists for the effectiveness of CBT or DBT in managing dysphoria?
->
How can someone grieve and accept body changes they no longer want?
->
Why do some trans communities discourage reading detransition narratives?
->
What support groups exist specifically for detransitioners?
->
How can someone come out (again) to family as detransitioning?
->
What are common stages of grief reported during detransition?
->
What role have psychedelic drugs played in some detrans stories?
Academic & Research Bias
Questioning the narrative in institutions
->
What methodological concerns have been raised about major detransition surveys?
->
Why do researchers report difficulty securing funding for detransition studies?
->
Do researchers who currently identify as trans have a conflict of interest?
->
What was the Cass Review and what recommendations did it produce?
->
What happened to Lisa Littman’s 2018 study on ROGD?
->
What is the Tavistock clinic review and why was it commissioned?
->
How was gender dysphoria re-classified between DSM-IV and DSM-5?
Controversial Perspectives
Detrans perspectives that gender activists really don't want you to hear
->
Are some people making a lot of money out of gender-affirming care?
->
What structural factors lead to under-representation of detransition stories in mainstream media?
->
In what ways do gender belief systems resemble religions or cults?
->
Are schools sidelining parents when children make choices about gender identity?